LoughboroBlade
Well-Known Member
I hope he he can be the player we know he can be but I just have a nagging Holmes / carruthers feeling to it.
That thought has also crossed my mind. I’ve said it before, but we’ve tried that position repeatedly with others that we thought had the attributes to do the role Duffy does, and it’s repeatedly not really worked out. McGoldrick is probably the best alternative we’ve had there, probably followed by Dowell. Brooks looked a bit lost there rather than playing off Clarke. Carruthers had flickers of promise in League 1 that disappeared rapidly once we were promoted. Holmes similarly failed to step up, while Woodburn never adjusted and was even worse in other positions he played in off the bench.
I think ultimately we’ll have to adjust our game in the same way as we did when Norwood filled the Coutts gap. He was never going to do exactly the same role, and perhaps the ultimate solution will be not to find someone to replicate Duffy’s contribution, but to evolve it.