Referee

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?


Would have to watch the MGW back again but if that’s a booking then why not all the minimum contacts that we see when defenders are trying to shield the ball and go down.

Either book all of the fuckers or none of them you incompetent set of twats.

The one on Ndiaye second half was an absolute joke. The defender with both arms outstretched pushed him over. You would have to be blind not to give that
 
Was a fucking dive though. Great player but needs to cut that shit out.
 
Keith Stroud has a new competitor from the looks of that tonight. Absolutely inept and guessing at most decisions. Complete fraud.
 
wak1889 said:
If mcgoldrick does his job we win regardless of the ref , another 1 on 1 clean through and can't finish then misses an open goal from 2 yards that was actually easier to score than miss
Click to expand...
True, but if the referee does his job as well then there’s every chance we have a different outcome. 11 v 11 there’s only one team trying to win the game
 
Even if the ref felt MGW had dived what was he doing giving the first yellow for an innocuous tackle out on the wing in the first half. Wall had repeatedly roughed up our players before this yet not a word or card .MGW puts his first tackle in and gets carded. It seems the ref was desperate to find fault with MGW and no-one else. It changed the game but if Mcg who had a shocker tonight had put away his two easy chances the sending off would have made no difference to the result.
 
djbaldken said:
I ve been trying really hard to think of a worse display from a referee.

I can't.

He was appalling.

His next match should be a Sunday league match on Herringthorpe playing fields.
There is no excuse for being that bad.
Click to expand...
Some decent games at heringthorpe. Don’t let that useless fucker ref one and spoil it
 
CPB said:
It's debatable as to whether you could say Gibbs white dived. It looked to me like a foul but had he gone down a bit threatically?
However you'd like to see players given some benefit (that they aren't diving) unless its really obvious.
I mean Bogle went down easier to try and buy a pen in 1st half and that wasn't a booking so why it's different for mgw?
I can only assume because mgw went off at ref in 1st half when he got what did look like an actual booking?

After this and then a few more decisions including not giving saville a 2nd booking the ref completely lost it.
His head was gone and for both teams I felt he was giving random decisions.

The standard of reffing at this level is atrocious. And you don't realise until you've been in the PL for two seasons just how bad it is.

We were awful first half until a few mins before we scored. 2nd half we were all over them until sending off and then I felt it was pretty even and we actually looked the more threatening until they scored.
Those 10 players did well and were unlucky.
Click to expand...
We were on the kop close to where MGW got booked first half. It wasn’t even a foul. He just touched the ball first. That’s why he and everyone in close proximity were up in arms about the decision. I had the wrong angle on the 2nd booking so will leave that to others with better views
 
Mgw sweats blind theres contact, but the replays do him no favors at all. Slightly more cringe than Bogle in the first half, who didn't get booked. Too early in game?
 
Was the worst ref since Blackburn at home in our promotion season. Probably actually worse than him overall. Definitely the sort of game you see refs demoted for but I imagine they'll just put it down to a bad day at the office and let him carry on.
 
Roygbiv said:
Was the worst ref since Blackburn at home in our promotion season. Probably actually worse than him overall. Definitely the sort of game you see refs demoted for but I imagine they'll just put it down to a bad day at the office and let him carry on.
Click to expand...
Anthony Taylor was the premier league referee that day when he stepped down a league and went all Billy big bollocks and sent Bash off for the ball hitting his arm at a free kick?
 

spongebobblade said:
Anthony Taylor was the premier league referee that day when he stepped down a league and went all Billy big bollocks and sent Bash off for the ball hitting his arm at a free kick?
Click to expand...


That's him. Todays made more laughable decisions I think. I'm struggling to think of a worse one but surely there will have been
 
Pitsmoorian said:
Mgw sweats blind theres contact, but the replays do him no favors at all. Slightly more cringe than Bogle in the first half, who didn't get booked. Too early in game?
Click to expand...

I was at the wrong end but to me it looked like Bogle fell over as much as anything. Gibbs-White definitely dived.
 
Pitsmoorian said:
Mgw sweats blind theres contact, but the replays do him no favors at all. Slightly more cringe than Bogle in the first half, who didn't get booked. Too early in game?
Click to expand...
If MGW was booked for diving, Bogle (looked like a dive to me) should have been in the first half. Had Bogle been booked it might have prevented any more diving. I just wish there was more consistency. If there was zero tolerance to clear cut misdmeanours such as goalkeepers holding onto the ball for more than 6 seconds, players not retreating and preventing quick free kicks, kicking the ball away to waste time, pinching 5 or 6 yards for every throw in - the list goes on and on. If they were punished for the first offence (early in the game), it would cut out most of the nonsense
 
Interesting read that....just shows how inept the criteria is to make it....totally lost control of a game that I thought was easy to ref...
In his defence he got the second yellow on MGW spot on...shame about the first one.

In general absolutely feckin hopeless.
 
The thing that always riles me about bad refs is that there appears to be no repercussions for a bad performance, therefore no incentive to be better. Why aren’t they taken to task in some way? If anyone was to look at the inconsistencies in his decision making last night, they would have to say he didn’t know what he was doing. He let them get away with some obvious fouls then would immediately blow for one against. Is that was the same or less obvious. Not saying he got the GW one wrong, by the way, but their lad should’ve got a second yellow for that cynical trip on Fleck.
Yet another bad ref performance goes unnoticed and we are on to the next one.

And I don’t think our players get on them enough after the bad decisions; can you imagine Man U, Liverpool or Arsenal players in that circumstance, and Klopp would be on the pitch reffing it himself.
 
Chimpan-A said:
The thing that always riles me about bad refs is that there appears to be no repercussions for a bad performance, therefore no incentive to be better. Why aren’t they taken to task in some way? If anyone was to look at the inconsistencies in his decision making last night, they would have to say he didn’t know what he was doing. He let them get away with some obvious fouls then would immediately blow for one against. Is that was the same or less obvious. Not saying he got the GW one wrong, by the way, but their lad should’ve got a second yellow for that cynical trip on Fleck.
Yet another bad ref performance goes unnoticed and we are on to the next one.

And I don’t think our players get on them enough after the bad decisions; can you imagine Man U, Liverpool or Arsenal players in that circumstance, and Klopp would be on the pitch reffing it himself.
Click to expand...

Actually quite a few of our players got at the ref for that second yellow for their lad.
 
Bladesman said:
Actually quite a few of our players got at the ref for that second yellow for their lad.
Click to expand...
They did but I thought it seemed a bit half hearted - a few shrugged shoulders and waving in the general direction of the foul. It’s not going to change the decision I guess but maybe makes him act differently. Ultimately I am still angry at his performance, but as someone has already stated, he didn’t lose us the game.
 
Chimpan-A said:
They did but I thought it seemed a bit half hearted - a few shrugged shoulders and waving in the general direction of the foul. It’s not going to change the decision I guess but maybe makes him act differently. Ultimately I am still angry at his performance, but as someone has already stated, he didn’t lose us the game.
Click to expand...

Nah even our keeper was shouting at the ref over that.

Fans and players couldn’t do more without going and grabbing a yellow card out of his pocket.
 
Controversially, I think he got the MGW decision right.

He should however have sent Saville off to make it an even kilter for the remainder of the match. No excuse for missing that foul on Ndiaye.
 
He did get the MGW dive right, we should be criticising him...if he stays on the pitch we win the game regardless of the ref.
MGW is class and doesn’t need the ‘premier league’ cheating aspects to his game
 

Think that after last nights display, the days of stuffed brown envelopes have returned, either that or it was Rowetts brother officiating. Terrible
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

CornwallBlade
Referee
Replies
12
Views
1K
ATL Recs
A
RammyBlade
Referee
Replies
14
Views
1K
dexter101
D
Maurice Maurice
Referee
3 4 5
Replies
123
Views
8K
jaybee
J
ChipButtyBlade
Referee For The Cardiff FA Cup 3rd
Replies
1
Views
511
Snowflake
S
William Carey
Referee Oliver Langford’s Performance Tonight
2 3
Replies
76
Views
5K
Anarita blade
A

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom