Hi Stef and
Snowman , I understand your reticence regarding this phrase, so perhaps you'll allow me to widen this conversation.
I've never been one for blind faith, it's manic, foolish, and there's the possibility of culpability in something you might, with hindsight, disagree with.
Yes, Wilder has bought players who haven't made the grade. let me refer you to something that CW said recently. I don't have the quote to hand but in essence it amounted to the fact that no matter how you had imagined a player might be a good fit it just doesn't work out for either party. Is blame attached? Do we point a finger accusingly? Or do we accept that everyone, including you and I, make errors of judgement, or what might be called miscalculations?
I know myself that there have been times when I considered someone a good fit for a particular position, yet it soon became clear that they weren't equipped for the intended job. Was it my fault, or did the other person convince me that they had the necessary tools to do the job? Perhaps the problem lay somewhere between the two of us. The truth is, as much as I would go over this time and again, I never reached a moment where a clear and unambiguous solution became clear to me.
As I've said, Wilder has pursued players, Leonard being the most obvious one that comes to mind. CW must have looked at Leonard within the Southend structure and seen a midfield player capable of giving us a turbo-charged dynamo, but as we're all aware, it didn't work out for the lad. Recruitment must be a strange area, you look at a player many times, he seems to tick all the necessary boxes, yet come the moment when money passes from one account to another, suddenly the hoped for answer to a need is anything but........we're not alone in this, it happens at other clubs. Man Utd bought Tottenham's shining star, Dimitar Berbatov, a wonderfully skilful player at Spurs, but once he'd arrived at Old Trafford what we saw was a player who simply couldn't offer the same range of dazzling skills. Whatever the reasons for this we'll probably never know, but Berbatov was a pale shadow of the player that excelled at Spurs. Trying to find reasons or explanations becomes a fruitless task, you have to move on rapidly, there's no time for reflection or self-indulgence. I must add this wasn't the only error that Alex Ferguson made when it came to recruitment, but it didn't have a negative impact on the relationship between Ferguson and the Old Trafford faithful. Overall AF's record was excellent, and I suspect this will be the same for Wilder.
Like I said, blind faith isn't the issue here, but we have to invest faith in a manager, so who better that Chris wilder to give us what we want? Great football, no negatives, just players playing to their potential. He hasn't done bad so far, and it's been with the support of the fans who've seen what this man can deliver, with, I should add, a not always supportive board. Which makes his achievements all the more exceptional in my book. So by all means offer your criticisms, as long as they're considered and constructive I'm sure they'll be welcome.