He was the right man for the job at the right time, if what we wanted was promotion. He did that, had the cheat code of Ndiaye to do so but got the job done - you can't really knock him.
He now no longer is the right man for the job. He's shown his deficiencies and there's no doubt in my mind we would be mid-table in the Championship next season at best with Hecky at the helm. Without Ndiaye we were and are lost.
What I would've loved is for us either to stick with Slav or A.N. Other who would get us away from the 5-3-2 long term. We needed to change the whole culture of the club and that was always going to be a struggle. The right manager for me at least was someone who we would initially back, totally overhaul the squad and rebuild in a 4-3-3 possession based system. But we appointed what I still perceive to be a great manager and gave him none of the types of players he needs to succeed with his systems - MGW aside.
I'd love us to appoint the likes of McKenna or Potter and build a new culture at the club but we can't afford to or we just aren't attractive enough to do so. With the contracts running out it's the perfect opportunity to think long-term but nothing the club does is long-term anymore. I just don't know.
You hear it so often that there's this massive gap in standard between the PL and the Championship.
However I think it's more about style of play. Watching PL football is almost like watching a different sport.
PL teams focus massively on keeping possession and every player has decent composure and good control on the ball.
The players all seem massive and muscle bound but there's less physicality, you only need to gently touch a player and they fall down on the floor.
Players are much more deadly in front of goal and able to create chances from nothing.
My view is that Slavs football philosophy is built around Premier league style football.
He had us playing short passing, keep possession football. We looked good but we over passed giving opposition defences time to re-organise.
Also he often has the defence pushed up to the half way line, so most of the play was in the opponents half.
The problem was our defence (mainly Egan and Robinson) were slow, so when we pushed up we were vulnerable to the long ball counter attack.
When Hecky replaced Slav, Hecky took a pragmatic approach and had us playing Championship style football.
He stopped the "keep possession" style as it's not as important in the 2nd tier. We mixed the style of play up and at times
weren't embarrassed to use long ball. Norwood was the main man, he would be encouraged to make the Hollywood pass.
80%- 90% of the time the ball went straight back to the opposition but occasionally it was a fantastic pass and we'd score.
Giving up possession was never a sin in the Championship because it wouldn't be long before you got the ball back.
Also Hecky realised that the quality was much lower in the Championship with hardly anyone able to score from well outside the box.
So again his "win at any cost" approach was, when we were leading then pull most of the team back into defence, then the defence couldn't be caught out for pace. I remember the Bristol City and Swansea away games where we defended for such long spells.
Normally to deliberately chose to defend is a receipt for disaster but like Athletic Madrid we often seemed surprisingly comfortable
Most matches last season our defence was under long spells of pressure but our goalie often had little to do.
Think Hecky has brought this Athletic Madrid defensive approach to the PL.
It's as though training is based on what we do without the ball, instead of what we do with the ball, in fairness results have been respectable but
when we have long spells without the ball in the PL then heads drop as it becomes like damage limitation, an attack versus defence routine.
At least in the 1st half against Man Utd we were on the front foot and took the battle to the opposition, reasons for optimism.
Really think our issue (like away to Spurs) is we need to give the defence a rest from constant defending.
The way you do this is to have a spell of keeping possession to take the heat out of a game.
The Wilder team had been coached for years to play little triangles even when under pressure and I think when you play against teams with better players, the ability to prevent these dangerous players to seeing much of the ball is really important in the PL.