secretchief
Member
- Joined
- Mar 4, 2010
- Messages
- 788
- Reaction score
- 1,015
When Leeds were relegated from the Premiership, I remember an article in the paper which made the point that Leeds weren't a 'big' club because big clubs don't get relegated.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?
Are you an owl? Serious question.
Well there's no point in continuing the discussion then if you're just going to ignore everything you don't like to hear. You're basically just sticking your fingers in your ears, looking the other way and going "blah blah blah" very loudly because you can't accept the truth.
I point out that Wendy are now a pretty well established third division club.
No. Serious answer.
because big clubs don't get relegated.
- 15 seasons (9 consecutive) in the top flight from 1984 to 2000.
- In 1992 they almost won the League Title finishing just 7 points behind Leeds.
- 1991 League Cup winners.
- 1993 League Cup runners-up.
- 1993 FA Cup runners-up.
- 1993 UEFA Cup participants.
Is that enough?
No Blade I know would wank themselves off about Wendys 'achievements' like you do.
I've got to say Mr 081 having followed your posts on football, politics ,music even TV programmes ,I have never disagreed with anyones views more than you in my whole life. If opposites attract we should get married.
The bigger picture is a city the size of Sheffield maybe hosting 3rd division derbies again next year which is absolutely disgraceful.
We haven't got a decent club or team between us at the moment, we're a city that punches so far below its weight.
Maybe Wednesday are now beginning to get their act together but generally both clubs are a complete embarrassment.
The bigger picture is a city the size of Sheffield maybe hosting 3rd division derbies again next year which is absolutely disgraceful.
We haven't got a decent club or team between us at the moment, we're a city that punches so far below its weight.
Maybe Wednesday are now beginning to get their act together...
You could equally substitute 'Bristol' for 'Sheffield'
I think that is disputable Len. Apart from the 'saviour' deal not yet being done, we are yet to see the numbers and terms that will apply to them, and the management, and all following its conclusion. I know its in your nature to predict the rise of SWFC in the same way that you can't help yourself from predicting the demise of SUFC, but both of these things are yet to be seen...
I know its in your nature to predict the rise of SWFC in the same way that you can't help yourself from predicting the demise of SUFC, but both of these things are yet to be seen...
Thought i'd ask this on the back of the "can we still challenge for promotion" post. I have to ask the question are we going to be the next big club to drop into the 3rd tier of the english league? Will we follow in the foot steps of Norwich, Southampton, Weeds and Forest clubs who have spent many years in the top 2 leagues but dropped down in recent years. One thing i do know we are not to big to go down.
Actually this is exactly the sort of season that a club, perceived by its fans to be, too good to go down gets sucked into the mire and finds it really difficult to struggle out of it. Seen it all before. If the scoring element doesn't pick up pronto then we are royally screwed.
Other teams in and around us - with the exception of Palace (although they have managed a 4 goal haul in one game) have improved whereas we appear to be static. The tactics are negative and we create few chances. Whilst that persists the outcome will be the same as it has for the first 11 games of the season.
It's alright working hard. Just see no evidence of us working smart.
Setting up every game with tactics geared to a defensive, rearguard action whilst looking to counter attack only works if you have players with pace and ability. We don't have that style of player, consequently the best we can hope for is a point in a draw but one mistake leads to that being blown out of the water - as has happened several times already this season.
The bigger picture is a city the size of Sheffield maybe hosting 3rd division derbies again next year which is absolutely disgraceful.
We haven't got a decent club or team between us at the moment, we're a city that punches so far below its weight.
Maybe Wednesday are now beginning to get their act together but generally both clubs are a complete embarrassment.
Much in the same way your predictions in the reverse have too?![]()
Nothing is impossible, but as unlikely as it is that we will get automatic promotion, we are equally unlikely to end up going down. This is not based on my normal cheery feelings, but simply that we have a squad that is plenty good enough to be comfortable in this league. We will need to get going soon, but there are 36 games left...
Dunc, I wonder if you can drop your pathetic get out clause for when you are losing an argument .... erm I mean signature 'I don't argue with idiots' for a moment and answer a couple of questions:
- which teams in the division do you think are significantly worse than us?
- from watching us this season, what evidence do you see that we will get better?
- in our current squad, which players are the one's that make up this 'plenty good enough' comment you made?
I dont care if they were winning the Champions League in front of 75,000 every week.
I've only included the players that are actually ours (all the loanees are good enough IMO)
Simmo - Good Enough
Morgan - Good Enough
Ward - Good Enough
Britton - Good Enough
Yeates - Good Enough
Ward - Good Enough
Evans - Good Enough
Henderson - Good Enough
Montgomery - Good Enough
Williamson - Good Enough
Cresswell - Good Enough
Jordan - Good Enough
We've got plenty of players that are good enough. The problem is a lack of players that are a bit special.
Dunc, I wonder if you can drop your pathetic get out clause for when you are losing an argument .... erm I mean signature 'I don't argue with idiots' for a moment and answer a couple of questions:
- which teams in the division do you think are significantly worse than us?
- from watching us this season, what evidence do you see that we will get better?
- in our current squad, which players are the one's that make up this 'plenty good enough' comment you made?
We all know you are a Pig fan so why do you constantly come on here pretending otherwise? Your pro-Pig comments are often ludicrous - looking for any possible angle, however tenuous, to try to put them in a better light. You've picked out one period in time when the Pigs did relatively well - ignoring the sh!t that came before & after. You also ignore the fact that you've been below us for years, your crowds are smaller & your ground is a rusting sh!t-hole.
Massive my rse. As you say, 9 consecutive seasons in the top flight, including qualifying for europe, and you still could not average 30k - something we did under Warnock despite being relegated.
P!ss off to Fowlstalk and drool over your massive £2m investment and your superb victory against the massive Leyton Orient.
---------- Post added at 11:28 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:22 AM ----------
Spot on. But he's not a Blade - he's a Pig living in Dingleland.
Lets start on the basic premise that my views are as valid as yours. Believe me, if we are going to compare pathetic internet signatures I think you give me some stiff competition. For the record I do not 'get out of argument' but I refuse to continue when the other person is just here to dig themselves deeper into an entrenched position, or to stroke their own fur in front of an assembled audience. I am not here to 'educate' anyone.
In answer to your questions. The teams in this league are broadly of a similar standard. With the possible exception of QPR and Cardiff, there isn't more than a 5% difference between the rest. The results show this to be the case, with anyone really being able to beat anyone on their day. A run of a few results would be enough for us, or anyone around us to get well up the table. Only 7 points between play-offs and relegation zone, but then we have only played 8 out of 46 games, not 38. Looking at last seasons table, was there any massive difference between us in 8th and Bristol City, Derby, Boro, Coventry, Preston, Watford, Ipswich, Barnsley, and other teams who finished in the mid table below us? I dont think there was. Peterborough was the team we could all nail as being 'poor' after selling their goal scorers, but this season no team stands out as being particularly poor, despite what you seemingly try to prove. You talk of Portsmouth, Leicester, Bristol City as if they are just about to hit form and streak past us, but you are blind to the possibility that we may also find form ourselves.
What evidence do you see that we will get worse? We've changed the style, not massively, but enough, and for spells in games we've looked a decent side, and a battling side. We haven't had the luck in front of goal, but it really is hyping it up to claim that we are a nailed on cert for relegation. We have improved in a few positions from last year. I know they are loans (season long) but Jordon and Calve are both better than what we had after Walker had gone back. I dont think we have quite worked out a formation where Britton and Ertle are used to their best effect, but they are both improvements too. Despite the lack of goals Boggy gives us three strikers in the squad who scored 15 goals a piece in the Championship last season. Are they shit, or are they struggling for form? I prefer to believe the latter. They've done it before.
Players who are 'Plenty Good enough' for a mid table Championship side? Simmondsen, Jordon, Bartley, Nos, Morgs, Monty, Britton, Ertle, Calve, Quinn S., Cresswell, Henderson (when fit), Boggy, Yeates, Williamson (when fit), Ward. Dont think I've missed one. I have question marks against Kozzy, not what he once was, Evans who I think mentally, the longer it goes on, the less likely that it will come good for him, and Taylor who shows flashes of a decent player but is undone too easily. I am not rating the likes of Lowton, Slew, Chappell and James as they are for next season and beyond. Thats 16 players who would fit into any other mid-table side and a few who would fit into a side with aspirations of play-offs and better. When we get a formation that they can deliver their best, and most importantly a bit of confidence in them, I can easily see us being comfortable.
Its down to Speedo and the coaches to get it right, and get us going. If they can't, then we may find outselves with a battle on to stay in the division. We all know its a possibility but there is no point in fretting about it at this stage with more than 80% of games still to be played...
Lets start on the basic premise that my views are as valid as yours. Believe me, if we are going to compare pathetic internet signatures I think you give me some stiff competition. For the record I do not 'get out of argument' but I refuse to continue when the other person is just here to dig themselves deeper into an entrenched position, or to stroke their own fur in front of an assembled audience. I am not here to 'educate' anyone.
In answer to your questions. The teams in this league are broadly of a similar standard. With the possible exception of QPR and Cardiff, there isn't more than a 5% difference between the rest. The results show this to be the case, with anyone really being able to beat anyone on their day. A run of a few results would be enough for us, or anyone around us to get well up the table. Only 7 points between play-offs and relegation zone, but then we have only played 8 out of 46 games, not 38. Looking at last seasons table, was there any massive difference between us in 8th and Bristol City, Derby, Boro, Coventry, Preston, Watford, Ipswich, Barnsley, and other teams who finished in the mid table below us? I dont think there was. Peterborough was the team we could all nail as being 'poor' after selling their goal scorers, but this season no team stands out as being particularly poor, despite what you seemingly try to prove. You talk of Portsmouth, Leicester, Bristol City as if they are just about to hit form and streak past us, but you are blind to the possibility that we may also find form ourselves.
What evidence do you see that we will get worse? We've changed the style, not massively, but enough, and for spells in games we've looked a decent side, and a battling side. We haven't had the luck in front of goal, but it really is hyping it up to claim that we are a nailed on cert for relegation. We have improved in a few positions from last year. I know they are loans (season long) but Jordon and Calve are both better than what we had after Walker had gone back. I dont think we have quite worked out a formation where Britton and Ertle are used to their best effect, but they are both improvements too. Despite the lack of goals Boggy gives us three strikers in the squad who scored 15 goals a piece in the Championship last season. Are they shit, or are they struggling for form? I prefer to believe the latter. They've done it before.
Players who are 'Plenty Good enough' for a mid table Championship side? Simmondsen, Jordon, Bartley, Nos, Morgs, Monty, Britton, Ertle, Calve, Quinn S., Cresswell, Henderson (when fit), Boggy, Yeates, Williamson (when fit), Ward. Dont think I've missed one. I have question marks against Kozzy, not what he once was, Evans who I think mentally, the longer it goes on, the less likely that it will come good for him, and Taylor who shows flashes of a decent player but is undone too easily. I am not rating the likes of Lowton, Slew, Chappell and James as they are for next season and beyond. Thats 16 players who would fit into any other mid-table side and a few who would fit into a side with aspirations of play-offs and better. When we get a formation that they can deliver their best, and most importantly a bit of confidence in them, I can easily see us being comfortable.
Its down to Speedo and the coaches to get it right, and get us going. If they can't, then we may find outselves with a battle on to stay in the division. We all know its a possibility but there is no point in fretting about it at this stage with more than 80% of games still to be played...
It doesn't matter how many times you keep saying I'm a Wednesday fan, it doesn't make it true. I'm a Sheffield United fan whether you like it or not. I've had a season ticket for over ten years and I'll be there against Burnley on saturday.
All this from a man who thinks the Sheffield clubs should be compared with Bristol in football terms. As such, very hard to take anything you say seriously from now on - decent contribution though..
We don't need to get worse to go down. We need to score more goals to stay up. What are the potential formations that could make us score a few goals?
I honestly think you live in a fanatsy land where SUFC are concerned at the moment...
Hilarious. You sad , sad Pig.
I class any team who has played in the PL is the last 5-10 years a big club.
All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?