I would agree in general with there being an over reaction, but I think most fans know that as a club we have a real dichotomy to deal with. While ever we have the likes of Fleck, Stevens & Norwood (and others), we are going to struggle. I don't know what has happened for their collective form to drop off a cliff, it's like they have PTSD or something, but let's be honest do we have enough quality in the squad to leave them out? Playing Hourihane on Tuesday seemed sensible to me, rotate the players a bit, but within minutes he showed it was a very bad day at the office, & I credit Slav for getting him off. Problem with that moving on is how does he possibly get back in the side after that performance? Well for me he doesn't, & if we can return him to his parent club in January we should.
Back to the old guard, Slav simply cannot get his style of play into most of our players, they are not up to it any more, & I am confident in saying we will not be able to make wholesale changes in January, we can't afford to when we have a squad full of players not justifying their salaries, who I doubt will attract bids from other clubs.
We cannot go back to the old system, despite potentially having the players to play that way they proved they cannot any longer by getting us relegated. And anyway, if that was the direction the club want to go in then it was pointless bring Slav in, we may as well have stuck with Hecky.
I also think that a lot of frustration & anger of our supporters is a very "Sheffield" reaction, apart from a few seconds of Greasy Chip Butty at the start of each half the crowd is largely silent, & only make noise after a mistake from one of our players or a crap decision from the referee. We has stopped supporting & are waiting to be entertained, it comes across really badly on TV. I understand this after the last 18 months or so, but we are showing little joy at being able to attend games again.
This is all just my opinion, I would much rather find positives to talk about & not criticise, but the writing has been on the wall for a while now, we need to know the club have a plan of action to reverse this otherwise our future is far from certain.