Newcastle United 1 Sheffield United 3

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?


Just curious, did you see Hodgy at 21 or later in his career?? I don't think you can really make judgements between 2 keepers until they have both finished their respective careers
Saw Hodgy from his first game to his last and he was imho the best keeper for us I have ever seen , also saw him in the old central league as a young kid trying to get in the first team and there was no doubt he would go on to have a great career. I understand you saying it's hard to compare them now with the game being faster, lighter balls ect but as Brian the Blade would say believe you me Hodgy was the best.
 
I agree with everything Bladesthorpe says above . For me Hodgy ,definitely, the best but Hendo heading the right way to rival Hodgy. Comparing players from a different era is always open to debate though, and as pointed out, Hendo is at the beginning of an illustrious career (hopefully with us).
Regarding the Blades 3-1 win at Newcastle, in the 1961 FA Cup, it should be high in Blades' folk-lore if only for the astonishing , first 18 mins Hat-Trick by Billy Russell. That match is ,also, etched in my memory as I was playing in another Cup quarter final on the same day- the now defunct F.A. Amateur Cup- against Hitchin Town in which we lost. A spectator had the match commentary on .Needless to say I didn't do a Billy Russell- more interested in the Blades' match.
 
Russell hat trick in first 18 mins
1. Hodgkinson
2. Coldwell
3. Shaw G
4. Richardson
5. Shaw J
6. Summers
7. Hodgson
8. Russell
9. Pace
10. Kettleborough
11. Simpson
Remember all of those players but can't remember ever seeing Russell when I started going Allchurch was on the wing and Hodgson inside right. one of my first memories was Hodgson scoring in a 1-0 win over Leicester god knows when.
 
Remember all of those players but can't remember ever seeing Russell when I started going Allchurch was on the wing and Hodgson inside right. one of my first memories was Hodgson scoring in a 1-0 win over Leicester god knows when.
We signed Allchurch on deadline day, about two weeks after the Newcastle match
 
Hodgy what a keeper best I’ve seen nearest one to him was Tom McAllister. We’ve had some good uns but Hodgy was PURE CLASS and Tom was destined for great things and we know who messed that up don’t we
 
Saw Hodgy in his last year for us and he made many errors in the first 5 months of the 1970-71 season so unfair for me to judge as I hadnt seen Hodgy at his peak
I would have to say hodgy in his hay day but hendo still young and he could go even better
 
I was there. !! Friendly Geordies were silent after 20 minutes . As a 15 year old my mate and I must have been making quite a noise. Tolerant respect from locals. But that was a very long time ago. Then on to Elland Road.
Me too. One of my life`s best away days. Then robbed at Elland Road.
 
Remember all of those players but can't remember ever seeing Russell when I started going Allchurch was on the wing and Hodgson inside right. one of my first memories was Hodgson scoring in a 1-0 win over Leicester god knows when.
Was that the game he came off the pitch covered in mud from head to toe
 
I saw his last league match for us , a 2-1 away defeat against a struggling Bolton side who we were expected to beat and it was pitiful to watch .

This truly great goalkeeper who had served us so well for so long let in two soft goals and dropped just about everything that came his way , being reduced to scrambling about in the box on his hands and knees trying to retrieve them .

Shortly after , I also saw John Hope's debut in a 2-1 win away against a very decent Oxford side and came away knowing that our season was back on track and believing that we would be promoted , which we were in what was probably the most memorable ending to a season I have ever experienced .
The Cardiff City game is still the best one I have been to.
The excitement queueing to get in.
The electric atmosphere in the ground.
The swaying of the kop.
The bright sparkling eyes of everyone
The noise when we scored.
The sheer joy.
 
The Cardiff City game is still the best one I have been to.
The excitement queueing to get in.
The electric atmosphere in the ground.
The swaying of the kop.
The bright sparkling eyes of everyone
The noise when we scored.
The sheer joy.

That's another of my top 5 - absolute cracker !
 

As a young paperboy i couldn't afford to go to this match, really pissed off as some of my mates could, the Blades scorers & players are not listed can anyone fill in the gaps?
You did ask! I hope the pics of the programme and from my old scrapbook convey something of my favourite away trip of all-time. 18,000 Blades in all corners of the ground, singing Ilkey Moor the whole game. We were behind the goal where Russell got his hat-trick, but I don't know the lads who ran on the pitch. Our 'football special' train broke down somewhere around Darlington, and for a while we looked like missing the match. My dad would have sympathised with you - he worked Saturday mornings, and nearly fell off his chair when Grandstand(?) reported rumours that United were 3-0 up after 20 minutes - the presenter did not know whether to believe it! More pics on the next post.
7D232AC2-85F2-4E94-87E0-50D21857160A.jpegCD8AA209-8EE7-42D3-95D7-9F3815DC7B67.jpegBD8AB259-E313-42F5-BB38-890E113E9F65.jpeg
 

I know owd'uns, me included these days always look back with rose tinted gigs but me dad says Hodgy was brilliant at his peak.
He also says Jimmy Hagan was the best ever & there should be a statue of him in the car park (instead of a former Wendy player/supporter).

As a kid I missed most of what was probably TC's best seasons living abroad. As a result I always look back more fondly on Geoff Salmons. Badger & Salmons were my heros & it broke my heart when Blades sold the latter to Stoke.
Your dad is bang on regarding J. Hagan on both counts.
 
I know owd'uns, me included these days always look back with rose tinted gigs but me dad says Hodgy was brilliant at his peak.
He also says Jimmy Hagan was the best ever & there should be a statue of him in the car park (instead of a former Wendy player/supporter).

As a kid I missed most of what was probably TC's best seasons living abroad. As a result I always look back more fondly on Geoff Salmons. Badger & Salmons were my heros & it broke my heart when Blades sold the latter to Stoke.
I can remember my dad shaking his head saying "we always sell our best players son & mentioning summat about Jone & Birchienall" which meant nowt to me at the time but became a very prophetic comment.

It was only years later when I did some research & learned these 2 'Legends' were sold within months I realised the gravity of their sale & the effect it must have had on fans at the time. More of an effect, I would imagine than selling Deane & Fjortoff as Jones & Birchenall were both at the beginning of excellent careers.
 
The Cardiff City game is still the best one I have been to.
The excitement queueing to get in.
The electric atmosphere in the ground.
The swaying of the kop.
The bright sparkling eyes of everyone
The noise when we scored.
The sheer joy.
That promotion season our annual leave from Ghana coincided with Cardiff & Watford game. Dad bought us tickets on the back row of Bramall Lane Stand for both games. I was only 8 but remember both games being magical.
 
Some brilliant photos there HBT ... don't suppose you have any similar in your scrapbook from the semi-final v Leicester?
Always happy to look out these things, particularly just now. The semi-final made less of an impression than the Newcastle match. The atmosphere was great (see last frame of the cartoon), but the match was not great. The main incident was Pace's disallowed goal, but as it was at the other end, I have no idea whether it was handball. He always maintained he didn't handle it, and he was an honest type. A couple of weeks later, Allchurch made his debut and scored the winner v Leeds at Elland Road, and began the push for promotion (think Basham, March last year).
image.jpegimage.jpegimage.jpegimage.jpeg
 
The replay was at Forest's ground on the following Thursday afternoon (no floodlights). Another 0-0, Hodgy brilliant, went to extra time. I didn't go (school :( ), and haven't got the programme, but here are some pics, and the report.image.jpegimage.jpegimage.jpeg
 
The defeat in the second replay meant no Cup Final, but we did win promotion, and got a photo in the Cup Final programme, which at the time gave me great pride:
64D48B7F-6835-4E4C-A5C1-E47C0B16E316.jpeg3C4FCAB7-A460-4FEA-A747-85F88DA847EA.jpeg
 
My dad was at that FA Cup final. He went to 1949 and 1955 FA Cup finals too. My Uncle Ronnie has the tickets. The 1949 is on the right of the below photo

View attachment 74098
The 1961 Final was huge, because the Double had not been done for so long that it seemed impossible (can't remember when the previous double was). That Spurs team was terrific to watch - if Utd were playing a long way from Sheffield, and I was playing school football Saturday mornings, I got a train to watch them in Nottingham, Manchester (and even S6). They were awesome, and would no doubt have beaten us in the final. If it is not too personal a question, how did your dad get tickets for these matches?
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom