You're throwing a few players well before my lifetime so perhaps I'll amend my previous statement to "creative players in the last 25 years".
In my time we've seen technically gifted players look outstanding at other clubs and get hounded out of Bramall Lane - Dean Windass, Paul Shaw, Paul Ifill, Leon Britton, Nathan Dyer, David Cotterill off the top of my head.
It's the same for goalscorers. We've taken many prolific strikers over the years and they've either been coached into chasing channels, back to goal, drop deep or shipped out. We did it twice with our very own, beloved Billy Sharp.