We need to talk about Matt Done

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

He's not a left wing back in a month of Sundays. Impact sub to replace Sharp or Adams when they aren't at the races.
Think your right Fjortoft Done is very much an average player if that ,shocking at defending and can't cross a ball to save his life.Once Sharp came in he lost his place and his injury stopped him from challenging Billy for the shirt.His best position is up front as he has the knack of being in the right place at the right time,but his overall team play is poor as it was last seaston as you say he would have made a good back up striker for us.Although Woolford hasn't pulled any trees up he is a natural wing back and is far better than Done at crossing and also is a better defender.
It's prayer matts out now as a draw leaves us in the hands of colchester who are doomed.,could they sneak something at Barnsley that's our only chance
now ,of course we would have to beat Coventry,there could still be another twist who knows.it's never over till the fat lady sings.
 



How can anyone criticise Matt Done. Playing out of position and has been most of the season yet consistently giving everything an being one of our better players. If we had another 10 players like him we'd be promoted by now.

You don't get promoted with 11 mid table League One standard players with little quality and no physicality. If you're just talking about his effort then even that's questionable, he often bottles going in for tackles.
 
Gave today a miss and watched Blackburn instead. If Done didn't do well and we need a new left back, then I'll do Adkins' scouting for him - they've got some guy who's in his thirties, has no pace, always looks to pass backwards rather than forwards and seems like a defensive liability. No prizes for guessing who I'm talking about.

edit - he's even out of contract at the end of the season so would be within our budget!

On a serious note, where's Wallace?
 
On a serious note, where's Wallace?

Still injured sadly – in theory left wingback should have played to his strengths, a pity we haven't been able to see him there as I think he'd be better than Done/Woolford
 
this is an easy one
matt done bang average left back/ wing back is tried at CF and starts banging goals in for fun s much so that he is bought by sheffield united where he starts banging goals in and becomes a fans favourite. gets injured and loses place in team under mysterious circumstances
new manager comes in who immediately buys tried and tested CF whi he knows well. matt done returned to left wing back. Result inevitable

I think that sums it up for me. He has always been a decent to average league one wing back/left back. He had a great purple patch at Rochdale last season but as a wing back he's always been as he is playing for us now.

I don't want to knock the guy too much though as he puts in so much effort and who knows if he would have carried on his goalscoring form if he had been given an extended run in that position
 
Gave today a miss and watched Blackburn instead. If Done didn't do well and we need a new left back, then I'll do Adkins' scouting for him - they've got some guy who's in his thirties, has no pace, always looks to pass backwards rather than forwards and seems like a defensive liability. No prizes for guessing who I'm talking about.

edit - he's even out of contract at the end of the season so would be within our budget!

On a serious note, where's Wallace?

Kilgallon. I'd definitely take him back. Would be a big upgrade on McEveley in the LCB position.
 
Another stinker of a performance from Done today I thought. Really not been impressed with him recently or all season really.

He's non-existent defensively and offers nothing going forward, even though that's meant to be what he's good at. Can't beat a player and his delivery is usually poor - that's when he actually looks to be direct instead of turning backwards or coming inside. There were a few times where he bottled tackles today as well, which is unacceptable.

It's not like he's being played out of position either. He's played as a left-back and a winger all his career.

Yeh - he does a lot of running and I appreciate that people like a 'trier' but he's simply not good enough.

Very limited player and very much a weak-link for me. I'd look to offload in the summer, as he's definitely not good enough for where we want to be.

What are his goals and assists stats this season?

Suppose he's not the only one though.



Oh Christ, really? - I'll save you a job and any other who agrees with you and re-write :)

He's not a defender and was never brought in as a defender. He offers plenty in defence.... when he is defending from the front as a striker chasing down the opposition back four, forcing them into making mistakes. Can beat a player and does beat a player, especially for pace when he's playing off the last man, latching onto through balls, or picking up the ball from a forced mistake that more often or not he has created. Bottles tackles? What striker can tackle?! Disregard that... can any of our lot tackle?

- How can you even say he is not playing out of position? He scored 17 goals last year and got 12 assists as a striker for Rochdale/Blades combined? Funnily enough, that record came about by playing him upfront because Rochdale had no other option. Turned out to be an excellent decision by the Kieth Hill, some decisions like that from our current manager may have furthered our position this year.

- He does a lot of running because no other useless fucker in our team can. They're all injury prone retards with hips hanging off, old has beens, couldn't give a fucks, or high as a kite! Why do you think he is playing there? Everyone else would drown in that position, it's the most physically demanding position to play on a football pitch. No one else in our squad can do it. Woolford is more likely to do himself then another player, let alone get anywhere near a decent position to cross the ball. He's slower than Hammond for gods sake!

I'd get rid of 3/4 of the rest of the squad before shipping out Done. I know, lets go sell players who can put the ball in the back of the net and get assists instead of doing what Adkins should have done in the first place. Identify the strongest players we have in their strongest positions and build a team around them. Or we could replace Done with Che at wing back, he's played down the right/left hand side for more of his career than upfront, so should be able to do a job yeah?

Final sentence is alright though. We need 7-8 additions for next year, 2 CB's and a whole new midfield as a must. No chance we're getting that many in and they'll gel quick enough. Come on though, their is far superior shitesters in our current squad than Matt Done. Play him where he is effective and he'll score goals, otherwise you may as well play George Long upfront, can't do any harm with the season over anyway can it?
 
Done s game is fast close down. When he played as striker this season he tried doing it but the rest of the players did not seem to get it. I remember one game he dud it twice and the third time he gave up because there was no team back up. Now the team have finally got the message to clise down fast from the front it would be good to see him there again to see if his goals were a flash in the pan.
When played as striker and scored he hit things the first time. He seems to be reluctant to do this from his current position. One yesterday in the 2nd half was perfect to be hit first time he wanted a touch. I screemed with annoyance at that point.
 
In fairness, we stopped playing him as a striker because he on the whole wasn't playing well as a striker this season. He only in fact got back into the team after the formation change when Woolford was injured.

For me, the jury's still out on whether he's actually a decent striker or whether he simply went on a Michael Brown esque anomaly year in front of goal at Rochdale.


Maybe we don't play him as a striker because we have Sharp and Adams, opinions will vary whether Done could play better with Sharp than Adams does. Anyway Adkins wants to develop Adams and that's fair enough.

So he feels, rightly or wrongly, he has to find a place for Done, wrongly IMO, just play him as an impact sub.

Then Adkins has to find a place for Basham when he has to find a place for Baptiste on return from injury. No way can he drop Hammond but maybe Coutts or Flynn? No, let's play them all, experienced players and all that. Out of position? What Flynn, Coutts, Basham, Done, Damned right, all out of position and 4 out of 5 midfield players with the other one simply crap.

I happen to think Adams is not best suited to front striker as well, better at running with the ball under control from a bit deeper, but I'm in a minority I think.

Done -striker or nothing.
Basham - defender or nothing, honest tryer that he is
Flynn - right or left wing back or nothing
Coutts - deep playmaker or nothing
Hammond - nothing

Oh and BTW, Woolford's best position is left wing back
 
Maybe we don't play him as a striker because we have Sharp and Adams, opinions will vary whether Done could play better with Sharp than Adams does. Anyway Adkins wants to develop Adams and that's fair enough.

So he feels, rightly or wrongly, he has to find a place for Done, wrongly IMO, just play him as an impact sub.

Then Adkins has to find a place for Basham when he has to find a place for Baptiste on return from injury. No way can he drop Hammond but maybe Coutts or Flynn? No, let's play them all, experienced players and all that. Out of position? What Flynn, Coutts, Basham, Done, Damned right, all out of position and 4 out of 5 midfield players with the other one simply crap.

I happen to think Adams is not best suited to front striker as well, better at running with the ball under control from a bit deeper, but I'm in a minority I think.

Done -striker or nothing.
Basham - defender or nothing, honest tryer that he is
Flynn - right or left wing back or nothing
Coutts - deep playmaker or nothing
Hammond - nothing

Oh and BTW, Woolford's best position is left wing back

Some sense in that , and Adkins now has to start with square pegs in square holes next season.

It's resolving the midfield to me and everything else will fall into place .

Is football that complicated or is Adkins just making it more difficult than it actually is . Time for shuffling the pack has to stop , and players being comfortable were they play and understand the there allocated task.

Still a bit undecided with Adkins , but what do I know being a South Stand moaner.

UTB
 
Maybe we don't play him as a striker because we have Sharp and Adams, opinions will vary whether Done could play better with Sharp than Adams does. Anyway Adkins wants to develop Adams and that's fair enough.

So he feels, rightly or wrongly, he has to find a place for Done, wrongly IMO, just play him as an impact sub.

Then Adkins has to find a place for Basham when he has to find a place for Baptiste on return from injury. No way can he drop Hammond but maybe Coutts or Flynn? No, let's play them all, experienced players and all that. Out of position? What Flynn, Coutts, Basham, Done, Damned right, all out of position and 4 out of 5 midfield players with the other one simply crap.

I happen to think Adams is not best suited to front striker as well, better at running with the ball under control from a bit deeper, but I'm in a minority I think.

Done -striker or nothing.
Basham - defender or nothing, honest tryer that he is
Flynn - right or left wing back or nothing
Coutts - deep playmaker or nothing
Hammond - nothing

Oh and BTW, Woolford's best position is left wing back
Woolfords' best position is at some other fuckers club.
 
Maybe we don't play him as a striker because we have Sharp and Adams, opinions will vary whether Done could play better with Sharp than Adams does. Anyway Adkins wants to develop Adams and that's fair enough.

So he feels, rightly or wrongly, he has to find a place for Done, wrongly IMO, just play him as an impact sub.

Then Adkins has to find a place for Basham when he has to find a place for Baptiste on return from injury. No way can he drop Hammond but maybe Coutts or Flynn? No, let's play them all, experienced players and all that. Out of position? What Flynn, Coutts, Basham, Done, Damned right, all out of position and 4 out of 5 midfield players with the other one simply crap.

I happen to think Adams is not best suited to front striker as well, better at running with the ball under control from a bit deeper, but I'm in a minority I think.

Done -striker or nothing.
Basham - defender or nothing, honest tryer that he is
Flynn - right or left wing back or nothing
Coutts - deep playmaker or nothing
Hammond - nothing

Oh and BTW, Woolford's best position is left wing back

"...I happen to think Adams is not best suited to front striker as well, better at running with the ball under control from a bit deeper, but I'm in a minority I think...."

I agree, so maybe I am in a minority as well, his first touch is too heavy, so he needs the space around him to bring the ball under control and then start his run, he is a strong lad when he gets up to speed.

Adams as an attacking midfielder, behind Sharp and Done/McNulty/new (tall, fast, strong) striker?
 
Woolfords' best position is at some other fuckers club.

To be fair to Woolford, he put a great, inch-perfect ball in to the box that landed right at Billy's feet, but Billy just could not get on it to fire at goal
 



To be fair to Woolford, he put a great, inch-perfect ball in to the box that landed right at Billy's feet, but Billy just could not get on it to fire at goal

...after a fantastic first touch,

We were right behind that ball he seemed to pass it exactly right but by some miracle there was no bend on it at all. It just went dead straight.

Pretty much anything on it and Billy gets there ahead of the keeper.
 
Maybe we don't play him as a striker because we have Sharp and Adams, opinions will vary whether Done could play better with Sharp than Adams does. Anyway Adkins wants to develop Adams and that's fair enough.

So he feels, rightly or wrongly, he has to find a place for Done, wrongly IMO, just play him as an impact sub.

Then Adkins has to find a place for Basham when he has to find a place for Baptiste on return from injury. No way can he drop Hammond but maybe Coutts or Flynn? No, let's play them all, experienced players and all that. Out of position? What Flynn, Coutts, Basham, Done, Damned right, all out of position and 4 out of 5 midfield players with the other one simply crap.

I happen to think Adams is not best suited to front striker as well, better at running with the ball under control from a bit deeper, but I'm in a minority I think.

Done -striker or nothing.
Basham - defender or nothing, honest tryer that he is
Flynn - right or left wing back or nothing
Coutts - deep playmaker or nothing
Hammond - nothing

Oh and BTW, Woolford's best position is left wing back


I would have said that Woolford's best position is left outside ....... in the car park ! :p

UTB & FTP
 
I think we should let done a bit of slack because I confused as anyone why he is at left back because it just makes us defensive fragile diwn the left side as Southend away proved
& also Because we have done more drastic thing that utd typically do. Lets buy a striker who banging in the goals & stick him on the wing. Just look at Jamie Murphy, Matt Done (Lb), Che Adams, Shaun Miller & Jose Baxter (Cm)
 
Dones decision making was indeed poor on Saturday. But he has been OK in the LWB position of late. Only OK mind.

I had high hopes for Done this season as a player who can add pace to the squad, get behind the defence and pitch in with a good few goals. It hasn't really happened. Perhaps he is not as good as I and others thought !

UTB
 
Probably, but only because Billy soft tapped it to his hands.
We must be on about different crosses then because Billy didn't get near the one I'm on about, it was physically impossible. As I said Woolford brought it down superbly but the ball was shite and he had all the time in the world to get it right.

On the subject of Billy, that was his worst game of the season for him, perhaps we gave him his award too early! :)
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom