Whose fault is it?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?




Been in a similar situation loads of times as a defender. You have to deal with it. Ok, Wes shouldn't have come but that's irrelevant, the ball should have been over the sidelines before he could even get near.
It's the same if a cross is coming in , and straight for my head. I don't give a shit if the keeper calls for it, I get it away .
 
Nedski said:
I think Robbo was going to leave to Wes but Tella give him a nudge in the back which puts him off and causes the confusion.

If anything (clutches at straws) it should have been a free kick to us.
Click to expand...
A lot of people have ignored this but it happened and caused the interference between Robbo and Wes. Tella doesn’t push him then JR 100% clears the ball and doesn’t leave it to Wes. Even with Wes calling for the ball you can see on the slow motion replay that Robbo is going to clear it at the last second then the push puts him off balance and takes him into Wes, hence why it looked like it did.

Two players don’t usually just collide like that for no reason without some sort of contact or miscommunication, they clearly communicated but the push did the damage. I will say there was no need for Wes to be there in the first place though.

In answer to the question, it was Tella then Wes in that order.
 
Kick it out then argue with the keeper after, 2 games v Burnley and 2 JLT fuck ups. Wes was also at fault if he shouted. Just kick the fucker (ball)!
 
Both players have a mistake in them at anytime.
Unfortunately they had it at the same time.
Replacements needed for both next season where ever Blades are.
 
Lendegoeystash said:
Wes.
Click to expand...
10000%

Had absolutely no business being there when JLT clearly had it covered.

Fucking annoyed with the daft cunt, was looking forward to this fixture to shut VK up and see how we matched up. There is every chance we would have won if we were at our best, would have been a huge 3 PTS.

Fucking Foddercunt
 
derekacorah said:
Kick it out then argue with the keeper after, 2 games v Burnley and 2 JLT fuck ups. Wes was also at fault if he shouted. Just kick the fucker (ball)!
Click to expand...
Wes was also at fault with JLT in the first one. Not sure why he thought JLT wanted the ball when he had a man closing him down.

I can only conclude they Wes is a bit thick.
 
100% on Wes that one.

Ok you can say Robinson should have just twatted it into row Z... But at least there's some reasoning on why he didn't. His goalkeeper has come off his line and called for it. Wes would have been able to clear it up the field instead of our for a thrown in a dangerous area.

As for wes. There's absolutely no reasoning behind the multiple stupid decisions he made:

1 - He's come out when he doesn't need to

2- He's called for the ball when his defender has it under control

3 - After calling for the ball he doesn't do anything and causes confusion (if you're coming and calling for it you better just take the lot)

4 - He then makes another stupid decision to get himself sent off, which effectively ended our hopes of a result and also means he now misses two important games.
 



We've seen loads of times in these situations no matter who shouted anything,sonebody takes control,the one who is nearest the ball,it looks awkward,its a throw in or a corner, move on,nothing to see.
What actually happened highlighted Robinsons lack of authority and decision making as a defender,and what Wes does is just confirming thar he thinks that way as well.
 
Hindsight is wonderful. Yes Robinson could have wellied it or wes kicked it out for a throw...but each obviously thought the other would and neither did.. shit happens..we move on and don't do it again. A bit of indecision cost us the game as the numbers worked against us. But a defeat against them was probable pre game and 4 home games on the trot favours us now so let's work on that rather than pointless recriminations
 
The goalkeeper has no business being anywhere near there with the CB in that position.

Felt for a few games now, Wes has seemed to want a bit more of the action/limelight. What he did tonight was completely unforgivable.

Hopefully after tonight's debacle, Hecky has suitably chastised him and he keeps his tail between his legs.

Can see a scenario now where Davies plays every game from now til the end of the season.
 
Dkc said:
Even after the mix-up, there was no need for the foul. Okay maybe Tella would have scored. But we would only have been 1-0 down with 11 players on the field and most of the game remaining. And Wes wouldn't be banned for two very important games.
Click to expand...
I made this point during the game. Never ceases to amaze me how players will take stupid red cards so early in the game over conceding.

Should have just let him through. I’d have fancied us to equalise.
 
Davalon said:
50/50.

Wes to start with both in needlessly coming out and then not dealing with it after he signalled to JR.

However, in the end Robbo should have taken control and cleared when he saw Wes hesitate.
Click to expand...
I thought this, but on the reverse angle in Sky it looked liked by the time JR could put his foot through it, Wes was right up on the ball so he couldn't.
It's a major fuck up, initiated by Wes. All JLT could have down is slowed down to block the attacker and let Wes boot it.
 
L1AM_SUFC said:
100% on Wes that one.

Ok you can say Robinson should have just twatted it into row Z... But at least there's some reasoning on why he didn't. His goalkeeper has come off his line and called for it. Wes would have been able to clear it up the field instead of our for a thrown in a dangerous area.

As for wes. There's absolutely no reasoning behind the multiple stupid decisions he made:

1 - He's come out when he doesn't need to

2- He's called for the ball when his defender has it under control

3 - After calling for the ball he doesn't do anything and causes confusion (if you're coming and calling for it you better just take the lot)

4 - He then makes another stupid decision to get himself sent off, which effectively ended our hopes of a result and also means he now misses two important games.
Click to expand...
3.5 He tries to dribble it out like fuckin Maradona
 
Yes, when we fuck up…we don’t half do it well. But I didn’t expect much from that game anyway. We need to be full strength (Wes aside) for all the games now, and that means McAtee. He is key to opening up defences and shares creative responsibilities with the heavily marked Illiman N’Diaye
 
LJBlade said:
A snapshot doesn’t tell the whole story.

In that imagine Robinson isn’t in a position to clear the ball and Wes is clearly indicating his intention to come for it. By the time Robinson is in a position to clear it Wes is there in front of him, looking like he’s about to get rid.
Click to expand...

how about this snapshot. robbo had 2 chances to clear it before he is even in the camera shot. wes shouldnt have confused things. but he panicked under pressure

Screenshot_20230411_095155_Twitter.jpg
 
L1AM_SUFC said:
100% on Wes that one.

Ok you can say Robinson should have just twatted it into row Z... But at least there's some reasoning on why he didn't. His goalkeeper has come off his line and called for it. Wes would have been able to clear it up the field instead of our for a thrown in a dangerous area.

As for wes. There's absolutely no reasoning behind the multiple stupid decisions he made:

1 - He's come out when he doesn't need to

2- He's called for the ball when his defender has it under control

3 - After calling for the ball he doesn't do anything and causes confusion (if you're coming and calling for it you better just take the lot)

4 - He then makes another stupid decision to get himself sent off, which effectively ended our hopes of a result and also means he now misses two important games.
Click to expand...

Exactly this. The indecision doesn't happen if the keeper doesn't come racing out of his area, shouting for the ball. It would have also given JLT the option of rolling the ball back to the keeper.
 
It's definitely Wes. If you're a defender running towards your own goal and your keeper comes running out, you leave it to him to deal with it.
 
Tella's a very quick and dangerous player well above the average level so you don't take any risk in that situation

Wes misjudged it all and created the risk and the subsequent confusion

He wouldn't have been able to do anything more than Robinson - kick it out for a throw. So he shouldn't have been near it

So a big thanks to him for making it a wasted trip for us after just 15 minutes

Robinson was double fucked because he shouldn't have been subbed either. It should have been Bogle and that it wasn't demonstrated that strange lack of understanding and judgement Hecky sometimes displays. That situation in that game cries out for Robinson, and is the most obvious possible time Bogle will be a liability and waste of space
 



You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Silky Sabella
It is not Ruben Selles fault
Replies
29
Views
1K
Boroblade1889
B
D
Same Old SameOld
Replies
3
Views
617
The Vicar
The Vicar
Jimmy Fleck
Who do we blame now?
Replies
21
Views
2K
Chris the Blade
C
B
Chris’s interview
2 3
Replies
76
Views
6K
pollster
P
Kelso
Who decided that Rueben Selles was the right manager for us.
2
Replies
45
Views
4K
djbaldken
D

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom