In the Championship in particular its more about the defence in front of you. He is a good shot stopper as you say but if he only has to stop 2 or 3 chances a game, we would have had a huge chance of doing well. In the promotion season of 22/23 he 18 clean sheets in 44 games, which goes along way to the points target, worst case that's 18 points on the table.
I don't understand the negativity around him, he was a free transfer, in a current area where the only signed on keeper is Grbic who has been linked with going too, and for some bizarre reason we are trying to sign down and extend Adam Davies who must be bordering on the most unused player of all time. As soon as Wes knew Wilder publicly didn't want him as number 1, he definitely had plenty of reasons for going which I don't blame him for. I am not saying he is the best keeper we have ever had or he was the all round keeper as he did have his faults but beggars can't be choosers and I think give it 2 or 3 seasons and we might regret not having a number 1 that has experience. At the moment its between Grbic or Davies or a Freebie/loan option...... Answers on a postcard!