I'm not saying he's a commanding CB or leader of defence. I'm saying exactly what I posted which was to challenge your view that he's going to be a squad player. He isn't, he'll be a starter unless he really drops a series of bollocks.
Yes I think we'll be looking to bring in a permanent defender now Anel has left.
You said we were wide open to aerial attack, which I would agree with, but losing Souza is no loss in that area because as you concede he wasn't good in the air anyway neither was Anel. So we're not massively behind the curve here. In fact, given we've not seen anything of the new players aerially we could be further on than we suspect but we're certainly not significantly weaker.
OK, if your opinion is that Anel was good defensively in the air, that's what it is. I disagree and I would say the evidence of the last few seasons, and how exposed we were once we lost Souttar who in fairness would be a huge miss in that area, but the drop off was so significant because Anel and Robinson are not up to standard in that area.
When we were up against inferior sides I thought Anel looked absolute class bringing the ball out, against aerially strong forwards he looked very vulnerable, as he did to pace if they looked to turn him or had decent strength. Anel was a solid Championship centre backs, and certainly one of the best if he had a top end player next to him. Without Egan and Souttar I didn't think he really stepped up and lead the defence with whoever his partner was and could look out of place against the top forwards in the league if exposed one on one.
This argument is beyond dumb to me. Why would you waste a few million "clearing them out on a free" from your budget? There's no benefit to it aside from making a meaningless gesture.