The thing I always come back to is:
How many cities the size of Sheffield could sustain a Meadowhall AND a thriving city centre for retail? Meadowhall essentially has been our city centre for years. Thereās only the Trafford Centre itās on a par with, and Manchester has always been far bigger than Sheffield. Thereās no way a Nottingham, Leicester-size city could comfortably have both.
Newcastle has the Metro Centre on its doorstep which is bigger then Meadowhall
Newcastle also has Eldon Square which is very similar in size to Meadowhall
Manchester has two larger malls than Meadowhall, the Trafford Centre and the Arndale
Birmingham has the Bullring and Merry Hill which are both bigger than Meadowhall
Liverpool One is larger than Meadowhall
Cardiff has St David's which is very similar in size to Meadowhall
Edinburgh has St James which is larger than Meadowhall
Leicester has Highcross which is only slightly smaller than Meadowhall
Glasgow has the Silverburn Centre and the East Kilbride Centre, both of which are not much smaller than Meadowhall, plus St Enoch Centre which is about two thirds the size of Meadowhall.
Leeds has three major shopping malls, Trinity, White Rose Centre, and the Merrion Centre, all of which are approximately three quarters the size of Meadowhall
Peterborough has Queensgate,
Belfast has Victoria Square
Southampton has Westquay
There are 12 shopping malls in the UK which are larger than Meadowhall
There is another dozen which are similar in size, and another 20 that are around 60-75% the size of Meadowhall