Season Review / School Report 24/25: Part 2 - Board/Club/Management

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Deadbat

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2009
Messages
6,240
Reaction score
35,080
2024/25 SUFC SEASON REVIEW / SCHOOL REPORT : Part 2



Staff report



Board / Club



Prince HRH Prince Abdullah bin Mosaad bin Abdulaziz Al Saud
I was beginning to think that he would never leave despite publicly saying he wanted to leave. It seemed like his desperation to go was such that he was willing to sell us to two investors who have ended up being less than reputable to say the least in Mauriss and Mmobuosi. That was always a worry and whilst we all accepted he could not support us with more investment, we still knew he was a relatively safe pair of hands and was not making stupid decisions and still always seemed to have us competitive at least top end Championship. Despite this the two point deduction and not paying our bills was not a good luck and the mess he oversaw for the Premier League season where we lost two key men and did not properly replace them. Furthermore, we saw many others run contracts down and saw us losing Jebbison and Bogle.





Off the field, we did finally see some potential improvements with the hotel reopen and more crucially a new training ground acquired on the old HSBC site. We also acquired the two plots of land from McCabe on the two sides of the Kop. We did seem to be trying to address the scouting/recruitment with changes being made in how we did things and personnel moving out and coming in, but these matters should have been addressed years ago and once again we had completely wasted a chance to try and cement ourselves at the top level.



There was so much talk of different American groups coming in. It seemed like it was happening and then it did not and then we heard the investors had changed. We heard from so many different sources with delays being attributed to the EFL and then Abdullah who wanted to make a percentage of any promotion income, if we went up. I had got to the point where I felt it was simply not going to happen but then whilst I was in America ironically – I saw that before Xmas it had finally gone through. It was nice to see him still talking about ‘us’ in a chat with Sheff United Way and I have no doubt he still has strong affections for the club.



The press release revealed that the new owners and co-chairmen were Helmy Eltoukhy and Steven Rosen had come in as part of the COH group which name comes from the bases of California/Ohio both Eltoukhy and Rosen are from. Eltoukhy is CEO and chairman of Guardant Health and has been influential in the medical field. Rosen has a background in the Cleveland area with several businesses. The press release talked about them taking over everything – it seemed that was of course the end of the United World links/partnership but the new owners took over the ground, hotel, training ground and everything connected to the club.

There was not real fanfare, or even a press conference. They just came in and said they backed Wilder and quickly gave him a new deal and did back him with the transfer business with some costly loans and a big money signing in Tom Cannon, coming through the door.

We saw them at the Wednesday game prior to the takeover and then they were introduced for the Burnley game but even since then we have heard little from them but they were around at the end of the season and seen at the games too such as the playoff and Wembley and tried to connect a bit more – the scarf giveaway at Wembley for instance. As a fan you want them to invest and make good decisions. So far, they have not tried to rock the boat.

Over time we had more new investors announced. The most well known was Joe Russo, who has been involved in the Marvel film franchise. Len Komoroski came in – he was another linked to the city of Cleveland and had been involved with sports teams such as the Cleveland Cavaliers. Terry Ahern, has was involved in real estate and investment.

On the surface, it seemed like they had brought in some real wealth and a range of different types of businessmen who had expertise in different fields – things you need to run a successful football club and one that hopes can not only get to the Premier League, but also stay there. They gave Wilder the long-term deal but now with us not going up – you wonder if they might get itchy fingers if we start badly next season. American owners are generally not a patient bunch and will have come here to have us in the top division and now we are another season away at least. The chatter seems to be he will be the man but you know football is fickle and he will need to get it right. They will also look at how he has conducted himself at times and the fines we have picked up for ill-discipline.



We then had two further appointments with Pejman Nozad coming in – someone who has been involved with football as a player back in his native Iran – but had since become a successful businessman in the Silicon Valley. We also then had the news that long serving CEO Stephen Bettis, named as part of the board.



Stephen Bettis
I have reference him above but he has been the one stable conduit in the change of ownership and remains someone who does get some flak but I think he has done well to remain a calm head and be the consistent day to day leader off the field and now is rewarded, with a place on the board. For a long time, he was the only real visible presence as part of the board. Certainly, the only one based in Sheffield and who is involved seemingly day to day. I think he has a thankless task but often gets hammered when he comes out and says stuff or when he does not. I actually think that compared to other CEO’s/front men we have had; he has been ok to be honest. I know we do impressions of him on the Tufty Club pod but it is very much tongue in cheek. I really do not mind him.



The current directors of both Blades Leisure Ltd, and Sheffield United Football Club Ltd are thus listed as :

  • Helmy Eltoukhy
  • Steven Rosen
  • Joe Russo
  • Len Komoroski
  • Terry Ahern
  • Pejman Nozad
  • Stephen Bettis
----



Carl Shieber, I believe is still there heading up the finances but we do not hear too much of him but he was another that seemed to be around, then leave and come back I think but has remained even with the changes. Dave McCarthy is involved still as Operations Director and we have Paul Fielder, as head of commercial who left for Huddersfield at the end of last season. Fielder was previously with Central Coast Mariners and Blackburn Rovers.



We started the season without a sponsor which was odd as there was talk of a betting company or someone that Abdullah was not happy getting into bed with such a type of business. However, we did get a new sponsor when a cryptocurrency company based in Japan, Maneki was announced as the principal sponsor. The look of the log with a cartoon cat was not the best I have to be honest but fortunately many had bought the sponsor less shirts before this change.



The kits itself were ok – I like the home strip with a nod to former kits from the 90’s and the third one – the cream one also I was a fan of. I was not convinced by the away kit – as they again tried to recreate colours from an early 90’s kit but ended up a bit of a mess I though in its execution. Once again the kits came out way too late again – the sponsor issue might have not helped but other teams have things ready almost by the end of the season and Errea have not delivered in this regard. The deal was signed in 2022 and was announced as multi deal so wonder if it might be up this year (or maybe next?). Be interesting where the new owners go with this area and of course, the sponsorship, as the Maneki deal seemed to be just for this season.



Ticketing is always a discussion point and the arguments on loyalty points rages on although there were a lot of games where people could get tickets early on in the season but then of course as we are going for promotion, it becomes harder. Season tickets went up but remain mostly competitive in terms of prices. I do feel the match day ticket prices (and way they are sold) were crazy and we saw situations where huge games like Leeds were not even sold out due to this. The playoff semi-final prices were way too high but United said the other play-off teams would not let them cap them lower – the gate receipts are shared.





Long serving groundsman; Glenn Nortcliffe and his team have continued to maintain the Desso pitch and now have two more to look after at Shirecliffe with more to come at the new HSBC site – the state of our pitch compared to our city rivals is credit to him/his team. There has been an argument that the Women should not use the pitch but we only had 19 games on it a year so surely it should be able to take more – and think it is great both men and women play here. Whether that continues with the lack of success for the women – we will see.

The club continue to do well with its social media stuff on X/Instagram etc and get the balance right between information, entertainment and humour without being too cocky like some clubs are. Although will have been embarrassed to have been hacked at the end of the season!



Unofficial Club Media




I repeat what I say every year, but also a big shout out at this point to all the unofficial stuff coming out from so many fans. Dem Blades fanzine and online stuff, The Pinch has been doing for a while now, are great reads and some brilliant writers (much better than me!). Also, we have seen some of the art stuff (we have had Arty Bianco and Shoreham Street Magnifique do some great things) has expanded with Marty Griot’s posters becoming a real talking point and feature on home match days.



I love the videos, vlogs and interviews and almost daily content, The Sheff Utd Way, keep putting out there. Even with Hal being abroad they keep bringing stuff out and a huge credit to the work of Hal and InGoodNick and of course Olly who all are brilliant at what they do. Jimmy Ramble has been quite prolific too and now seems to be a full-time gig for him. He even managed to get an interview with the Prince and has content almost every day which is impressive! He too splits opinion – I did not agreed with him ‘going live’ so soon after the Baldock tragedy – but it is good to dip in and out of all the online stuff. I am not sure I could produce/watch that much stuff but is there if you want it. If we had nothing – we would moan and most do it for free too.



Also, the American Blades, Chad and Noah, who contribute with the passionate watch alongs. It would be remiss of me not to mention the untimely passing of Johnny from Shoreham View (I went to his funeral) and still hard to get my head around that he is not around and we won’t see any of his videos anymore – at least any new ones- but it’s great to go back and watch the old ones. Still enjoy the superb podcasts/vlogs too from Blades Pod/4 Blades/Red Half of Sheffield and the stuff Travelling Blades does. All offer great analysis and entertainment. There is the Tufty Club too. I digress! Also, it is fantastic the work Rainbow Blades had done too in trying to make the club and fans more inclusive and credit to the club for recognising them and working with them too. James has rightly won more awards for his work too. Of course, S2 4SU and its moderators/creators continue to do an amazing job also along with posters like Roy and his superb view from. BladesPod also has done some great stuff on the Women’s team.



There really is some great content out there so well done all. I do not really get involved in the bashing of stuff as I say more do it for the love of the club and you can choose who/what you want to listen to, so it really is good to hear/see/watch so much great content and all are different/offer something to fans. Been fortunate enough to meet a lot of them now too and they are all fantastic and great company.



The local press sadly has still struggled in comparison to put much interesting content out in my opinion. It has got worse since Nathan Hemmingham who was one of the better ones is not involved in covering United stopped being used by Yorkshire Live was it? Ditto for Richard Sutcliffe at the Athletic who now writes for Wrexham! The others seem very stale and the likes of Hall/Biggs rarely got any inside scoops or news stories. However, I would say Danny Hall did start to get more stuff (maybe after Abdullah moved on?) and we saw more stories that he broke rather than just repeated stuff he had read/seen on the internet.



Grade C (Last season F): Hard to rate this as we have had two ownerships over the season. Abdullah did back Wilder in the summer despite moving on although there is an argument we were still left light. He also sanctioned the hotel being re-opened and the training ground acquisition but maybe the takeover took way too long and it troubled some he still wanted money (even if not around) if we went up.

The new owners were able to reward Wilder and bring in players to help the promotion push so be interesting where we go now in terms of whether we offload players and/or bring many in and try and go again? It’s nice they have quietly gone about things behind the scenes but maybe I would like more in terms of what they want to achieve and their plans?



Next season


What they do next will of course go a long way to see if this mark goes up or down. I hope they can invest and properly back us – but it’s more the infrastructure off the field (training complex, academy status, ground improvements and a plan to develop a proper strategy in terms of scouting/player recruitment) that I want to see taken on to the next level. We still seem cautious as to their plans and intentions and is very much early doors. Not sure how many really do how much money they actually have and more importantly, how much they will want to invest.





 

Manager/Coaches



Chris Wilder
I wrote this last season and was highly critical of us bringing him back and then retaining him into this season. I did not think he was the man to lead the turnaround and be part of the major changes we needed to make to get us going in the right direction. I saw little albeit in difficult circumstances that made me think that he was going to lead a resurgence. I would not have been bothered if we had parted ways again and gone in a different direction. As the summer went on, the recruitment seemed slow (not his fault) as the takeover dragged on and seemed like it was never going to happen. Slowly we started to make some smart moves (O’Hare, Burrows, Moore, Cooper etc and the loan moves or Rak Sakyi and Souttar) allied to some strange moves (McCallum. Shackleton) and after some thinking we may be nearer the bottom than the top – which seems mad now. We started to think we might be around the top 6 possibly if not as strong as the others coming down and Leeds and potentially even Boro/Norwich and West Brom. The pre-season was a bit mixed and we still had some issues with the side and with the 2-point deduction – it was imperative we got off to a good start. We started well and despite the draw with QPR, we slowly started to become a tough side to beat and the defence became miserly. He had the team spirit back again which was incredible after the hammerings we took last year and players who looked so poor and one’s many wanted out of the club – Souza and Ahmedhodzic –were outstanding and got the fans back on side. Wilder had also lowered the average age of the side and was bringing through more youngsters like Peck and Seriki.



We became hard to beat and whilst the football was not scintillating, we had a structure to be tough to beat and just use our quality to eek out goals when we needed them. It worked and we went on a long unbeaten run – until we lost to Leeds/Boro. We then started to think we might not be as good as the top teams possibly and had beaten mostly the fodder. We started to pick up injuries (Arblaster/Souttar) but continued to remain around the top and went on further long runs. We lost again to the better teams around Xmas and you thought we might pull away but he brought in reinforcements and we did the double over Wednesday. His post-match posturing saw many of the fans right behind him and we followed it up with a big win against Coventry. At this point with Leeds stuttering, I think many thought we might finish the job but had a disastrous week with losses to mediocre sides Oxford, Millwall and Plymouth. We love Wilder when we have the big wins and his pride to manage the clubs but equally when things go wrong, we hear the cocky/arrogant and stubborn man who has a chip on his shoulder. We saw him confronting fans and players at Plymouth as he seemed to have let the pressure get to him. He struggled to accept blame and his team selections/subs frustrated fans.

Big credit to him in that he rallied the troops though and got them turned round and well prepared for the playoffs. His game plan and set up v Bristol City was prefect and worked to a tee (after they had been better in the league). The final sadly saw him revert to type and we had a decent first half undone by a negative approach that ultimately cost him and us. He looked really down at full time and seeing him at the Paul Heaton concert, he looked quite emotional.

When things are going well Wilder loves the acclaim and be amongst it (pub scenes etc) and fans (including me!) lap it up ad he bring everyone together. You feel so together but when it goes wrong, we see the bitter side of him where he loses his head and does not act like how a manager/figurehead really is – I accept it will always be hard with him being in charge of the team he supports of course. The way he went off at full time at Wembley and not trying to rally his players (or fans) did not look great but ultimately sums up what he is – a fan – and needs to be more measure and professional at times but not sure he will ever change. He is what he is. When it goes well, he Is loved but things turn a bit toxic when we are struggling. I would also say the mood shift in other teams fans (not that it matters) is that he is not well liked anymore and that does reflect on the club.

It will be interesting to see what happens now moving forward. He almost surpassed everything we expected this season and built up the expectations. If we had been 5th/6th and then lost in the playoffs then maybe he would not have got the pelters but being right up there and doing well – he sadly built himself to be shot at when we imploded somewhat at the end of the season.

Wilder clearly has shown to be a good motivator and builds a team spirit/mentality but tactically not sure he and his coaching staff have developed in this side since he was last here? We won a lot of games due to the above qualities but also relied on solid defensive play and moments of magic to get narrow wins. When the defence dropped off/lost key players – we then struggled to create and if Hamer was off – it was hard to see where we got goals from. I worry whether we will always be around the top with Wilder because if what he forges and unites the players but whether he can take us on to the top level and keep us there with his lack of ideas in a tactical sense or way of changing things up.

Grade B (Last season F+)



Alan Knill Wilder clearly trusts him and takes him wherever he goes. He seems a steady and trusted lieutenant for Wilder. Seems a smashing bloke and one that is almost part of the fabric here. It is an odd one as he was lauded tactically for a long time and we had an effective set up in terms of the defensive set up to start the season. We were well organised for long periods and had a good solid shape – up to Xmas but the performances dropped off. Knill seemed less involved in the coaching on the sideline – often Wilder would take to Prestridge or Duke which was odd I felt? I also did not see much innovation in what we did in terms of how we set up/changing things and we were quite predictable at times. I was concerned when we went behind in games, we rarely had another plan to come back and often did not come back in the rare games we went behind. It was interesting that Wilder brought in someone different in Keith Andrews. He of course left but we did not replace him and I was worried that we essentially were relying on the same three. I wanted to see something different in terms of the coaching and ideas and the style of play – with some talented players – despite long winning runs - has been quite poor.



Matt Prestridge
See above with Knill. It seems whilst ever Wilder he is here, so will Knill and Prestridge. He is someone that is involved in coaching and the sport science side but not sure we have seen huge developments in our fitness levels. The stats do not bear out this thought as we were not getting beaten late on in lots of games but I often felt we had a number of players who seemed fatigued or could not last the pace. We used to be super fit and would overrun teams even in the Championship (not just League One) but that is not the case these days – maybe we have signed a number of players who have not been able to be up with the pace or missed too many games.



Jack Lester Hearing about the work he was doing with Campbell and the other strikers, clearly shows how much of an influence he can be to the forwards and he seems to be more involved than he used to be – of course used to the Academy lead and now is firmly entrenched in the first team set up. Was credited with some of the set plays (step over goal for Hamer) in the playoffs.



Matt Collins was pushed up the first team after being involved in the u21’s. Collins had been manager briefly at Bradford and clearly had impressed Wilder and Knill etc in that he was moved up and now is on the first team staff.



Tom Little
is still the club's head of performance in the summer of 2022 and still as listed as being around despite the incoming staff and the poor medical record at the club.



Matt Duke is still United's goalkeeping coach. This again a job he kind of fell into when Darren Ward moved on (now part of the England women’s set up by the way) -Duke was an academy coach and much like Hecky and Lester was bumped up after the changes but concerns me if he had anything to do with the Grbic signing but maybe, he made up for it, if he helped us identify Cooper!



Gary McSheffrey is now the u21 coach. The former Coventry player who also spent a fair bit of time towards the end of his career in the area – at Doncaster – was put in charge as Collins stepped up to be involved in the first team,



Jim O’Brien
was put in charge of the u18’s at the start of the season after Matt Thorpe moved on to be part of the England junior set up (u15 assistant coach). O’Brien, from Scotland, had been a player locally at Barnsley but played for a number of clubs after coming through at his home town club, Celtic. He had been a coach at Notts County under Luke Williams before leaving after he moved to Swansea.



The medical department had a change in that we appointed Bryan English – who has worked with a number of clubs and was with Wilder at Boro. Still there is Steve Humphries, Ryan Flanagan, Joe Sowden, Chris Senior, Paul Evans and Iain Worton. The club doctors are Dr Alex Worthington and Dr Subhashis Basu.



The first team management is still supported by Lee McMahon, Nathan Winder and Carl Hopwood and Adam Geelan are the kitmen. We also have a chef Matt Dale supported by Adrian Ogden with Elliott Frankland leading the clubs nutritional needs.



We do have an analyst department led by Mikey Allen who returned as head of recruitment. The analyst team is led by Hayden Whiting with Michael Cooper (not the keeper) and Liam McLaughlin supporting.



Jamie Hoyland was brought in as chief scout along with Allen as they head up the recruitment. I was sceptical of these changes as Allen and Hoyland had been around before and maybe wanted something fresh and innovative, but the signings of Cooper/Burrows have been superb and even the likes of Campbell has worked out.



The signings of the two lads in January was interesting as the club discussed the new data driven system they were using -which seemed to be borne out of the new ownership group. Wilder might be a bit old school and clearly has his favourites (as all managers do) of players he likes/trusts and maybe his over reliance on British players is a fair point. Hopefully we can develop how we scout/recruit (regardless of how long Wilder is here). We have heard recently links with an American, James Bord (a poker player), who is meant to be leading on the way we recruit – we have seen this in it’s infancy with the two signings in January, so be interesting if we do go down this route moving forward. I think sadly though, that in today’s day and age most well-run clubs know about every player around the world ands there are less secrets. Of course, as Brentford and Brighton, have proved, you can get some players and then sell them on for huge profits.







Next season



As I write this, I do not see anything but Wilder coming back. There has been a lot of talk about whether we need to move on and try something different but you only have to look at Luton to see where things have gone wrong for another side who came down last season. The way we fell away at the end of course makes it seem like he failed but if we had finished say 5th/6th and steadily moved up the league and missed out, it would have been a different narrative. We (he) did far better than I thought we would have done. I never would have thought us getting 90 (92) points and go so close to promotion (twice). However, the overriding thought is we did all that work and missed out and have the notion we did blow it. His tactics when it mattered (despite all the points) were not great and the football on the whole was poor to watch despite the wins. I worry, that he is not the Wilder we had of a few years ago that was forward thinking and innovative and seems more cautious and pragmatic. That is fine if we had gone up, but we didn’t. The overall entertainment was not great. He quoted stats when it suited but I would say that a lot of teams would be very envious of our records and how well we did. Still at the end of the day, it all counts for nothing now. Does not matter what records Wilder throws out now – we are back on 0 and have to start again. Will be interesting what happens over the summer – I worry his recruitment is poor (Burrows, Cooper and O’Hare excellent but January was on the whole a bit of a disaster) and the profile of players is away from the modern game – needing pace and athleticism. I do not trust him to bring the players in to improve the way we play and how attacking we can be. We will see. My gut feeling is he remains but if he gets a poor start then the crowd will become even more divided and be interesting to see what the board does.
 
I thought the recruitment in the summer was really good. I think it would be harsh to say otherwise and not every signing will work out, but many of them did.
Good signings : O'Hare, Burrows, Cooper, Moore, Campbell along with loans, Souttar, Rak-Sakyi
Ok signings : McCallum plus Gilchrist
Not so great : Shackleton

There's probably a couple I've missed too.
 
I think the summer business was decent to good.

Burrows, Campbell and Cooper excellent business.
Souttar a really good loan also.

O'Hare, JRS and Moore were ok but I was a bit disappointed in them overall. The latter had an awful PO final and rarely fit. O'Hare and JRS also were taken out of the team. Both on huge wages and didn't nail down a place when it mattered.

McCallum was very meh.
Gilchrist lost his place.
Shackleton a waste of resources

January was a disaster though. Owners backed CW.

Cannon dreadful and a complete waste if money.

Holding did not get in the team despite Robinson's form.

BBD not a regular, not fit and not player wd saw last season..

Clarke was poor and then injured.

Choudhury was decent tbf.

5 came in and only 1 got in the team or made a decent impact.

So 15 signings. 4 or 5 good. 4 or 5 OK. 7 little to no impact for me.
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom