Eric Cartman
Active Member
- Banned
- #121
Oh I don't check Wiki when I'm comparing players I use whoscored - gives you a breakdown of a players actual play. I admit players can do a lot of off the ball work that isn't noted, and Washington does. He works hard and runs the channels. But he just doesn't score goals at Championship level - that's the top and bottom of it - we already have Lavery for that.You're bemoaning that he's down in the pecking order, and his goal record at championship is poor - I understand that.
However, that doesn't tell the story. People (not saying this is definetly you) have a tendency to check Wikipedia for his goal ratio, and jump to a conclusion.
I think there are plenty of reasons why this could actually be a decent signing.
And as for Matt Smith, I think he's probably a more clinical player than Washington and may have scored more goals, but let's be honest: we'd have to adjust our style of play: he's a target man, and nothing more unfortunately.
When I've seen him before I've thought he's not actually a bad player, especially for Peterborough - but he just doesn't score goals at this level.
I just can't pretend I think it's a good signing or get excited about it when we've been linked with much better names all summer and consistently said we're only after players who improve us - and ended up with QPR's 5th choice. Had we signed him earlier in the window I probably wouldn't be as disappointed.