Booker4
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2015
- Messages
- 8,704
- Reaction score
- 12,502
No I can't compare them. And in turn I can't compare Maguire and Murphy to the likes of Walker and Jags. Why? Because our transfer policy is wank and people that defend it are wank and Che's "replacement" will be another step down
In my view some transfers I've agreed with, others not. For example I don't blame to club for selling Maguire and Murphy because they had spent a few seasons playing League One and were understandably looking to better themselves. I understood why we sold Naughton too for similar reasons, but I disagreed with Walker going too, he'd only played 6 games and we sold him for nowhere near we could have, had he stayed longer. I'll not debate all the transfers but in essence some seemed understandable, but plenty not. I think its harsh to say the fans who defend the clubs policy are wank, but I understand your frustrations. We all thought selling Slew was bad, but look at how that turned out! Of course had he stayed maybe he would have been a much better player now but I do think that the players themselves often move for the wrong reasons and then their career stutters. Blackman and Slew fit into that bracket, although Blackman recovered, Slew hasn't.
If we get £2m plus for Adams, who could still very much go either way then I think we can't blame the club for selling, knowing how Adams is now, not for what he might be in the future.