I understand your sentiment Robbie but be fair it's not very rational. It could be summarised as,
'If you don't earn much but try hard you can be rewarded with alcohol. But if you earn a bit and don't try as hard (as I would like ) you should not be allowed alcohol?'
Rather an odd approach given your paragraph on the detrimental effects of alcohol?
It could be condensed even more to,
'I'm fed up we aren't doing very well so you should be punished by not being allowed a night out.'
And what's this about a paid holiday?
Sitwell said much the same

and saw the flaw in your argument.
Oh and just for clarification, I am not in anyway condoning or excusing behavior that may be referred to as an 'incident' and lead to a club statement!