Andy Reid!!!!

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

I must admit that United has surprised me with this deal, and i'm chuffed with his signing. I've still been disappointed all week with the Doncaster performance but i'm pleased to see that United have grasped the bull by the horns and managed to pull this deal off. It must have been hard to keep it under wraps as i imagine he would walk in to most Championship sides, and all the top end of the Championship will have been interested in signing him. So from me its a big well done United.

He is a player of proven class, and whenever i have seen him play against United he has been good and a stand out player. The only concern i have is that he has a tendancy to put weight on, and isn't the most mobile of players but he has class and hopefully that will shine through.
 



He is a player of proven class, and whenever i have seen him play against United he has been good and a stand out player. The only concern i have is that he has a tendancy to put weight on, and isn't the most mobile of players but he has class and hopefully that will shine through.

He might be a bit of a fatty bum-bum, but so was Shipperly, and he was bloody brilliant for us. Anyway, all the chicks like a fat lad.:D
 
In response to the 2 above posts. I have seen enough of Reid over his career to make a judgement. He has just signed and hence how many matches I have been to is completely and utterly irrelevant. Reid is over weight, injury prone and slow.

What was that bit about an attention seeking Whore?

Love sniggers imagine one person sat at his computer.

The question is not irrelevevant. you just refuse to answer because you've been to not enough games to make a judgement for yourself on the Blades.
If you judge Andy reid like Glynn Hodges then most Nearly all Blades would say 'god if he's like Glynn hodges then we've got a gem'.
On the other hand if you view Glynn Hodges as crap then that also points to how crap your judgement is and just puts in to context how pathetic your posting have been.
As pointed out before, on here we have intelligent posters who attend games and can make their own conclusions. They dont have to have some self appointed Devils Advocate to stir in to life their brains especially one who gets his information second hand and makes a judgement from what - say - Andy giddins said on the radio.

So just so we can get a clear picture of ALL YOUR JUDGMENTS IN OTHER THREADS ON HERE.

How many Home games have you been to this season to see the Blades ?
How many away games have you been to this season to see the Blades ?
How many other teams have you been to see this season?
 
What was that bit about an attention seeking Whore?

Love sniggers imagine one person sat at his computer.

The question is not irrelevevant. you just refuse to answer because you've been to not enough games to make a judgement for yourself on the Blades.
If you judge Andy reid like Glynn Hodges then most Nearly all Blades would say 'god if he's like Glynn hodges then we've got a gem'.
On the other hand if you view Glynn Hodges as crap then that also points to how crap your judgement is and just puts in to context how pathetic your posting have been.
As pointed out before, on here we have intelligent posters who attend games and can make their own conclusions. They dont have to have some self appointed Devils Advocate to stir in to life their brains especially one who gets his information second hand and makes a judgement from what - say - Andy giddins said on the radio.

So just so we can get a clear picture of ALL YOUR JUDGMENTS IN OTHER THREADS ON HERE.

How many Home games have you been to this season to see the Blades ?
How many away games have you been to this season to see the Blades ?
How many other teams have you been to see this season?

Deep down you know the answer to that.

To be honest Ollessendro is the one poster on here i'm sick to the back teeth of. It seems to me that he only posts on here because he likes the attention. Every man and his dog on here knows that things aren't brilliant, but to go on incessantly about it day in, day out with the same old boring crap trotted out is quite frankly boring.
 
Deep down you know the answer to that.

To be honest Ollessendro is the one poster on here i'm sick to the back teeth of. It seems to me that he only posts on here because he likes the attention. Every man and his dog on here knows that things aren't brilliant, but to go on incessantly about it day in, day out with the same old boring crap trotted out is quite frankly boring.
top post brownie
 
the whole 'one month' loan deal thing is out of our hands... pretty sure one of the rules of the loan window is after a certain date a loan can only be a month, but can be extended after
 
I wouldn't expect this to be a changing of formations we've needed another footballer in the team (we actually need a few more) I would expect him to replace Quinny in the middle of the park.
Although obviously he can also play out wide instead of Cresswell but will Yeates keep his place?
 
Yeates has to keep his place Bob, I would go;

Simmo

Calve
Morgan
Bartley
Taylor, (unless Jordan is fit)

Yeates
Britton
Ertl
Reid

Ward
Evans/Bogdanovic

But I have a feeling Nosworthy and Cresswell will still start.......
 
If you're not remotley inspired by us signing a player that has played above and been out of our reach for most of his career, and is still only 28, then I suggest you find another interest. You've got a very disappointing life ahead.....:D

UTB

Back in Jan 06 there was a school of thought who considered the signings of two from Reid, Koumas and Beattie would have kept us up. At that time, none of the three were out of our reach. Fleety and Dunc, however, were utterly convinced that the signings of Shelton, Seck and Fathi could only bring sunshine and happines for evermore...
 
Back in Jan 06 there was a school of thought who considered the signings of two from Reid, Koumas and Beattie would have kept us up. At that time, none of the three were out of our reach. Fleety and Dunc, however, were utterly convinced that the signings of Shelton, Seck and Fathi could only bring sunshine and happines for evermore...

some people are easy pleased.....must be.
 
Will be very interesting to see where reid play. I personally, would like to see him down the middle. However, if he plays wide, then we are going to need a good box man down the MIDDLE! for me that has to be Cresswell. For all his criticism, he has been playing out of position and from what i see Boggy isnt a great header of the ball and Jamie Ward....well... lets just say not renound for his heading either!

I'd go:

Lowton Morgan Bartley Jordan
Yeates Britton Reid Ward
Cresswell Boggy

I suspect though:

Calve Morgan Nozza Taylor
Yeates Britton Quinn Reid
Boggy Ward
 
Would definitely go for 2 wide men (Yeates and Ward?) with Reid and Britton pulling the strings in the middle. Although maybe that's a bit lightweight? A holding midfielder behind Reid and Britton with only 1 up front (Boggy) might be more attacking than it sounds ...

Something like:
Simmo
Calve, Morgs, Bartley, Jordan
Ertl
Ward,Britton, Reid, Yeates
Boggy

Ward and Yeates pushing on when we attack makes it a 4-1-2-3 formation or Ertl can pull back as an extra defender if Calve or Jordan get caught ... Ertl playing as a holding midfielder gives Britton and Reid licence to push on as well as allowing the full backs to offer support going forward. Also there's goals in Ward,Yeates,Reid and Boggy if they've the freedom to push forward.

---------- Post added at 10:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:36 AM ----------

obviously Simmo, Ertl and Boggy are meant to be in the centre but I can't get them there it won't let me "tab" across. This management lark is feckin difficult
 
What about;

Simonsen
Lowton-Morgan-Bartley-Jordan
Calve-Britton-Reid-Yeates
Ward-Evans/Bogdanovic

Try Calve in midfield as his defensive quality can be questioned, but is good going forward. Britton to sit just in front of the defence with Reid pushing up.
 



Did you see his last appearance at the Lane for Charlton where he ran the game for them?

He has genuine class and we won't get anyone better in.

Wasn't that back in 2007/8? And wasn't that the year Charlton went down?

I suspect they've just juggled the De Laet wages to fund this deal.

Which then probably suggests De Laet aint coming back

However, the fact Bartley can be recalled should they choose, it doesn't surprise me.

Makes sense. Although I'm unconvinced of Reid, I'm happy Speed has finally signed an attacking player, rather than another defender. From De Laets last few performances I'm not too upset that he doesn't apear to be coming back.

I know what you mean about Irish footballers George Best and Roy Keane weren't very good either.

Yep, 2 of the handful of decent Irish players to have ever played football.

I think that comment was tongue in cheek ghandi, mind you I do think Ollies posts are getting less and less interesting. I used to look forward to his posts, he made some relevant points, most of which I disagreed with, but they were often good points. Alas not these days.

Mick, that hurts :(

Let's not forget Paul McGrath, but he probably didn't see him play either!

Yes, you can add Paul McGrath to that (very small) list. And don't forget Irelands greatest ever player, Liam (Chipper) Brady. Still, can anyone name any more?

Oh and I did see Paul Mac play. He is the grestest defender that I've seen put on a Blades shirt (with the possible exception of Jags) and even at 38 (back in 07/08 I think?) he was absolute class.

wonder if he's any good with a hammer ?

Great idea BB. I might write to Birch and see if he'll release for the day to help wi mi shed.

Waited 3 months for what? What the hell is Calve then? He's more attack minded than Jamie Ward and he's supposed to be a full back, that said, I reckon he'd be a great RW. You can't argue with the Forward thinking, but the defensive side is looking a bit aged. Maybe at this stage it's experience we need at the back.

Calve is a light weight right back, with limited ability at defending (his main job) and whilst he looked decent at first, he has looked poor of late going forward.

What was that bit about an attention seeking Whore?

Love sniggers imagine one person sat at his computer.

The question is not irrelevevant. you just refuse to answer because you've been to not enough games to make a judgement for yourself on the Blades.
If you judge Andy reid like Glynn Hodges then most Nearly all Blades would say 'god if he's like Glynn hodges then we've got a gem'.
On the other hand if you view Glynn Hodges as crap then that also points to how crap your judgement is and just puts in to context how pathetic your posting have been.
As pointed out before, on here we have intelligent posters who attend games and can make their own conclusions. They dont have to have some self appointed Devils Advocate to stir in to life their brains especially one who gets his information second hand and makes a judgement from what - say - Andy giddins said on the radio.

So just so we can get a clear picture of ALL YOUR JUDGMENTS IN OTHER THREADS ON HERE.

How many Home games have you been to this season to see the Blades ?
How many away games have you been to this season to see the Blades ?
How many other teams have you been to see this season?

my my. All this posts says is that you don't like me. I am merley stating an opinion. Your (attempted) victimisation is becoming as tedious to me, as my posts are to Brownie.

why does it matter how much I've been to the Lane this season for me to make a judgement on a player that has never played in a United shirt before? I don't rate the guy. Has nothing to do with how many times I've been to BDTBL recently.

Deep down you know the answer to that.

To be honest Ollessendro is the one poster on here i'm sick to the back teeth of. It seems to me that he only posts on here because he likes the attention. Every man and his dog on here knows that things aren't brilliant, but to go on incessantly about it day in, day out with the same old boring crap trotted out is quite frankly boring.

win some, lose some.
 
What was that bit about an attention seeking Whore?

Love sniggers imagine one person sat at his computer.

The question is not irrelevevant. you just refuse to answer because you've been to not enough games to make a judgement for yourself on the Blades.
If you judge Andy reid like Glynn Hodges then most Nearly all Blades would say 'god if he's like Glynn hodges then we've got a gem'.
On the other hand if you view Glynn Hodges as crap then that also points to how crap your judgement is and just puts in to context how pathetic your posting have been.
As pointed out before, on here we have intelligent posters who attend games and can make their own conclusions. They dont have to have some self appointed Devils Advocate to stir in to life their brains especially one who gets his information second hand and makes a judgement from what - say - Andy giddins said on the radio.

So just so we can get a clear picture of ALL YOUR JUDGMENTS IN OTHER THREADS ON HERE.

How many Home games have you been to this season to see the Blades ?
How many away games have you been to this season to see the Blades ?
How many other teams have you been to see this season?

my my. All this posts says is that you don't like me. I am merley stating an opinion. Your (attempted) victimisation is becoming as tedious to me, as my posts are to Brownie.

why does it matter how much I've been to the Lane this season for me to make a judgement on a player that has never played in a United shirt before? I don't rate the guy. Has nothing to do with how many times I've been to BDTBL recently.

How could i not like someone i haven't met? surley i'd be making a judgment without real communication or insite into the person? A few disagreements on here and the odd agreement would make me pathetic for doing so wouldnt they?


I do suggest you read the bit in capitals about other threads on this forum. the question has been asked of you several times and you constantly avoid answering. I could draw a conclusion from that, that you are embarrassed to answer?
And within your reply to this i still will get the avoidance.
 
Deep down you know the answer to that.

To be honest Ollessendro is the one poster on here i'm sick to the back teeth of. It seems to me that he only posts on here because he likes the attention. Every man and his dog on here knows that things aren't brilliant, but to go on incessantly about it day in, day out with the same old boring crap trotted out is quite frankly boring.

Agreed. It has become really boring and tedious, and he does it on virtually every thread. In my opinion, he has single handedly ruined a very good forum. A shame, because he used to make decent posts, but has become a sad parody of himself over the last few weeks.
 
How could i not like someone i haven't met? surley i'd be making a judgment without real communication or insite into the person? A few disagreements on here and the odd agreement would make me pathetic for doing so wouldnt they?


I do suggest you read the bit in capitals about other threads on this forum. the question has been asked of you several times and you constantly avoid answering. I could draw a conclusion from that, that you are embarrassed to answer?
And within your reply to this i still will get the avoidance.

Plenty of others do it on here Boo. But I'd like to think that you see our little tiffles as light hearted banter.

I refuse to answer your pointless questions, because I think that they are irrelevant. I am not embarassed, as I have been open that I have been concentrating on building my shed, rather than events at BDTBL. It's funny that you don't question anybody else on this issue, but have some things about gunning for me. So, why do you keep asking? It is essentially an attempt at victimisation, but luckily gorillas have thick skin. On a slight aside (I feel this is fair as your questions are an side to this Andy Reid thread) have you read the comprehensive spending review document released by the Treasury and did you listen to all George Osbourne's speach? I wondered if you had an opinion on the spending cuts too?
 
I'm just letting it all wash over me in a kind of "fuck it" vibe. I know it's crap at the Lane but there's nowt I can do about it, so let's let fate decide. Peace and harmony to all, except students.:D

Mind you, it's easy to dislike someone you haven't met. I've not met Gordon Brown or Nick Griffin, but I don't like either of them, the swivel-eyed loons.
 
Why are you gob smacked? I find faults in eveything to do with SUFC :D Oh and the Irish are not very good at football.

I see keane, and best have had a mention.

what about Robbie Keane, damien duff, shay given, niall quinn, keeeeeef!, dare i say it, paddy kenny.
 
Most composed player on pitch when he came on. Shows how far we've got to go though how on earth did he end up so deep.
 



All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom