Mine would be:
Hodgkinson (Naturally)
Len Badger (Classiest RB)
Graham Shaw (Classiest LB)
Joe Shaw (seemingly psychic sweeper)
Phil Jagielka (a legend still in the making)
Denis Mortimer(pure class, even at the age he was with us)
Trevor Hockey (Midfield destroyer/ ball winner)
Tony Currie (no comments required, he could "walk on water")
Alan Woodward( awesome winger, striker and midfielder)
Brian Deane ( possibly the best £15K buy ever)
Mick Jones (local boy, big, strong, brave and skillful)
Subs
Tom McAllister ( United career curtailed with serious injuries, otherwise the stuff of would-be legend)
Peter Ndlovu (Sharpest ball skills ever seen in a United Shirt)
Jimmy Hagan (an obvious legend but I only saw him in testimonials)
Alex Sabella (much too good for the players that he has round him at the time for us to benefit fully from his talent)
I have seen other legends (elsewhere) at our club, but mostly past their best by the time that they came here such as Thomson & Rush (ex Liverpool), wee Jimmy Johnston (Celtic), McGrath ( Man U & Villa), Gordon Cowans, and Martin Peters to name a few. They would certainly figure had they played for us in their peak
This list is obviously just an opinion, but a considered one at that
PS How many of the above would we need to make the current team worth watching?