FTPE
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2014
- Messages
- 9,920
- Reaction score
- 17,959
Thats class cheers.Defender Season Comparison – Defensive & Passing Profile
Japhet Tanganga (Millwall, 24/25)
Strengths:
- Very durable (40 games, 3,552 mins)
- Strong defensive duels (37 tackles won, 36 INT)
- Aerial solidity (63.7%)
- Passing: decent medium range (87.9%)
- Progressive passes: 83 total, respectable given Millwall’s style
Weaknesses:
- Overall pass accuracy lowest here (77.3%)
- Long passing weak (53.7%)
- Few creative passes: just 5 key passes, 8 passes into penalty area
- Negative value on xA (underperformed passing creativity)
- Limited attacking outlet
Jack Robinson (Sheff Utd, 24/25)
Strengths:
- Big on/off impact (+17 GD)
- Passing: high accuracy (82.5% overall, 94% short, 90% medium)
- Reliable in buildup: 88 progressive passes
- Carries high volume (97 final third entries)
Weaknesses:
- Discipline: 9 yellows, 2 OGs
- Long passing shaky (50.4%)
- Low creative threat (10 key passes, only 1 pass into penalty area)
- More of a recycler than a progressive distributor
Ben Mee (Brentford, 22/23)
Strengths:
- Veteran presence, strong influence (+16 GD, +9.2 xG)
- Pass accuracy respectable (76.5% overall, 85.4% short, 82.7% medium)
- Reliable long passer (53.5%)
- Some progressive intent: 84 progressive passes
- Composed: 1 assist, 8 key passes
Weaknesses:
- Lowest completion rate of the four (76.5%)
- Passing distribution safe, rarely line-breaking
- Creativity limited (only 7 passes into penalty area)
- Big aerial volume but only 57.2% success
Bobby Thomas (Coventry, 24/25)
Strengths:
- Ever-present (38 games, 3,334 mins)
- Best aerial record (66.5%)
- Balanced defender: 38 INT, 32 tackles won
- Strong passing stats: 81.7% overall, 89–90% short/medium
- Most progressive: 132 progressive passes (highest of group)
- Enters attacking third a lot (139 entries)
Weaknesses:
- Slightly more turnovers due to risk-taking (long passing 46.0%)
- Accuracy lower than Robinson when pressed
- Some discipline issues: 22 fouls, 1 OG
- Creative passing not sharp (only 7 key passes despite high progressions)
Passing Rankings:
- Most Progressive: Bobby Thomas (132 progressive passes, highest of group)
- Most Accurate: Jack Robinson (82.5% overall, elite short/medium)
- Best Long Passing: Ben Mee (53.5%, consistent outlet)
- Weakest Passing Profile: Japhet Tanganga (low accuracy, poor long passing, limited creativity)
I suppose it depends on partnerships and whether Selles wants a ball winner and a ball player separately. An all-rounder is way out of our price range. You dont get Prime JOC's for under £20m anymore.