Sheffield United vs Queens Park Rangers

  • xa_prs_kickoff Match date
  • Bramall Lane, Sheffield
  • Att: 26,636

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Status
Ratings for this match closed
1664739506189.png vs. 1664739513361.png

Championship Week 13 - Tuesday 4th October 2022 - 19:45 - Bramall Lane
Please keep all discussion related to the match within this thread.



Matchday Stats/Player Ratings - https://www.s24su.com/forum/match-day/match/sheffield-united-vs-queens-park-rangers.617/

Officials:

Referee: James Linington
Assistant Referee: Shaun Hudson
Assistant Referee: Mark Stevens
Fourth Official: Stephen Martin

Coverage:

Follow via S24SU Twitter: https://twitter.com/s24su

Need a VPN? - https://www.s24su.com/forum/threads/vpn-usage.87094/

1664739656111.png


📺
Live TV Coverage:

SUTV Live - https://live.sufc.co.uk/

Screenshot 2022-10-02 at 20.41.34.png
 


First half fine, second half just disjointed with baffling subs. How Doyle was janked as opposed to Berge is beyond me, and giving Baldock 90 seconds, if that, just wastes a sub window for zero reason
 
Couldn't open them up or get in behind them, and didn't work their keeper enough...We weren't that bad, just the final ball really.. They were a threat on the break, and defended well tbf.. Soft goal, but it happens..Hopefully get back on track v Stoke.
 
Disappointing. Started well and dominated the first half without creating too much. Ndiaye should have hit the target with a chance he created for himself. We were in and around their box a lot and they only broke a couple of times but it was a little worrying how easy they got through us. Second half looked like it was going to carry on the same but we stood off them way too much and they scored thanks to slack defending and terrible keeping. They has a few chances when they just seemed to play through us way too easily. We didn't have much to throw at them. we looked tired and short of idea. players on different wavelengths and poor final balls.

Wes - 5 - Saved a standard chance with his legs and claimed a couple but little to do. Terrible on the goal. Beaten at his near post. Seemed to leave it thinking it was going wide.
Bogle - 6 - He looks dangerous going forward and good to see him back starting. His decision making was poor tonight though and he struggled a bit with where he should be playing on the wrong side. Tired badly before coming off.
RND - 7 - Our best defender but I wish he'd stop doing the daft things. Made a crucial interception and fought all night.
Egan - 5.5 - Daft booking and I had my hands over my eyes when he took the (usual) heavy touch and tackle. Should have done much better with a free header.
Basham - 5.5 - Thought he looked a bit iffy under not the greatest amount of pressure. Slow on the ball at times as well.
Baldock - 5 - Worrying he looks to be injured. Poor delivery going forward again and got caught a couple of times with sloppy passes.
Doyle - 6.5 - Looks buy and put in a great sliding block. Does a lot of things well but needs to build his fitness up. Blowing after 55 minutes and taken off again.
Norwood - 7 - Probably our MOM without being that good. Had a good shot well saved and kept trying to get us moving. Need to stop with the high dinked passes all the time. They can work really well but shouldn't be an automatic. Put in a shift defensively as well.
Berge - 5 - Started really strongly and even did some defending. Looked about 80 years old after about 60 minutes and just got slower and slower. Worrying he finished the game getting treatment but he needs to be stronger and more switched on.
Ndiaye - 5.5 - Poor game from him tonight had a great run in the first half but shot off-target when he should have done better. He could use a rest, I think. Nowhere near as influential over the last two games.
McBurnie - 5.5 - Another who looks tired and it wasn't really his night. Made me laugh when that throughball hit his head and bounced out,

Subs

Khadra - 6 - Mixed. He put some great early crosses in but no one really making the runs. Needs to be more determined when on the ball. Had several one on ones and just passed it inside.
Brewster - 5 - Ran around but wasn't really involved. Gone very quiet since he came back from injury
Sharp - 5.5 - Made runs and got in positions but not really that influential
McAtee - 5.5 - Sat on the left wing and put a decent cross in but it was all a bit predictable

Hecky - 5 - We have a lot of tired player and a lot of injuries and he looks to be struggling for options. If Baldock is now injured then we're one in, one out. I'd have gone to 4 at the back and even played wingers when Baldock went off. QPR sat back and there was little room though. We're painfully short in the middle and lack players to boss midfield. You could argue that Arblaster should have replaced Berge but we're lacking legs in that area.

QPR - They had a plan and stuck to it. While we dominated possession first half we hardly caused Dieng any problems. They defended really well though.
 
Disappointing. Started well and dominated the first half without creating too much. Ndiaye should have hit the target with a chance he created for himself. We were in and around their box a lot and they only broke a couple of times but it was a little worrying how easy they got through us. Second half looked like it was going to carry on the same but we stood off them way too much and they scored thanks to slack defending and terrible keeping. They has a few chances when they just seemed to play through us way too easily. We didn't have much to throw at them. we looked tired and short of idea. players on different wavelengths and poor final balls.

Wes - 5 - Saved a standard chance with his legs and claimed a couple but little to do. Terrible on the goal. Beaten at his near post. Seemed to leave it thinking it was going wide.
Bogle - 6 - He looks dangerous going forward and good to see him back starting. His decision making was poor tonight though and he struggled a bit with where he should be playing on the wrong side. Tired badly before coming off.
RND - 7 - Our best defender but I wish he'd stop doing the daft things. Made a crucial interception and fought all night.
Egan - 5.5 - Daft booking and I had my hands over my eyes when he took the (usual) heavy touch and tackle. Should have done much better with a free header.
Basham - 5.5 - Thought he looked a bit iffy under not the greatest amount of pressure. Slow on the ball at times as well.
Baldock - 5 - Worrying he looks to be injured. Poor delivery going forward again and got caught a couple of times with sloppy passes.
Doyle - 6.5 - Looks buy and put in a great sliding block. Does a lot of things well but needs to build his fitness up. Blowing after 55 minutes and taken off again.
Norwood - 7 - Probably our MOM without being that good. Had a good shot well saved and kept trying to get us moving. Need to stop with the high dinked passes all the time. They can work really well but shouldn't be an automatic. Put in a shift defensively as well.
Berge - 5 - Started really strongly and even did some defending. Looked about 80 years old after about 60 minutes and just got slower and slower. Worrying he finished the game getting treatment but he needs to be stronger and more switched on.
Ndiaye - 5.5 - Poor game from him tonight had a great run in the first half but shot off-target when he should have done better. He could use a rest, I think. Nowhere near as influential over the last two games.
McBurnie - 5.5 - Another who looks tired and it wasn't really his night. Made me laugh when that throughball hit his head and bounced out,

Subs

Khadra - 6 - Mixed. He put some great early crosses in but no one really making the runs. Needs to be more determined when on the ball. Had several one on ones and just passed it inside.
Brewster - 5 - Ran around but wasn't really involved. Gone very quiet since he came back from injury
Sharp - 5.5 - Made runs and got in positions but not really that influential
McAtee - 5.5 - Sat on the left wing and put a decent cross in but it was all a bit predictable

Hecky - 5 - We have a lot of tired player and a lot of injuries and he looks to be struggling for options. If Baldock is now injured then we're one in, one out. I'd have gone to 4 at the back and even played wingers when Baldock went off. QPR sat back and there was little room though. We're painfully short in the middle and lack players to boss midfield. You could argue that Arblaster should have replaced Berge but we're lacking legs in that area.

QPR - They had a plan and stuck to it. While we dominated possession first half we hardly caused Dieng any problems. They defended really well though.
I mainly agree but just don't understand how athletes who play only twice a week can be tired.
 
Very bad tonight. Got to move on from it.
 
Couldn't open them up or get in behind them, and didn't work their keeper enough...We weren't that bad, just the final ball really.. They were a threat on the break, and defended well tbf.. Soft goal, but it happens..Hopefully get back on track v Stoke.

Thats my assessment too. We played reasonably well until we got near their goal.
A mixture of poor final ball and great defending from them.

Don't feel too downhearted because it's not like it was a smash and grab.
It was a fairly even game overall, QPR looked a good team and arguably deserved their win.

It's one defeat, we're still top of the league and we look for a reaction in the next game.
Positives were thought Khadra and McAtee looked bright, quick feet and little tricks. Also thought Bogle showed promise, when he's up to speed he'll be a big payer for us and we have Ahmedhodzic coming back and he gives us a new dimension.
 

Frustrating night, pretty much a blueprint away performance from QPR.

Against counter attacking teams, we really struggle if we don't get the first goal. The first half was our chance to win this game.

There are a few concerns as we go into 2 winnable games followed by a tough run:

Anel's absence is hurting us so much. It's being compounded by Basham being waaay off his own standards. With Baldock taking a heavy knock and Basham struggling with what looked his left groin/knee, I've absolutely no idea what the backline will be at Stoke.

Ndiaye and Berge have had two poor games, by their standards, since the international break. A rest, a refresh, change things up...whatever you want to call it, they shouldn't have played 180 mins each.

Doyle is becoming an easy option to hook and tonight is third time it's had the opposite effect. PNE away we were awful without him, and we dropped 2 gears in these last 2 home games after he went off. PH isn't daft, Berge was noticeably out of steam on Saturday and both Berge and Norwood were levels below Doyle tonight...are we avoiding subbing them in favour of a loan player so it doesn't hurt their confidence? Others have mentioned he's not fit, really? He started 3 in a row before the PNE experiment and was buzzing for the U21s.

Sharp and Brewster have made 2 poor contributions off the bench this week. We need someone to step up, McBurnie isn't going to keep this purple patch going forever and he's not going to play 90 every week either. Sharp is coming back to fitness, but I'm worried about Brewster.

The substitutions, in general, are also hurting us. There's confusion about where to play Khadra and McAtee, and who to play them with. We look disjointed no matter who comes on, when they come and who they come on for.

We've been on a great run and got some deserved results. There's now a chasing pack trying to suck us in and we need to be wiser to avoid that happening. Players coming back will help but subs need to be much better.
 
Last edited:
Frustrating night, pretty much a blueprint away performance from QPR.

Against counter attacking teams, we really struggle if we don't get the first goal. The first half was our chance to win this game.

There are a few concerns as we go into 2 winnable games followed by a tough run:

Anel's absence is hurting us so much. It's being compounded by Basham being waaay off his own standards. With Baldock taking a heavy knock and Basham struggling with what looked his left groin/knee, I've absolutely no idea what the backline will be at Stoke.

Ndiaye and Berge have had two poor games, by their standards, since the international break. A rest, a refresh, change things up...whatever you want to call it, they shouldn't have played 180 mins each.

Doyle is becoming an easy option to hook and tonight is third time it's had the opposite effect. PNE away we were awful without him, and we dropped 2 gears in these last 2 home games after he went off. PH isn't daft, Berge was noticeably out of steam on Saturday and both Berge and Norwood were levels below Doyle tonight...are we avoiding subbing them in favour of a loan player so it doesn't hurt their confidence? Others have mentioned he's not fit, really? He started 3 in a row before the PNE experiment and was buzzing for the U21s.

Sharp and Brewster have made 2 poor contributions off the bench this week. We need someone to step up, McBurnie isn't going to keep this purple patch going forever and he's not going to play 90 every week either. Sharp is coming back to fitness, but I'm worried about Brewster.

The substitutions, in general, are also hurting us. There's confusion about where to play Khadra and McAtee, and who to play them with. We look disjointed no matter who comes on, when they come and who they come on for.

We've been on a great run and got some deserved results. There's now a chasing pack trying to suck us in and we need to be wiser to avoid that happening. Players coming back will help but subs need to be much better.
Totally agree.
I think mistake to put Bogle on L when only just back from long absence.
I would have Baldock on L , Bogle on R.
As it was , when attacking we kept feeding Bogle on his weak foot so all he could do was turn inside.
So many players under par tonight.
 
im quite blank on this because i couldnt get on the sky sports app, password issues & Wednesday were on the radio. so bar updates from soccer saturday i didnt get much. but from what i got, would i be right in that we huffed & puffed with 21 shots on goal, but we were terrible in front of goal.

also is our defensive woes finally getting the better of us which have got to be looked at because February & March it was a crisis. now its october its still going which means it can't be bad luck. it was only til i was saying at work did the extent sink in. havent we really only got egan & basham match fit playing in their proper position. as we have got 3 CBs out, both LB's out & 1 RB just back as the other has limped off
 
Anyone know the attendance from last night? Thanks in advance.
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom