Outgoings > Incomings

[mattbianco1]

We all know that our squad was much better last season compared to this one, but thought i'd compare my thoughts on INS and OUTS - like-for-like position comparison

OUTGOING​	> = <​	INCOMING​
Robinson​	<​	Mee​
Choudhury​	>​	Matos​
Moore​	X​	Not replaced​
Gilchrist​	>​	Godfrey​
Rak-Sakyi​	>​	Ogbene​
Brereton-Diaz​	>​	Barry​
Clarke​	>​	Polendakov​
Holding/Souttar	>​	McGuinness​
Brewster​	=​	Ings​
Vini Souza​	>​	Soumare​
Anel​	=​	Tanganga​

Other signings not included in the above comparison table: Ukaki, Chong, Riedewald

Of all the signings made, i would argue that only Mee is better than who he replaced and Tanganga is on par with Anel.
I'm not saying Tanganga is a better player than Anel, but for Championship football, he is more than suitable.

 

[mattbianco1]

Lots of people like/play FIFA and often say that they are a good judge of players ability. Below is the table comparing their overall ratings on this seasons game:

OUTGOING​	INCOMING​	RATING Diff (relating to new player)​
Robinson​	Mee​	+3​
Choudhury​	Matos​	-5​
Moore​	N/A​	N/A​
Gilchrist​	Godfrey​	+2​
Rak-Sakyi​	Ogbene​	+2​
Brereton-Diaz​	Barry​	-3​
Clarke​	Polendakov​	-14​
Holding/Souttar​	McGuinness​	-2 / -3​
Brewster​	Ings​	+2​
Vini Souza​	Soumare​	-7​
Anel​	Tanganga​	-1​

An offset of -23

 

[Bladesince59]

Ings just collects his pension.

 

[nopigfansintown]

Our worst window this century? Cloughie's second season is up there I suppose. The last Prem season will be mentioned but we were paupers relative to that league.

 

[mattbianco1]

Ings just collects his pension.

I don't think it helps him getting 10 mins here and there

 

[Slim Man]

We all know that our squad was much better last season compared to this one, but thought i'd compare my thoughts on INS and OUTS - like-for-like position comparison

OUTGOING​	> = <​	INCOMING​
Robinson​	<​	Mee​
Choudhury​	>​	Matos​
Moore​	X​	Not replaced​
Gilchrist​	>​	Godfrey​
Rak-Sakyi​	>​	Ogbene​
Brereton-Diaz​	>​	Barry​
Clarke​	>​	Polendakov​
Holding/Souttar	>​	McGuinness​
Brewster​	=​	Ings​
Vini Souza​	>​	Soumare​
Anel​	=​	Tanganga​

Other signings not included in the above comparison table: Ukaki, Chong, Riedewald

Of all the signings made, i would argue that only Mee is better than who he replaced and Tanganga is on par with Anel.
I'm not saying Tanganga is a better player than Anel, but for Championship football, he is more than suitable.

You also state that Brewster is on a par with Ings which I disagree with. Ings has gone. Legs can't do what his head wants to.