This wasn't some sort of easy take-over-a-flying-team gig he landed. Southampton, like us this season, were the bookies favourites to go up – with all the pressures and expectations that entails. Pardew was shifted on soon in. They had a start that was well below expectations and were towards the bottom at the end of September. They only got into the automatic places after Christmas, and were in an almighty battle to catch Huddersfield and Brighton in the automatic places. As we knew from the season after that, that's a seriously high pressure scenario – and by the end of it they grabbed 2nd spot. Big club, big expectations, he found a way to meet them. This season has been dismal, but let's not suggest that promotion wasn't the result of a decent fight.
As I say, I'm not denigrating Adkins' achievement that season at Southampton at all, far from it - he did superbly. But the situation he was in wasn't as translatable to ours as you suggest.
In the first instance, although they'd had a pretty poor start to the season, it was very early days when Adkins got there (they'd won 1, drawn 1 & lost 3 - 2 of those losses while they were managerless).
And, after that rocky start, it was pretty much success all the way for Adkins:
- 5 without loss after losing his first game
- a spell of 4 wins, 1 draw, 2 losses
- 4 wins on the spin
- 5 without loss
- a spell of 7 wins & 1 draw
- ending the season with 6 wins on the spin.
Their record clearly kept improving over the season, but they always bounced back after losses, regularly kept clean sheets & scored 3 or more on loads of occasions.
Undeniable, that this was all at a big club & that Adkins managed his group of players well under a pressure to succeed. But, ultimately, he had very, very good players. And what is highly significant is that not one of his key players that season did he have to bring in to the club - the squad was already assembled for him.
It was, on the face of it, similar to us - big club, wallowing in the depths, high pressure to succeed. But, in the actual circumstances, very different - he didn't have to contend with ongoing adversity (because he got them motoring straight away) & he had all the players he needed there waiting for him.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010–11_Southampton_F.C._season