metalblade
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 6, 2005
- Messages
- 16,458
- Reaction score
- 25,261
We could have had a Cat1 academy instead we blew the money on Brewster.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?
Thing is we always need the money when giving our youngsters away for nothing. Same argument was made when we sold DCL for 1m...Two years apart though.
We got Lankshear for free the year before, and we needed the money at the time. Lad was pure potential at that point, not the fella we see today.
Because we saw with our own eyes how limited as a footballer Moore is.What i meant was - nobody was banging on about wanting him back last season. Kieffer Moore scored 11 league goals last season aswell. Nobody wanted him back
We would probably hoof aimless balls up the channel to him and wonder why he’s not scoring.
From the limited amount of time that I’ve seen Lankshear he has scored tap ins and been in the right place at the right time.
With our slow and ponderous attacks there isn’t much space in the box as the opposition have time to get back. I doubt he would score many in the current team
We’d got Campbell in the form of his career, Moore doing what Moore does, Hamer, O’Hare, Brooks & Rak-Sakyi all contributing and Diaz through the door. We didn’t need another forward.Everybody knows the Cannon signing wasn’t value for money and he’s not worth what we paid. People do skip over the context of the signing though. We were at the top end of the table in January - new owners looking to invest to get the one-off hit of promotion to the premier league. It’s widely voiced that in January you pay over the odds, and there are fewer good options around. At the time, there were enough people that thought the man was a goal-scorer, and if we were paying double what he was actually worth …? Well it stopped Sunderland getting him and dented their push, and a ‘wasted’ 5 million was small change if it got us over the line.
It didn’t help us.
Sunderland were better off without him.
Without promotion, the wasted money siddenly seemed like a big amount to throw away.
But at the time, the reasoning behind the signing didn’t seem anywhere near as bad as it does now.
The hamstrung One?Though I'd agree that he should have played a bit more, he was still very much first team and his sale value reflected that. He's also a rarity. Our first team over the past few seasons is littered with players through the academy and there's a very clear pathway - there were four academy product in the last squad.
There were some dark days in the past where we were never saw youth involvement. I do tend to agree that Wilder is growing ever more reluctant though - as evidenced by his reticence to give One minutes.
Leeds and Burnley both getting 100 points had nowt to do with it, then?We’d got Campbell in the form of his career, Moore doing what Moore does, Hamer, O’Hare, Brooks & Rak-Sakyi all contributing and Diaz through the door. We didn’t need another forward.
We were screaming out for a fill in for Souttar, from memory I think both Worrall and Mepham were available at the time.
You can trace our failure to get promoted all the way back to that decision to sign cannon over a centre back (other than the last minute signing of an unfit Holding, who he didn’t play).
Is that actually the case?We could have had a Cat1 academy instead we blew the money on Brewster.
Forgot the stat, but isn't Bamford the highest scoring player in the division since he joined us? Or he was recently?We're a strikers graveyard.
The hamstrung One?
That one who hasn’t been fit since he pulled it 10 mins into a start?
The One who hasn’t been available pretty much all season but got a fair few minutes pre season? That One?
Or de we have another One?
Had we replaced Souttar rather than signing Cannon there is a possibility that we might have been slugging it out with them at that level. It was certainly a decision that prevented that possibility, whether it was Wilder’s or the board’s, and we’ll probably never know which.Leeds and Burnley both getting 100 points had nowt to do with it, then?
They were both better than us and had squads of greater value and paid a lot more. We sucked v Burnley but competed really well with Leeds at home until they equalised.Had we replaced Souttar rather than signing Cannon there is a possibility that we might have been slugging it out with them at that level. It was certainly a decision that prevented that possibility, whether it was Wilder’s or the board’s, and we’ll probably never know which.
When we were as defensively sound as we were with Souttar they weren’t that much better than us. Cost of squad isn’t always the single determining factor, as we proved in 2018/19, Coventry last season and the likes of Brentford and Brighton are proving right now. If it was, football would be a pointless sport.They were both better than us and had squads of greater value and paid a lot more. We sucked v Burnley but competed really well with Leeds at home until they equalised.
He was in the U21s when he was 16 and still scoring. Clearly a brilliant finisher, always in the right place, has the natural instinct of a top top striker. BUT, and this is the important part, there's no guarantee he would have got the culture of the club.Where do you get that from? He was progressing well with us ! We knew we had a natural finisher on our hands and lost him to spurs for a fee yes! But pinched by spurs.
Had we replaced O'Connell rather than signing Brewster we might have had a good crack that second season. Both times we chose an overpriced, underscoring striker (that rely on poaching which is absolutely not how we play) and stuck with Robinson instead.Had we replaced Souttar rather than signing Cannon there is a possibility that we might have been slugging it out with them at that level. It was certainly a decision that prevented that possibility, whether it was Wilder’s or the board’s, and we’ll probably never know which.
Not defending Cannon.When we were as defensively sound as we were with Souttar they weren’t that much better than us. Cost of squad isn’t always the single determining factor, as we proved in 2018/19, Coventry last season and the likes of Brentford and Brighton are proving right now. If it was, football would be a pointless sport.
You can differ in opinion as much as you like, but it is very clear to most that purchasing Cannon rather than a quality CH impacted that season, and I doubt you’ll convince anyone otherwise.
Same reason why we didn't go for Mcburnie I suppose, Selles must not have wanted a ST when we definitely needed one to replace Moore and Brewster.Can't understand why we weren't in for him as a loanee last season.
There were a lot of weird ifs and buts from that 24/25 season, mainly with us and Leeds.When we were as defensively sound as we were with Souttar they weren’t that much better than us. Cost of squad isn’t always the single determining factor, as we proved in 2018/19, Coventry last season and the likes of Brentford and Brighton are proving right now. If it was, football would be a pointless sport.
You can differ in opinion as much as you like, but it is very clear to most that purchasing Cannon rather than a quality CH impacted that season, and I doubt you’ll convince anyone otherwise.
Will Lankshear has scored more Championship goals for Middlesbrough (13) in his 13 appearances than Tom Cannon has in his 63 for us (10).
They both cost £10m. Let that sink in.
United as a club do fantastic when it comes to the youth development via the academy. We don't do well when it comes to introducing them into the first team set up. I don't necessarily mean in playing them (though I do think we're not great at that), I mean in terms of selling them waaay to early. Osula as a prime example. Every man, woman, dog, cat or chicken could tell he were about to have his "break out" season.
Very well putEverybody knows the Cannon signing wasn’t value for money and he’s not worth what we paid. People do skip over the context of the signing though. We were at the top end of the table in January - new owners looking to invest to get the one-off hit of promotion to the premier league. It’s widely voiced that in January you pay over the odds, and there are fewer good options around. At the time, there were enough people that thought the man was a goal-scorer, and if we were paying double what he was actually worth …? Well it stopped Sunderland getting him and dented their push, and a ‘wasted’ 5 million was small change if it got us over the line.
It didn’t help us.
Sunderland were better off without him.
Without promotion, the wasted money siddenly seemed like a big amount to throw away.
But at the time, the reasoning behind the signing didn’t seem anywhere near as bad as it does now.
All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?