Lankshear

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?




Two years apart though.

We got Lankshear for free the year before, and we needed the money at the time. Lad was pure potential at that point, not the fella we see today.
Thing is we always need the money when giving our youngsters away for nothing. Same argument was made when we sold DCL for 1m...
 
What i meant was - nobody was banging on about wanting him back last season. Kieffer Moore scored 11 league goals last season aswell. Nobody wanted him back
Because we saw with our own eyes how limited as a footballer Moore is.

You're now comparing a 33 year old striker on his way down, to a 20 year old on his way up, in his first full season in professional football? (ages of the two last season).

As other posters have said though, if he'd have come back to us, he'd not have 15 goals in 16 games.
We're a strikers graveyard. We are nowhere near as creative as Boro.
 
Falls under the "what if we bought Maradona" bollocms

Top quality at that age isn't going to stay long. Still think we got lucky to get 2 seasons out of Illiman.
 
The bigger issue is why Boro were able to get much better value out of their £10m than we did. No amount of copium will make Cannon anything more than a L1/lower champ player.
 
Everybody knows the Cannon signing wasn’t value for money and he’s not worth what we paid. People do skip over the context of the signing though. We were at the top end of the table in January - new owners looking to invest to get the one-off hit of promotion to the premier league. It’s widely voiced that in January you pay over the odds, and there are fewer good options around. At the time, there were enough people that thought the man was a goal-scorer, and if we were paying double what he was actually worth …? Well it stopped Sunderland getting him and dented their push, and a ‘wasted’ 5 million was small change if it got us over the line.
It didn’t help us.
Sunderland were better off without him.
Without promotion, the wasted money siddenly seemed like a big amount to throw away.

But at the time, the reasoning behind the signing didn’t seem anywhere near as bad as it does now.
 
We would probably hoof aimless balls up the channel to him and wonder why he’s not scoring.
From the limited amount of time that I’ve seen Lankshear he has scored tap ins and been in the right place at the right time.
With our slow and ponderous attacks there isn’t much space in the box as the opposition have time to get back. I doubt he would score many in the current team
 
We would probably hoof aimless balls up the channel to him and wonder why he’s not scoring.
From the limited amount of time that I’ve seen Lankshear he has scored tap ins and been in the right place at the right time.
With our slow and ponderous attacks there isn’t much space in the box as the opposition have time to get back. I doubt he would score many in the current team

You might be right he wouldn't score many in the current team, but can you please tell me how many aimless 'hoofs' you have seen this season? If anything, we don't get it forward quick enough.
 
Everybody knows the Cannon signing wasn’t value for money and he’s not worth what we paid. People do skip over the context of the signing though. We were at the top end of the table in January - new owners looking to invest to get the one-off hit of promotion to the premier league. It’s widely voiced that in January you pay over the odds, and there are fewer good options around. At the time, there were enough people that thought the man was a goal-scorer, and if we were paying double what he was actually worth …? Well it stopped Sunderland getting him and dented their push, and a ‘wasted’ 5 million was small change if it got us over the line.
It didn’t help us.
Sunderland were better off without him.
Without promotion, the wasted money siddenly seemed like a big amount to throw away.

But at the time, the reasoning behind the signing didn’t seem anywhere near as bad as it does now.
We’d got Campbell in the form of his career, Moore doing what Moore does, Hamer, O’Hare, Brooks & Rak-Sakyi all contributing and Diaz through the door. We didn’t need another forward.

We were screaming out for a fill in for Souttar, from memory I think both Worrall and Mepham were available at the time.

You can trace our failure to get promoted all the way back to that decision to sign cannon over a centre back (other than the last minute signing of an unfit Holding, who he didn’t play).
 
Though I'd agree that he should have played a bit more, he was still very much first team and his sale value reflected that. He's also a rarity. Our first team over the past few seasons is littered with players through the academy and there's a very clear pathway - there were four academy product in the last squad.

There were some dark days in the past where we were never saw youth involvement. I do tend to agree that Wilder is growing ever more reluctant though - as evidenced by his reticence to give One minutes.
The hamstrung One?
That one who hasn’t been fit since he pulled it 10 mins into a start?
The One who hasn’t been available pretty much all season but got a fair few minutes pre season? That One?

Or de we have another One?
 
We’d got Campbell in the form of his career, Moore doing what Moore does, Hamer, O’Hare, Brooks & Rak-Sakyi all contributing and Diaz through the door. We didn’t need another forward.

We were screaming out for a fill in for Souttar, from memory I think both Worrall and Mepham were available at the time.

You can trace our failure to get promoted all the way back to that decision to sign cannon over a centre back (other than the last minute signing of an unfit Holding, who he didn’t play).
Leeds and Burnley both getting 100 points had nowt to do with it, then?
 
The hamstrung One?
That one who hasn’t been fit since he pulled it 10 mins into a start?
The One who hasn’t been available pretty much all season but got a fair few minutes pre season? That One?

Or de we have another One?

Calm ya tits Ken, I didn't realise that One's time at the club only just started at the time he got his latest injury.

Wilder has of course consistently shown that he wants him around the first team when he's been fit. I forget.
 
Leeds and Burnley both getting 100 points had nowt to do with it, then?
Had we replaced Souttar rather than signing Cannon there is a possibility that we might have been slugging it out with them at that level. It was certainly a decision that prevented that possibility, whether it was Wilder’s or the board’s, and we’ll probably never know which.
 



Had we replaced Souttar rather than signing Cannon there is a possibility that we might have been slugging it out with them at that level. It was certainly a decision that prevented that possibility, whether it was Wilder’s or the board’s, and we’ll probably never know which.
They were both better than us and had squads of greater value and paid a lot more. We sucked v Burnley but competed really well with Leeds at home until they equalised.
 
They were both better than us and had squads of greater value and paid a lot more. We sucked v Burnley but competed really well with Leeds at home until they equalised.
When we were as defensively sound as we were with Souttar they weren’t that much better than us. Cost of squad isn’t always the single determining factor, as we proved in 2018/19, Coventry last season and the likes of Brentford and Brighton are proving right now. If it was, football would be a pointless sport.

You can differ in opinion as much as you like, but it is very clear to most that purchasing Cannon rather than a quality CH impacted that season, and I doubt you’ll convince anyone otherwise.
 
Where do you get that from? He was progressing well with us ! We knew we had a natural finisher on our hands and lost him to spurs for a fee yes! But pinched by spurs.
He was in the U21s when he was 16 and still scoring. Clearly a brilliant finisher, always in the right place, has the natural instinct of a top top striker. BUT, and this is the important part, there's no guarantee he would have got the culture of the club.
Had we replaced Souttar rather than signing Cannon there is a possibility that we might have been slugging it out with them at that level. It was certainly a decision that prevented that possibility, whether it was Wilder’s or the board’s, and we’ll probably never know which.
Had we replaced O'Connell rather than signing Brewster we might have had a good crack that second season. Both times we chose an overpriced, underscoring striker (that rely on poaching which is absolutely not how we play) and stuck with Robinson instead.

It's actually insane that Wilder's teams are always defensively minded and organised, yet the big money gets spent on strikers that dont score.
 
When we were as defensively sound as we were with Souttar they weren’t that much better than us. Cost of squad isn’t always the single determining factor, as we proved in 2018/19, Coventry last season and the likes of Brentford and Brighton are proving right now. If it was, football would be a pointless sport.

You can differ in opinion as much as you like, but it is very clear to most that purchasing Cannon rather than a quality CH impacted that season, and I doubt you’ll convince anyone otherwise.
Not defending Cannon.
Just stating it wasn’t the only factor.
Agreed we’d have been closer if Souttar had remained fit or we managed to get in a suitable replacement CH but that was never any guarantee.
 
Not sure there’s much actual controversy here. We did well to get 90 pts off the back of Prem humiliation. We might have got more had we been cleverer in January. But two other teams were truly remarkable and it’s a stretch to think we should have earned 11 more points than we did.
 
Can't understand why we weren't in for him as a loanee last season.
Same reason why we didn't go for Mcburnie I suppose, Selles must not have wanted a ST when we definitely needed one to replace Moore and Brewster.

Granted Wilder probably should have tried to sign him last summer, but it does make you wonder why RS didn't think we ought to sign 1 ST to replace 2 departing ones.
 
When we were as defensively sound as we were with Souttar they weren’t that much better than us. Cost of squad isn’t always the single determining factor, as we proved in 2018/19, Coventry last season and the likes of Brentford and Brighton are proving right now. If it was, football would be a pointless sport.

You can differ in opinion as much as you like, but it is very clear to most that purchasing Cannon rather than a quality CH impacted that season, and I doubt you’ll convince anyone otherwise.
There were a lot of weird ifs and buts from that 24/25 season, mainly with us and Leeds.

Imagine if Leeds had either dropped Meslier earlier that season (even just a few games before) or if Farke had persisted with playing him until the end of the season, given how he was dropping clangers in every game.

Had either of those things happened, table would have definitely looked different.

Or even something as simple as Souttar not getting injured for us, or if Campbell hadn't gone from Cov win at home to PO final without scoring, which really didn't help.
 
Will Lankshear has scored more Championship goals for Middlesbrough (13) in his 13 appearances than Tom Cannon has in his 63 for us (10).

They both cost £10m. Let that sink in.

Put Lankshear in this team he probably scores about 3 this season.
 
The right hand side the weak point both offensively and defensively.

I would say move BBD to the right but I dont fancy either Canon or Campbell up front.

If Donovan is crocked then its probably Mcallum on and Burrows pushing up
 
Trying see
Positive in this it shows that our scouting in the youth side of thing is exceptional. We always seem to be able to pick up lads from
Prem academies that are surplus to requirements and find gems. Jagielka, Tonge, Brooks, Osula, Peck, Lankshear. Obvious shame that we often don’t benefit as much as we should from this but at least it shows our youth scouting works (or at least has in the past)
 
United as a club do fantastic when it comes to the youth development via the academy. We don't do well when it comes to introducing them into the first team set up. I don't necessarily mean in playing them (though I do think we're not great at that), I mean in terms of selling them waaay to early. Osula as a prime example. Every man, woman, dog, cat or chicken could tell he were about to have his "break out" season.

I couldn't. I thought we had Newcastle's pants down.
 



Everybody knows the Cannon signing wasn’t value for money and he’s not worth what we paid. People do skip over the context of the signing though. We were at the top end of the table in January - new owners looking to invest to get the one-off hit of promotion to the premier league. It’s widely voiced that in January you pay over the odds, and there are fewer good options around. At the time, there were enough people that thought the man was a goal-scorer, and if we were paying double what he was actually worth …? Well it stopped Sunderland getting him and dented their push, and a ‘wasted’ 5 million was small change if it got us over the line.
It didn’t help us.
Sunderland were better off without him.
Without promotion, the wasted money siddenly seemed like a big amount to throw away.

But at the time, the reasoning behind the signing didn’t seem anywhere near as bad as it does now.
Very well put
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom