The ground improvement debate will unfortunately always linger on because our ground isn't good enough anymore for the club grow and compete in the Premier League, as we would all hope. My take is this:
The Kop is obviously the biggest problem which needs addressing ASAP. Poor viewing angles, poles obstructing the view, insufficient legroom, outside concourse, poor toilets and food facilities, the majority of entrances/exits being at the back more or less forcing everybody in one direction - these are all major issues, some of which could even force the closure of the entire stand in time.
What it really needs is demolishing and a brand new stand building in its place. However, apart from the high cost of doing this there will be a lot of knock-on issues if we did go down this route. The stand would be closed for 18 months minimum - where are the 7000-8000 season ticket holders who currently sit on the Kop going to go? We just haven't got the spare capacity to place them all elsewhere.
The better solution would be to add an extra tier to the South Stand (using the current plans) which would enable an extra 6000 seats to be added to the capacity whilst not disrupting the existing match day experience. It would also provide space to place the current Kop season ticket holders when the Kop redevelopment finally takes place (as it must at sometime). There would be additional benefits such as increased hospitality revenue and, unlike the Kop, these plans look impressive.
Once this is completed then the demolition of the kop could commence. The current plans for the Kop though are a joke and do not address many of the problems we, as fans, or the safety officers currently face.
The perfect solution (in my opinion) would be to extend the South Stand lower tier all the way around to meet the John Street side, include rail seating plans (if possible) and use a cantilever design just like the South Stand currently has. this would allow for extending the South Stand upper tier around in the same way along Shoreham Street, should that be necessary in the future.
The final result looking similar to St. James Park for those confused by my description.
Will this happen......probably not....but it should be the plan. The new owner (whoever that will be) should do everything possible to gain control of those 2 pockets of land stolen by McCabe, so that United can submit plans which will be both impressive and address all safety and supporter issues.
The cost involved......tens of millions which can only be achieved by Premier League football, and even then we would have to try and survive on the cheap for a couple of seasons, which generally doesn't happen. I'm not surprised that the Prince wants out as he can see the problems ahead if we do go up.....and if we don't.