silver blade
Member
- Joined
- Mar 5, 2014
- Messages
- 804
- Reaction score
- 1,210
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?
I maintain that Kabbas goal is just as good, if not better, then the Euro 96 Gazza vs. Scotland goal.
Colin Hendry fully commited and landed flat on his arse, Walker stayed on his feet which made the volley much trickier.
I maintain that Kabbas goal is just as good, if not better, then the Euro 96 Gazza vs. Scotland goal.
Colin Hendry fully commited and landed flat on his arse, Walker stayed on his feet which made the volley much trickier.
That side was better than the one that Warnock got promoted a few years later
Perhaps in midfield and in part up front, but particularly that night I wouldn’t have said the defence was, and would argue that the best lineup was definitely better that season.
Comparing what I’d put as the best lineups:
Kenny 03 vs Kenny 06 – the more experienced Kenny wins that battle
Jags 03 vs Bromby 06 – Jags much better
Harley/Quinn/Kozluk 03 vs Unsworth 06 – Unsworth considerably better than the lot
Murphy & Page 03 vs Morgs & Short 06 – much as I really liked Murphy & Page, Morgs & Short were the better and more reliable pairing
Tonge 03 vs Armstrong 06 – clearly Tonge
Brown & Macca 03 vs Jags & Tonge 06 – definitely Brown & Macca
Ndlovu 03 vs Ifill 06 – I can already sense the rage some will have at this answer, but sorry everyone it’s Ifill, who was definitely much better that season than he gets credit for and was a key part of the promotion.
Kabba & Windass 03 vs Webber & HMS Shipperley 06 – just when you’d all calmed down over #NuddyIfillGate, I’m going to double the rage and say I’m afraid it’s the excellent latter partnership(perley). Kabba & Windass had a good spell initially, but players effects on the team should be judged on their overall contribution not just on their spells of good form. Webber the better goal return, HMS the better partner (and much better goal return)
Was 03 a better team to watch and generally more exciting than 06? Absolutely. Was it the better team based on the players involved? The midfield was, but that’s about it.
Agree on Ifill. Loved Nuddy, one of the most outrageously skillful players we've ever had but Ifill was a solid 7-8/10 week in week out. To borrow an analogy, players like Nuddy win you cup ties, players like Ifill win you leagues. Shame he wasn't quite up to Premier standard but he was an outstanding 2nd tier player.Perhaps in midfield and in part up front, but particularly that night I wouldn’t have said the defence was, and would argue that the best lineup was definitely better that season.
Comparing what I’d put as the best lineups:
Kenny 03 vs Kenny 06 – the more experienced Kenny wins that battle
Jags 03 vs Bromby 06 – Jags much better
Harley/Quinn/Kozluk 03 vs Unsworth 06 – Unsworth considerably better than the lot
Murphy & Page 03 vs Morgs & Short 06 – much as I really liked Murphy & Page, Morgs & Short were the better and more reliable pairing
Tonge 03 vs Armstrong 06 – clearly Tonge
Brown & Macca 03 vs Jags & Tonge 06 – definitely Brown & Macca
Ndlovu 03 vs Ifill 06 – I can already sense the rage some will have at this answer, but sorry everyone it’s Ifill, who was definitely much better that season than he gets credit for and was a key part of the promotion.
Kabba & Windass 03 vs Webber & HMS Shipperley 06 – just when you’d all calmed down over #NuddyIfillGate, I’m going to double the rage and say I’m afraid it’s the excellent latter partnership(perley). Kabba & Windass had a good spell initially, but players effects on the team should be judged on their overall contribution not just on their spells of good form. Webber the better goal return, HMS the better partner (and much better goal return)
Was 03 a better team to watch and generally more exciting than 06? Absolutely. Was it the better team based on the players involved? The midfield was, but that’s about it.
Murphy & Page 03 vs Morgs & Short 06 – much as I really liked Murphy & Page, Morgs & Short were the better and more reliable pairing
Brown & Macca 03 vs Jags & Tonge 06 – definitely Brown & Macca
My mind is fried. I've got Jags & Morgan as the 1st choice CB pairing in 2005/06. Short played but I didn't have him as first choice ???
Here's my combined XI from '03 & '06 in the 4-4-2 that we played then and if they were to play in the current CWAK system...
4-4-2:
Kenny3-5-2:
Geary - Jagielka - Morgan - Unsworth
Ifill - Brown - McCall - Tonge
Kabba - Webber
Kenny
Jagielka - Morgan - Bromby
Geary - McCall - Brown - Armstrong
Tonge
Kabba - Webber
I maintain that Kabbas goal is just as good, if not better, then the Euro 96 Gazza vs. Scotland goal.
Colin Hendry fully commited and landed flat on his arse, Walker stayed on his feet which made the volley much trickier.
How many of those players at their best for us would get in the current side? Jags, maybe Tonge, Morgan and Brown, but who would they replace? I loved Morgan, but I'd not swap him for Egan, for example. Sorry Morgs.My mind is fried. I've got Jags & Morgan as the 1st choice CB pairing in 2005/06. Short played but I didn't have him as first choice ???
Here's my combined XI from '03 & '06 in the 4-4-2 that we played then and if they were to play in the current CWAK system...
4-4-2:
Kenny3-5-2:
Geary - Jagielka - Morgan - Unsworth
Ifill - Brown - McCall - Tonge
Kabba - Webber
Kenny
Jagielka - Morgan - Bromby
Geary - McCall - Brown - Armstrong
Tonge
Kabba - Webber
My mind is fried. I've got Jags & Morgan as the 1st choice CB pairing in 2005/06. Short played but I didn't have him as first choice ???
All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?