Wilder needs to stop being so stubborn and just go back to the 3-5-2.
The full backs we already have here would make much better wing backs and I think Gus would be brilliant in the "Duffy role"
I’m not convinced by going back to a back 3 if I’m honest. The clamour for 3 defenders masks how shit ours have been this season imo. When we had Souttar and Anel we weren’t looking back to 352 and we certainly won’t be signing Bash and JOC this summer.
Most top teams play a variant of 433 / 4231 which can expose a back 3 with a wide player getting in the gap between the wing back and the centre backs. We saw this a lot during our relegation from the prem. once we’d been worked out teams left pace hugging the touch lines and as soon as we conceded possession they were in down the sides.
I’d just like us to sign another natural wide player, keeping Brooks. I’m disappointed we never got to see it last season with BBD or Raj Sakyi on the left, Brooks on the right and Hamer in the middle.
Playing him centrally will mean he isn’t having to track an athletic fullback or winger back into his own half as often. His pressing responsibilities would be onto a defender or a defensive midfielder. He wouldn’t then be leaving borrows / Mcallum exposed to a 2v1.
In possession he constantly wanders inside, which also leaves Burrows /
Mcallum isolated without the option of a pass down the line / overlap. He isn’t fast enough to beat a man for pace - let a natural winger do that. We’re so unbalanced as a team with him as a faux winger.
Playing centrally he can wander side to side and take the ball from the left or right and gets our most creative player on the ball more and hopefully also into more goal scoring position.