GoalWatch vs Gillingham

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Bergen Blade

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2009
Messages
7,384
Reaction score
19,471
Location
Bergen, Norway
1st: Gillingham attack down our left, manage to get past the challenges of Fleck, O'Connell and Done and their midfielder Wright is picked out in the box. He gets past EEL and Coutts and finishes past Moore.

The situation is similar to the one leading up to Walsall's penalty (4th goal) last week. Our midfielders move over to close down play on our left, leaving little protection centrally in front of our centre halves.

Vs Gillingham, circle showing their midfielder, who went on to score:
Skjermbilde 2017-01-22 22.39.31.png

Vs Walsall, circle showing their midfielder who went on to win their penalty:
Skjermbilde 2017-01-22 22.35.35.png

So on both occasions our players can't win the ball on the left hand side and our midfield are unable to cover the space centrally.


As Wright is picked out, he skips past EEL, who like last week shows a worrying weakness when players run at him. Coutts never quite gets goalside of Wright and is probably scared to give a penalty away. Basham and Freeman are focusing on their men in the box.



Some teams pack the midfield, forming a five-man block in front of the defence that the opposition has to break down. On occasions we're struggling to cover enough ground in midfield as we have two strikers; then Duffy is allowed to be more advanced than Fleck/Coutts, while the wing backs on scenarios like the above, become orthodox full backs. This leaves a two-man block - Fleck and Coutts - and it can be hard for them at times.

This lack of protection puts more pressure on the centre halves, who has to deal with players running at them and EEL has really struggled of late. He offers aerial strength and is excellent if opponents have their back to goal, but the last couple of games have exposed a weakness in him. Maybe being in the centre isn't ideal for him. Maybe Jake Wright's inclusion will help us cope better.


2nd: A long throw into the box is flicked on by Ehmer. Josh Wright runs on to the ball and toe pokes it past Moore.

O'Connell loses the original header:
Skjermbilde 2017-01-22 23.07.58.png

Josh Wright finds space between Basham and Freeman:
Skjermbilde 2017-01-22 23.08.27.png

I can't quite work out if Basham was originally marking Wright, or if we zonal mark on this occasion. Wilder will blame Basham if he's been specifically told to mark Wright. If we were zonal marking, Freeman was the one who should have kept an eye on Wright's run and used his body to block his path.

 



Not sure if Moore could have done any better for the second, though it could be argued that he could have challenged to punch or catch the ball when it was headed on
 
Not sure if Moore could have done any better for the second, though it could be argued that he could have challenged to punch or catch the ball when it was headed on

It was noticeable that after this Moore was indeed attacking and punching from long throws.
 
Thanks again Bergen Blade for highlighting the deficiencies of our midfield defending. Again some of us have been moaning about Coutts and him refusing to take responsibility in defensive situations. I'll say again he has got better going forward but he needs to improve drastically in his attitude to defending.
I'll say again also look at Southends first goal. It is just the same.
 
1st: Gillingham attack down our left, manage to get past the challenges of Fleck, O'Connell and Done and their midfielder Wright is picked out in the box. He gets past EEL and Coutts and finishes past Moore.

The situation is similar to the one leading up to Walsall's penalty (4th goal) last week. Our midfielders move over to close down play on our left, leaving little protection centrally in front of our centre halves.

Vs Gillingham, circle showing their midfielder, who went on to score:
View attachment 22433

Vs Walsall, circle showing their midfielder who went on to win their penalty:
View attachment 22434

So on both occasions our players can't win the ball on the left hand side and our midfield are unable to cover the space centrally.


As Wright is picked out, he skips past EEL, who like last week shows a worrying weakness when players run at him. Coutts never quite gets goalside of Wright and is probably scared to give a penalty away. Basham and Freeman are focusing on their men in the box.



Some teams pack the midfield, forming a five-man block in front of the defence that the opposition has to break down. On occasions we're struggling to cover enough ground in midfield as we have two strikers; then Duffy is allowed to be more advanced than Fleck/Coutts, while the wing backs on scenarios like the above, become orthodox full backs. This leaves a two-man block - Fleck and Coutts - and it can be hard for them at times.

This lack of protection puts more pressure on the centre halves, who has to deal with players running at them and EEL has really struggled of late. He offers aerial strength and is excellent if opponents have their back to goal, but the last couple of games have exposed a weakness in him. Maybe being in the centre isn't ideal for him. Maybe Jake Wright's inclusion will help us cope better.


2nd: A long throw into the box is flicked on by Ehmer. Josh Wright runs on to the ball and toe pokes it past Moore.

O'Connell loses the original header:
View attachment 22435

Josh Wright finds space between Basham and Freeman:
View attachment 22436

I can't quite work out if Basham was originally marking Wright, or if we zonal mark on this occasion. Wilder will blame Basham if he's been specifically told to mark Wright. If we were zonal marking, Freeman was the one who should have kept an eye on Wright's run and used his body to block his path.



Our defending for their first reminded me of one of the goals we conceded against Southend. Our back three all drop back to the edge of the six yard line so they could virtually hold hands, and without a deep lying midfielder there's a huge space on the edge of our box. The back three don't all have a man to mark, so someone needs to step out to close the space. On both occasions it happens too late and opponents score.

This is what Wright gives us - organisation, communication and a better reading of situations. He slower and poor on the ball, but surely has to play more.
 
A problem who putting Wright in the centre and EEL on the right is that EEL's not as good going forward or on the ball as Basham and JOC. Thought his touch and passing were exposed when he played RCB.
 
After their second goal, they kept on putting us under pressure with the long throws. One of them was even allowed to bounce in the area - something that a Sunday league team would get slated for, letting alone a professional team. If we can address simple issues like that, I think we'll be fine.
 
Bergen summarises the situation spot on imho.
We need Wright back despite his limitations as the weakness of EEL is now beginning to show.
The goal v Gillingham just the same as at Southend.
In total honesty we probably need to sign another centre back in this transfer window.
UTB
 
Good to have your analyses again, even if for those of a certain age it's a bit like seeing Kate Adie reporting on the BBC news from a trouble spot - you knew things had started to go wrong! ;) Your analysis shows that it was a team problem, not a defence problem, and how hard it is to solve one problem without creating another, particularly with the first one. If we come across another long-throw merchant, I think the keeper has to come (Moore got decent punches on the later ones), and have a player out to mark the throw-in taker, because inevitably the punch goes in his direction, and he has loads of time to cross again.
Loved your analysis - and hope no more are needed this season!
 
Second goal if you look where Basham is in the first photo and then look at him in the second photo he hasn't moved an inch. The goal scorer meanwhile has moved three yards to score. :mad:
 
Our defending for their first reminded me of one of the goals we conceded against Southend. Our back three all drop back to the edge of the six yard line so they could virtually hold hands, and without a deep lying midfielder there's a huge space on the edge of our box. The back three don't all have a man to mark, so someone needs to step out to close the space. On both occasions it happens too late and opponents score.

This is what Wright gives us - organisation, communication and a better reading of situations. He slower and poor on the ball, but surely has to play more.

Well spotted!

Skjermbilde 2017-01-23 21.12.08.png
 
A problem who putting Wright in the centre and EEL on the right is that EEL's not as good going forward or on the ball as Basham and JOC. Thought his touch and passing were exposed when he played RCB.

That is true, and I think Wilder appreciates Basham and O'Connell being decent on the ball for centre halves. EEL's aerial strength in both boxes has been important too, so it's understandable that Wilder is reluctant to drop him.
 
I've mentioned it elsewhere but it comes back to the midfield more often than not. They're not holding shape and there's no one protecting the back 3. Very unusual for a team playing wingbacks. We seem to get pulled around by where the ball is and not holding shape or tracking runners. When we're pushing up the field it's less of an issue as the wingbacks can generally get back, but we're sitting back more and more.
 



We can all blame midfield.....but the fault is a team fault. In most cases possession is lost up front allowing the break of our opponents.

Anyway....good analysis, and I agree that their player has been lost by defenders allowing them a clear opening as the ball lands nicely for them. The question is why, and the main reason which you miss Bergen is body position.

The still picture for the second Gills goal highlights a clear fault for both EEL, and Basham. Both of them are too side on simply watching the ball as it is flicked on. Neither are in a position to see what's going on around them. EEL is marking someone at least fairly tightly, but Bash is ball watching and has no idea what is happening behind him. If he had a more open body position, he would be in a position to see in his peripharel vision the Gills player and at least get in the way.
Basics of defending....body position and not getting stuck ball watching. Bash has switched off, and Freeman has let him run off him. Poor defending. But keep an eye on it, football coaches are always ranting at academy level about body position.

Keeper can't be blamed, he can't tell them of the danger in the time frame available, and midfielders can only drop so far until it's the defenders jobs. We had enough players there we just didn't defend the situations well. We need to remember this is league one....and we are getting what we are paying for.

Wilder will have let them know it wasn't good.
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom