GCB - ours or Rotherham's?

[jaz7887]

it was a rotherham song originally but that doesn't matter its not like they are tryin to claim it or sing it.

 

[SwissBlade]

it was a rotherham song originally but that doesn't matter its not like they are tryin to claim it or sing it.

Its not a fact unless you put fact in the sentence - Fact

It doesn't matter if they wanted to claim it or sing it. The poll here is the definitive poll. It was agreed.

If you consider that 5% of the votes can be discounted as they pressed the wrong option, that leaves 95% of the vote which is effectively now 100% of the vote and if we assume that the 5% were the ones that voted for Rotherham these should be voided, it therefore proves that the actual of origin of the GCB was Sheffield United - FACT

 

[shorehamview]

It's no more a Rotherham United song than it is a Mamelodi Sundowns ditty.

 

[Studge]

The first time my Dad ever heard it sung was by the Rotherham Blades, which just confuses matters.

I agree first heard it sung by our good friends the Parkgate/Rawmish blades by the brothers with the same name as the Plant Hire Co.

 

[Sensiblade]

I agree first heard it sung by our good friends the Parkgate/Rawmish blades by the brothers with the same name as the Plant Hire Co.

Mummy and Daddy Plant Hire Co. must have been proud

(this bit not aimed at Studge) Who give a shit anyway, we are by far the most famous for singing it, I have never ever heard Rotherham sing it in my life.
and I haven't seen any proof that whats being said is Fact so I go with Blades all the way

 

[bartman]

No it isn't.

Yet another incorrect claim from a united fan about a song.

Yes united used it for booker before man u for cantona but they used it for paul mcgrath before that and before united used it for booker.

Just askedmy MD-life time Man Utd fan 35 year season ticket holder. He cannot recall the Stretford End ever singing that song about Paul McGrath....Villa did thou later in his career

 

[Sensiblade]

It strangely all goes quiet when actual proof is asked for

 

[TonyAgana]

i pressed the wrong button......

Bet you don't tick the wrong box in May!

 

[GRUMPY BLADE]

I always thought it was John Denver?