The issue with both Barry and Ogbene is that whilst they have something to offer, they're struggling to execute it at this level. They'll run into the channels with the ball, but the moment they're confronted by a defender, they try and knock it round them, get out muscled in a far more physical league and lose possession. When we're struggling defensively, that loss of possession is usually quite dangerous for the team as whole.
Brooks tends to hold it up and wait for Seriki to invert or overlap, or ping it off into midfield, he's good at it and it usually helps us into a promising position. The main thing though is that he doesn't give up possession as easy and keeps the attacking move alive. The other two don't and it's likely the reason they get shit thrown their way rather than a question of their ability on the ball.