Roy's View From... Cardiff and Bolton fans views on GARY MADINE

[BladeInIreland]

You made statements regarding his (according to you) inability to score goals. You stated that he would not be a good fit for us. You then attempt to turn your argument around to the fact that his scoring a couple of goals doesn't change anything regarding your personal opinion of him - in other words, ok he can score goals but "I still know already that he is a c**t."
So, please make up your mind my friend - do you want him to fail (and possibly hinder our chances of getting promotion) simply because of your personal opinion of him, or because he can't score goals and isn't a good signing for us on sound footballing reasons?
Also - may I ask what your views are on a civilised society believing in forgiveness and rehabilitation?
Also - what is your opinion of people on social media using abusive language?

My point hasn’t changed, he still has a lot to prove before his signing can be deemed good for footballing reasons. Two goals doesn’t suddenly make him a top goal scorer. I would still pick McGoldrick over him, regardless of my opinion of him.

And no disrespect I’m not ignoring your other points I just honestly don’t have time at the minute but I don’t really have much to expand on anyway.

 

[derfblade.3]

Madine or Goldie? Doesn't have to be like that does it? Goldie behind Madine and Bill looked great v Boro . Wilder has a lovely problem of who he plays and where they play in the front positions and after a very good debut from Hogan the lovely problem gets better. Great work in the transfer market by Chris and the team.

 

[sitwell]

You haven't seen him play for us then?

He wont have met him either.