Brewster v O'hare

[Fjortoft's Aeroplane]

Wilder took a controversial punt picking Brewster ahead of O'Hare against the Pigs and it paid off. Question is was it a fluke? or is this the correct decision going into the least 8 games?
Who would you rather see starting in the last 8 games?

 

[ISZA ⚔️]

4 each.

 

[1066blade]

It depends entirely on the opposition every game. Oh, and the
Pitch of course. CW decided the Sty was no fit surface for slick fast passing like O'Hare and Seriki

 

[jono_t2000]

O'hare for me every day of the week

 

[Iceybabey]

Can we get a comparison of goal contributions?

Brewster on more goals and COH with more assists?

 

[Iceybabey]

Can we get a comparison of goal contributions?

Brewster on more goals and COH with more assists?

Just had a look. Brewster with 3 goals and 3 assists. COH with 2 goals and 6 assists. COH has played more minutes and, for me, is key to our press. No doubt Brewster should have at least 2 or 3 more goals to his name- same could be said for COH.

 

[McGrath]

It depends entirely on the opposition every game. Oh, and the
Pitch of course. CW decided the Sty was no fit surface for slick fast passing like O'Hare and Seriki

Bizarre that their pitch picked out match winner

 

[Frank the tank]

Personally think Brewster is more an Iimact player but o hare needs to. Recapture his form of earlier in the season and stop dwelling on the ball

 

[3Cheers4Ramirez]

Brewster is more of a goal threat. O'Hare never looks remotely like scoring in this team and I'm surprised he's even managed to scramble 2

But Brewster is usually better coming off the bench, and this team is more used to playing with O'Hare and relying on his work rate

Brereton, Hamer and Campbell should provide enough goals to mean that we can afford O'Hare's shortcomings there

Horses for courses too. Often, neither should start. Plymouth and Oxford away for example - go with JRS against them

 

[MayorOJC]

Neither, Hamer.

But O'Hare over Brewster.

 

[nopigfansintown]

O'Hare. He was knackered against Bristol City. Their pitch is shit and they were always going to lump it to the big man neutralising O'Hare's pressing quality so the change was the right one at the right time.

 

[Boxer Blade]

O'hare for me every day of the week

So Brewster on a Saturday and Sunday then

 

[HeCanDoMagic]

O'hare for me every day of the week

Apart from Sunday.

 

[Nosworthys Throw]

I reckon Brewster would catch him with an overhand right in the later rounds

 

[crazyblade1889]

Brewster is looking sharper each game. Give it another month and he will hit a purple patch in form I reckon. Just as his contract runs out. Complete shock that one!

 

[BladeByChoice]

Can we get a comparison of goal contributions?

Brewster on more goals and COH with more assists?

https://sheffieldunited.sportsvision.io/watch/2024-25/rhian%20brewster,callum%20o'hare/goal,target,assist

 

[Chimpan-A]

I really like Brewster this season. But I really like O’Hare. But which one is best? There’s only one way to find out ….. FIGHT!

 

[robbiez666]

The fact O'Hare isn't starting most games is madness. We don't create anywhere near enough chances and he and Hamer are out two most creative players.

 

[Not so Slim ane]

O'Hare by a mile for me, pressing, work rate, creativity are way better than Brewster

 

[Bladesince59]

Ohare. Brewster's been and gone

 

[bakeblade]

The fact O'Hare isn't starting most games is madness. We don't create anywhere near enough chances and he and Hamer are out two most creative players.

Brewster did well against Wednesday and Cov and scored in both, so deserved to start against Oxford. Unfortunately he was poor, but most were
O'Hare will start on Tuesday

 

[Pintor75]

O'Hare for me, the goals Brewster scored were important ,but anyone could have knocked them in, O'Hare is the better player and more mobile, what we need now not trying to get someone a new deal

 

[straight_outta_compton]

O'Hare for me too, simply because of his work rate and closing down their defenders & keeper

Brewster is good for instinctive shots, but his positional sense is woeful. But glad to see him fit and looking lean. Hopefully he'll improve and quickly!!!

 

[joefirth03]

Start O'hare, bench Brewster. We miss O'hare's work rate when he doesn't start - Brewster is also a better impact sub than O'hare has been.

 

[Not so Slim ane]

Brewster did well against Wednesday and Cov and scored in both, so deserved to start against Oxford. Unfortunately he was poor, but most were
O'Hare will start on Tuesday

Brewster was very poor against Wednesday other than the goal, better against Coventry but still didn't do a great deal

 

[ATL Recs]

Ohare for me moves defenders and runs direct also works hard off the ball limiting space
Even on an off day he is a nuisance for defenders
Should have been the first substitution at half time on Saturday

 

[jono_t2000]

O'Hare for me.

Brewsters goals contributions per minute are better.. but O'Hare keeps us on the front foot more with his workrate and pressing.

 

[Agreasychipbutty]

Rotate them game by game depending who suits it better, Brewster offers better link up and forward passing, O'Hare gives more energy and better at retaining the ball. If it's going to be an open game play Brewster, if it's going to be more scrappy and/or we expect the opposition to have a lot of the ball and will need to press play O'Hare. Oxford I think would have suited O'Hare better (not that I think it would have made a difference we were shit all over), Coventry was ideal for Brewster.