Alan Hodgkinson was the best goalkeeper United had in all the years I watched them. In folklore he will be remembered along with Billy Foulkes, though he was nowhere near the same size.
He wasn’t a tall man but he more than made up for this by his great anticipation and positioning. The great United defence of that time, (Hodgkinson; Coldwell; Graham Shaw; Richardson; Joe Shaw; Summers), played together so often that they developed a remarkable ability to work as a unit and cover for each other.
Hodgy was also the best goalkeeper I have seen for coming out of his goal and “smothering” an advancing opposition forward who had managed to get through the defence. I saw him do this once against Leyton Orient in 1959. It was at the Lane, it had been raining and the pitch was slippy. The advancing opposition forward was Tommy Johnston. His studs cut a long and deep gash in Hodgy’s leg. He had to go off and Dennis Shields had to go in goal (he didn’t do bad either). Hodgy was out for a few weeks.
I always felt confident when Hodgy was in goal. He played several times for England, but not as much as he deserved. Ron Springett was preferred. He was good, but Hodgy was better. His positioning meant that he made goalkeeping look easy, so that may be why he didn’t get the recognition he should have.
- Walth Snr