Barry and Bindon: Not good enough.

[TopBoy]

Sorry Pal, I can't let you off here. Barry was poor, slow, seemingly completely unmotivated and totally ineffectual, I'll give you that.

His performance though was never even close to the mind-bendingly awful abortion that Ben Godfrey put in against Ipswich earlier this season in my opinion.

Barry at least delivered a couple of decent corners and tried not to give the ball away by just simply passing the ball back 5 yards to a defender during his 50-odd minutes. Godfrey however showed an incredible level of consistency during his whole Ipswich display. Somehow he managed to keep up the shittest possible standards mixed with apathy and indifference. It was 'different level' ineptness. We really would have been better off having the other defenders push a wheelie bin around in his shirt on the night, he was SO bad.

Oh Joy.

utb

I actually think the Barry performance was worse; it was just in his position he wasn't as exposed, so the impact wasn't felt in the result. I watched Barry closely as I sit in the middle of the south stand and was speechless. I used more energy that him going for a HT piss.

 

[Berkshire Blade]

The shambolic loans this year are the reason we are so bad.

Unfortunately unless something sensational happens is going to cost us for years

 

[IdLiketoRogerMoore]

At the risk of being devils advocate, i remember similar conversations about McAtee following his first couple of games, and he ended up being our best player during the final quarter of that season....

He wasn't great yesterday, but I'd be inclined to keep him around.

Bindon and Godfrey on the other hand are historically bad loans and need to be returned the minute the clock strikes midnight at Nea Year....

 

[Houston_Blade]

That said, there wasn’t a semblance of a co-ordinated collective press for much of the game, particularly in the first half. Which looked like a bit of a wasted opportunity, given the weight of panicky errors Watford made in their own third.

Do you mean that O’Hare legging it forwards like a headless chicken while the others behind him just stand and watch isn’t a ‘collective press’?! It had me fooled.

 

[Houston_Blade]

At the risk of being devils advocate, i remember similar conversations about McAtee following his first couple of games, and he ended up being our best player during the final quarter of that season....

He wasn't great yesterday, but I'd be inclined to keep him around.

Bindon and Godfrey on the other hand are historically bad loans and need to be returned the minute the clock strikes midnight at Nea Year....

My only hope is that he has a miraculous turnaround like McAtee did and comes good. He does look proper wank though so far.

 

[Silky Sabella]

You are all so happy to slag these player's off probably just because they were signed by Ruben Selles, but you haven't got the decency, mentality or respect to mention, Mee, Tanganga and McGuiness, who pig wilder constantly praises, stating how important they are to the team.( Not forgetting pig wilder made Tanganga captain immediately) and were all signed due to Ruben Selles being manager.
It is only the obscene obsessive wilder paranoia from some of you lot, and also the friendly, cosy unhealthy relationship between wilder and Bettis that caused a knee jerk reaction from the owner's that caused Selles to lose his job, because he would have turned the team into a winning, entertaining team, end of!
Ruben Selles should still be manager. Thank goodness wilder won't be around for longer than 18 months

 

[Sportbilly /Detroit Blade]

You are all so happy to slag these player's off probably just because they were signed by Ruben Selles, but you haven't got the decency, mentality or respect to mention, Mee, Tanganga and McGuiness, who pig wilder constantly praises, stating how important they are to the team.( Not forgetting pig wilder made Tanganga captain immediately) and were all signed due to Ruben Selles being manager.
It is only the obscene obsessive wilder paranoia from some of you lot, and also the friendly, cosy unhealthy relationship between wilder and Bettis that caused a knee jerk reaction from the owner's that caused Selles to lose his job, because he would have turned the team into a winning, entertaining team, end of!
Ruben Selles should still be manager. Thank goodness wilder won't be around for longer than 18 months

I genuinely believe you should be sectioned!

 

[Koh Samui Blade]

You are all so happy to slag these player's off probably just because they were signed by Ruben Selles, but you haven't got the decency, mentality or respect to mention, Mee, Tanganga and McGuiness, who pig wilder constantly praises, stating how important they are to the team.( Not forgetting pig wilder made Tanganga captain immediately) and were all signed due to Ruben Selles being manager.
It is only the obscene obsessive wilder paranoia from some of you lot, and also the friendly, cosy unhealthy relationship between wilder and Bettis that caused a knee jerk reaction from the owner's that caused Selles to lose his job, because he would have turned the team into a winning, entertaining team, end of!
Ruben Selles should still be manager. Thank goodness wilder won't be around for longer than 18 months

What are you on?????

 

[IdLiketoRogerMoore]

My only hope is that he has a miraculous turnaround like McAtee did and comes good. He does look proper wank though so far.

He's a young lad who's not played, trained at this level before...

Jury's out for me whether he's James McAtee or Ben Woodburn - but to be hammering him this early is just typical Bladey McBladey (*see thread where Peck is getting similarly hammered)...

Based purely on that first 25 mins v Bristol, I'm going out on a limb and saying there's a player in there. Maybe nothing more than an impact sub for us this season, but Wilder is obviously seeing enough from him in training to think he can replace Hamer....

 

[true99blade]

McAtee never had a poor start. He looked a bit off it on his debut against Luton and some nutter posted a thread stating Man City had our pants down. One of the only true examples of fans pissing the bed on here. Based on multiple viewings, Barry is just simply shite. Edit: and Bindon looks especially shite in my opinion.

 

[Gannon's perm]

You are all so happy to slag these player's off probably just because they were signed by Ruben Selles, but you haven't got the decency, mentality or respect to mention, Mee, Tanganga and McGuiness, who pig wilder constantly praises, stating how important they are to the team.( Not forgetting pig wilder made Tanganga captain immediately) and were all signed due to Ruben Selles being manager.
It is only the obscene obsessive wilder paranoia from some of you lot, and also the friendly, cosy unhealthy relationship between wilder and Bettis that caused a knee jerk reaction from the owner's that caused Selles to lose his job, because he would have turned the team into a winning, entertaining team, end of!
Ruben Selles should still be manager. Thank goodness wilder won't be around for longer than 18 months

Only around here is you!

 

[Houston_Blade]

He's a young lad who's not played, trained at this level before...

Jury's out for me whether he's James McAtee or Ben Woodburn - but to be hammering him this early is just typical Bladey McBladey (*see thread where Peck is getting similarly hammered)...

Based purely on that first 25 mins v Bristol, I'm going out on a limb and saying there's a player in there. Maybe nothing more than an impact sub for us this season, but Wilder is obviously seeing enough from him in training to think he can replace Hamer....

He looked good against weaker opposition in the preseason games I managed to watch. Since coming into the Championship he’s been poor so maybe it’s just about levels. He doesn’t look like the kind of player who will run his bollocks off and do the defensive side of the game so he’s probably not going to fit into a Wilder team (see also Brooks). We don’t play wingers anymore so he’s not really playing in his preferred position.

I’m not saying he’s a bad player but sadly I don’t think it’s going to work out for him here.

 

[cahill]

Not sure about Burrows not being « good enough for the Championship « , he was in the Team of the Season along with Gus last year

 

[Berkshire Blade]

I genuinely believe you should be sectioned!

What are you on?????

Sheffield Wednesday fan suffering side effects from a boycott of deludamol

 

[Blademan89]

You are all so happy to slag these player's off probably just because they were signed by Ruben Selles, but you haven't got the decency, mentality or respect to mention, Mee, Tanganga and McGuiness, who pig wilder constantly praises, stating how important they are to the team.( Not forgetting pig wilder made Tanganga captain immediately) and were all signed due to Ruben Selles being manager.
It is only the obscene obsessive wilder paranoia from some of you lot, and also the friendly, cosy unhealthy relationship between wilder and Bettis that caused a knee jerk reaction from the owner's that caused Selles to lose his job, because he would have turned the team into a winning, entertaining team, end of!
Ruben Selles should still be manager. Thank goodness wilder won't be around for longer than 18 months

Lol headloss. Wilder lives rent free lad, chan the man destroyed your club but wilder has destroyed your mentally

As the famous Ian beale line goes.. ive got nothing left

 

[Rodders]

You are all so happy to slag these player's off probably just because they were signed by Ruben Selles, but you haven't got the decency, mentality or respect to mention, Mee, Tanganga and McGuiness, who pig wilder constantly praises, stating how important they are to the team.( Not forgetting pig wilder made Tanganga captain immediately) and were all signed due to Ruben Selles being manager.
It is only the obscene obsessive wilder paranoia from some of you lot, and also the friendly, cosy unhealthy relationship between wilder and Bettis that caused a knee jerk reaction from the owner's that caused Selles to lose his job, because he would have turned the team into a winning, entertaining team, end of!
Ruben Selles should still be manager. Thank goodness wilder won't be around for longer than 18 months

You just worry about Wednesday going bust, we’ll be fine

 

[Kenilworth]

At the risk of being devils advocate, i remember similar conversations about McAtee following his first couple of games, and he ended up being our best player during the final quarter of that season....

He wasn't great yesterday, but I'd be inclined to keep him around.

Bindon and Godfrey on the other hand are historically bad loans and need to be returned the minute the clock strikes midnight at Nea Year....

Nah
Chalk and cheese.
McAttee was dreadful away at Luton but that gave him the understanding of the levels of aggression and physicality required in the champ as opposed to U21 cat 1 football.
That changed the very next time he played.
Lightweight hasn’t progressed since the 20 min spell vs Bristol City. He’s just got worse and worse.
He couldn’t aggressively mash a tea bag.

 

[jimmymuir]

At least Barry and Bindon shouldn't be too expensive, Ben Godfrey on the other hand...

 

[bertieblade]

Godfrey was brought in on reputation, not ability

 

[JD88]

Could have easily dragged Barry off after 20 mins on the weekend, slow, weak and very predictable.. Woefully out of his depth and surely will be gone January 1st.

 

[Billyblade]

You are all so happy to slag these player's off probably just because they were signed by Ruben Selles, but you haven't got the decency, mentality or respect to mention, Mee, Tanganga and McGuiness, who pig wilder constantly praises, stating how important they are to the team.( Not forgetting pig wilder made Tanganga captain immediately) and were all signed due to Ruben Selles being manager.
It is only the obscene obsessive wilder paranoia from some of you lot, and also the friendly, cosy unhealthy relationship between wilder and Bettis that caused a knee jerk reaction from the owner's that caused Selles to lose his job, because he would have turned the team into a winning, entertaining team, end of!
Ruben Selles should still be manager. Thank goodness wilder won't be around for longer than 18 months

I honestly can't imagine a time when I could be so obsessed with my teams rivals to the point where I'd be analysing signings, Club hierarchy etc. and posting such in depth analysis on their forum.

You are a real sad act.

 

[Back post bob]

For me on Saturday Barry took a few strong but fair challenges then looked like he didn't fancy it.