Brewster

[Bladeinleeds]

If we are playing on the counter attack Brewster should really thrive in this team. As always with him it will be down to fitness and I notice Wilder is not in a rush to give him more than sub appearances at the moment.

I think that’s sensible to be fair

With the amount of bad luck he’s had seemingly every time he started playing himself into abit of form - we should take it slow.

Build it up from the bench and see how he does before looking to start him. I don’t think the 5-3-2 formation got the best out of him so maybe the new one will end up being more suited to his game? Time will tell.

Campbell is another one where we need to take it slow and ease him in. An incredibly difficult summer for him from a personal point of view combined with zero pre season means we’ve every reason to ease him in slowly.

 

[Enigmatic]

I think a few will be eating humble pie this season. Brewster has quality. If he stays fit it will show, as it did with his incisive pass (on the half-volley) for our second last night.

 

[Lama]

I imagine many footballers have taken to twitter, or had a quick google to see what sort of reaction their performance(s) have garnered from fans.

That makes me sick to think, as I imagine this thread probably pops up. God forbid he ever sees it: Some of the comments on here would break is heart, which is an embarrassing reflection of a fanbase that can be so fabulously supportive when it suits.

It’s fair to say it hasn’t worked out (yet). It’s fair to say you dont rate him as a player. It’s very fair to say he’s not been worth the fee paid. Beyond that though, some of the more vitriolic comments really show some posters up for the type of supporters they really are.

There is not a person on this planet who will want things to work out more than RB; you can see that in the way he supports his teammates, celebrates the goals of others and the respect he’s earnt from those within the club.

I think we all understand there’s a reasonable chance there won’t be a poetic redemption arc, but for fuck’s sake, why would you not support him while he’s here, putting on a red and white shirt?

 

[Slim Man]

I imagine many footballers have taken to twitter, or had a quick google to see what sort of reaction their performance(s) have garnered from fans.

That makes me sick to think, as I imagine this thread probably pops up. God forbid he ever sees it: Some of the comments on here would break is heart, which is an embarrassing reflection of a fanbase that can be so fabulously supportive when it suits.

It’s fair to say it hasn’t worked out (yet). It’s fair to say you dont rate him as a player. It’s very fair to say he’s not been worth the fee paid. Beyond that though, some of the more vitriolic comments really show some posters up for the type of supporters they really are.

There is not a person on this planet who will want things to work out more than RB; you can see that in the way he supports his teammates, celebrates the goals of others and the respect he’s earnt from those within the club.

I think we all understand there’s a reasonable chance there won’t be a poetic redemption arc, but for fuck’s sake, why would you not support him while he’s here, putting on a red and white shirt?

I think it’s fair to discuss a player on a fans forum. And it can’t be argued his impact has been pretty negative overall.

Where are we meant to talk about him in a negative light where he won’t see it out of interest?

 

[Slim Man]

The top and bottom of it is he has little to no impact on games. Doesn’t know where to be, what to do, and just doesn’t look good enough.

He looks like a right back who’s been put in attacking areas.

Hopefully Campbell has got summat about him

 

[FinchleyBlade]

I imagine many footballers have taken to twitter, or had a quick google to see what sort of reaction their performance(s) have garnered from fans.

That makes me sick to think, as I imagine this thread probably pops up. God forbid he ever sees it: Some of the comments on here would break is heart, which is an embarrassing reflection of a fanbase that can be so fabulously supportive when it suits.

It’s fair to say it hasn’t worked out (yet). It’s fair to say you dont rate him as a player. It’s very fair to say he’s not been worth the fee paid. Beyond that though, some of the more vitriolic comments really show some posters up for the type of supporters they really are.

There is not a person on this planet who will want things to work out more than RB; you can see that in the way he supports his teammates, celebrates the goals of others and the respect he’s earnt from those within the club.

I think we all understand there’s a reasonable chance there won’t be a poetic redemption arc, but for fuck’s sake, why would you not support him while he’s here, putting on a red and white shirt?

The whole point of a football forum is to discuss things like this. Brewster has been an absolutely horrific signing, what exactly are people meant to say? Pretend otherwise?

 

[Lama]

I think it’s fair to discuss a player on a fans forum. And it can’t be argued his impact has been pretty negative overall.

Where are we meant to talk about him in a negative light where he won’t see it out of interest?

I never said it wasn't fair, if you read my post, I'm in complete agreement with you.

Plenty of comments on this thread go beyond a discussion of his qualities as a player or his impact overall. There's some really nasty stuff been said.

It was nice to see Ahmedhodzic get such a good reception last night, it's a shame that kind of support doesn't apply to all United players.

 

[Lama]

The whole point of a football forum is to discuss things like this. Brewster has been an absolutely horrific signing, what exactly are people meant to say? Pretend otherwise?

As above, read my post: Not every post in this thread is "discussion" - some of it is pretty vile.

 

[Not so Slim ane]

I imagine many footballers have taken to twitter, or had a quick google to see what sort of reaction their performance(s) have garnered from fans.

That makes me sick to think, as I imagine this thread probably pops up. God forbid he ever sees it: Some of the comments on here would break is heart, which is an embarrassing reflection of a fanbase that can be so fabulously supportive when it suits.

It’s fair to say it hasn’t worked out (yet). It’s fair to say you dont rate him as a player. It’s very fair to say he’s not been worth the fee paid. Beyond that though, some of the more vitriolic comments really show some posters up for the type of supporters they really are.

There is not a person on this planet who will want things to work out more than RB; you can see that in the way he supports his teammates, celebrates the goals of others and the respect he’s earnt from those within the club.

I think we all understand there’s a reasonable chance there won’t be a poetic redemption arc, but for fuck’s sake, why would you not support him while he’s here, putting on a red and white shirt?

The problem is he's had enough chances now and proven he's hopeless.. louie marsh might be the next Harry kane but Brewster takes his game time.... In the same way people say it's not Brewster's fault that he cost £23m, it's not Marsh's fault that he didn't cost £23m

 

[Dnblade]

He did well to get the ball out to Moore for the 2nd,I know Moore still had a bit to do,but credit him for that.

 

[utd4ever]

He looks like he will never score a goal.
Problem……. He’s a striker.

He could have done with a loan to lower league. One for fitness and two to break into scoring. I think that’s all he needs. A goal or two to get the confidence.

 

[Lama]

The problem is he's had enough chances now and proven he's hopeless.. louie marsh might be the next Harry kane but Brewster takes his game time.... In the same way people say it's not Brewster's fault that he cost £23m, it's not Marsh's fault that he didn't cost £23m

I understand that point, but I disagree:

Yesterday was not a game for Marsh, or any of the untested youngsters. We’re already a pretty young side, yesterday’s substitutes provided a bit of guile, and Wilder’s decision was vindicated by Brewster, McCallum and Brooks linking up for the goal. The really fresh players like Marsh, Hampson, Oné et al should ideally starting cup games, and coming on when were coasting; not when the game is in the balance.

Is McCallum or Burrows blocking Harry Boyes place in the team? Are Souttar and Anel blocking Dovydas Sasnauskas? I’m with you that the youngsters need chances, but there is a time and a place, and Hull away on a Friday night is not that place, especially when the team is already so young.

 

[Not so Slim ane]

I understand that point, but I disagree:

Yesterday was not a game for Marsh, or any of the untested youngsters. We’re already a pretty young side, yesterday’s substitutes provided a bit of guile, and Wilder’s decision was vindicated by Brewster, McCallum and Brooks linking up for the goal. The really fresh players like Marsh, Hampson, Oné et al should ideally starting cup games, and coming on when were coasting; not when the game is in the balance.

Is McCallum or Burrows blocking Harry Boyes place in the team? Are Souttar and Anel blocking Dovydas Sasnauskas? I’m with you that the youngsters need chances, but there is a time and a place, and Hull away on a Friday night is not that place, especially when the team is already so young.

If they are good enough they are old enough

Southampton have an 18 year old playing for them against man u today, just won them a pen and has looked their best player so far

McCallum and burrows are doing their job and playing well, Brewster isn't, so don't get that point at all

 

[Frank the tank]

If they are good enough they are old enough

Southampton have an 18 year old playing for them against man u today, just won them a pen and has looked their best player so far

McCallum and burrows are doing their job and playing well, Brewster isn't, so don't get that point at all

I'm very excited about marsh but he's no where near ready for the first team yet

You can see that just from looking at him
The kids special though I think if he physically develops even only as much as a david Brooks or James maddison ( who he reminds me a lot of) he's going to play at the top

 

[Lama]

If they are good enough they are old enough

Southampton have an 18 year old playing for them against man u today, just won them a pen and has looked their best player so far

McCallum and burrows are doing their job and playing well, Brewster isn't, so don't get that point at all

The “if they are good enough, they are old enough” comment is generally reserved for only the very best young players, generational talents. The vast majority of young players need time to learn, and freedom to make mistakes - I’m of the opinion that last night was not one of those games where we could particularly afford to do that.

I’d say Brewster did his job when he came on; he played a part in the goal and we remained comfortable for the rest of the game with him on the pitch. Had Marsh come on and made that volleyed pass to Moore, I suspect we’d all be lapping it up and praising his contribution.

But ultimately, none of this matters, and if you read my original post you’d know that I think it’s unlikely Brewster will come good. I’m just disappointed when posters (I’m not even referring to you) cross the line from discussion to ridicule and vitriolic comments.

 

[71Blade]

I think a few will be eating humble pie this season. Brewster has quality. If he stays fit it will show, as it did with his incisive pass (on the half-volley) for our second last night.

I honestly can't see it i just don't think Brewster and the Blades are a good fit, He comes across as a real nice decent kid I'd swap that for a real shit but scores goals. The price tag isn't his fault we all wanted him he just looks lost to me maybe guilty of trying to hard. I'd love to be proved wrong though. UTB

 

[Not so Slim ane]

The “if they are good enough, they are old enough” comment is generally reserved for only the very best young players, generational talents. The vast majority of young players need time to learn, and freedom to make mistakes - I’m of the opinion that last night was not one of those games where we could particularly afford to do that.

I’d say Brewster did his job when he came on; he played a part in the goal and we remained comfortable for the rest of the game with him on the pitch. Had Marsh come on and made that volleyed pass to Moore, I suspect we’d all be lapping it up and praising his contribution.

But ultimately, none of this matters, and if you read my original post you’d know that I think it’s unlikely Brewster will come good. I’m just disappointed when posters (I’m not even referring to you) cross the line from discussion to ridicule and vitriolic comments.

Marsh has played about 20 minutes this season and scored, ironically when Brewster took a terrible penalty then stood there like a pudding rather than following in. If we gave Marsh 20 mins last night instead of Brewster there is a good chance he would have scored again

Let's be honest Brewster kicked the ball anywhere in the build up to the goal, it was a bad pass that was going out of play and Moore did well to keep it in

I just think he's taking the place of someone who could contribute and it's time to call it a day. Bewster is as bad, if not worse, in his position than Gribic was

 

[Not so Slim ane]

I'm very excited about marsh but he's no where near ready for the first team yet

You can see that just from looking at him
The kids special though I think if he physically develops even only as much as a david Brooks or James maddison ( who he reminds me a lot of) he's going to play at the top

He's not a starter I agree but 20 mins here and there is where he should be at the moment.... David Brooks was built like a 12 year old and it didn't stop him ripping the pigs to pieces

 

[Frank the tank]

He's not a starter I agree but 20 mins here and there is where he should be at the moment.... David Brooks was built like a 12 year old and it didn't stop him ripping the pigs to pieces

Brooks is like the hulk compared to marsh

 

[Lama]

Marsh has played about 20 minutes this season and scored, ironically when Brewster took a terrible penalty then stood there like a pudding rather than following in. If we gave Marsh 20 mins last night instead of Brewster there is a good chance he would have scored again

Let's be honest Brewster kicked the ball anywhere in the build up to the goal, it was a bad pass that was going out of play and Moore did well to keep it in

I just think he's taking the place of someone who could contribute and it's time to call it a day. Bewster is as bad, if not worse, in his position than Gribic was

You honestly believe that:

• There is a good chance Marsh would have scored in last nights game.
• The ball to Moore was “a bad pass”
• Brewster is as bad, or worse than Gribic

I guess it’s different strokes for different folks, as I disagree with you entirely.

My ultimate point though isn’t that Brewster is good or bad: I just hope the criticism of him doesn’t cross the line, like it seems do normally.

Up the blades (including Brewster)

 

[djbaldken]

I think his general play this season so far has been fantastic. I think he’ll do a Billy, one will go in off his arse and then he’ll score 10 in 15 or something.

I think you think way too much. Have a lay down. It's obviously affecting you.

Nothing. Zero. Zilch. Has been remotely FANTASTIC about his general play.
The chance of him doing a Billy are as remote as me having a night of unbridled sex in a three some with Scarlett Johansson and Salma Hayek.

 

[Houston_Blade]

You honestly believe that:

• There is a good chance Marsh would have scored in last nights game.
• The ball to Moore was “a bad pass”
• Brewster is as bad, or worse than Gribic

I guess it’s different strokes for different folks, as I disagree with you entirely.

My ultimate point though isn’t that Brewster is good or bad: I just hope the criticism of him doesn’t cross the line, like it seems do normally.

Up the blades (including Brewster)

The problem is, if you critique his performance then the same old posters trot out the same old excuses about why he’s good.

I said in an earlier post that he’s gone beyond the point of a nuanced argument now, you’re either seen as slagging him off or blindly praising him.

For me he’s the worst signing we’ve ever made and needs to be getting 9/10 every time he’s on the pitch to get anywhere near redeeming the last few years of piss poor play.

The people who are desperate to justify him will try and spin what he did last night into something good, in reality he was bang average as ever, the Wolves game last year being the case in point where a 6/10 performance was lauded by some as a Haaland-esque coming of age for the lad.

I’m looking forward to him either doing something or leaving in the summer, it’s a win:win for the club as he either helps us this season and we get an option to keep him or just slides off into obscurity and we can all forget he ever played here.

 

[Agreasychipbutty]

Jumping blind for that ball was so random, but it paid off.

When he jumped I thought "wtf is he trying there" but without him knowing much about it, it turned into a perfect through ball. You miss every shot you don't take.

 

[Not so Slim ane]

You honestly believe that:

• There is a good chance Marsh would have scored in last nights game.
• The ball to Moore was “a bad pass”
• Brewster is as bad, or worse than Gribic

I guess it’s different strokes for different folks, as I disagree with you entirely.

My ultimate point though isn’t that Brewster is good or bad: I just hope the criticism of him doesn’t cross the line, like it seems do normally.

Up the blades (including Brewster)

Yes I think there is a good chance Marsh would have scored against a poor hull team chasing the game and leaving massive gaps at the back, the lad is a natural goalscorer, you can see it in his game. The reaction to the penalty against Wrexham tells you all you need to know, Brewster was ten yards from it scratching his arse (follow in your shots), marsh was on it like a flash.

I'd say Brewster is worse than Gribic... Gribic's mistakes are highlighted more because they result in a goal. He occasionally makes a good save whereas Brewster rarely even registers a shot, his movement is terrible, he can't tackle, can't pass and is always injured.

 

[Wright1889]

I think you think way too much. Have a lay down. It's obviously affecting you.

Nothing. Zero. Zilch. Has been remotely FANTASTIC about his general play.
The chance of him doing a Billy are as remote as me having a night of unbridled sex in a three some with Scarlett Johansson and Salma Hayek.

I think you think way too much. Have a lay down. It’s a obviously affecting you.

You wouldn’t have a chance with Pat Butcher and Dot Cotton ya melted welly

 

[Lama]

The problem is, if you critique his performance then the same old posters trot out the same old excuses about why he’s good.

I said in an earlier post that he’s gone beyond the point of a nuanced argument now, you’re either seen as slagging him off or blindly praising him.

For me he’s the worst signing we’ve ever made and needs to be getting 9/10 every time he’s on the pitch to get anywhere near redeeming the last few years of piss poor play.

The people who are desperate to justify him will try and spin what he did last night into something good, in reality he was bang average as ever, the Wolves game last year being the case in point where a 6/10 performance was lauded by some as a Haaland-esque coming of age for the lad.

I’m looking forward to him either doing something or leaving in the summer, it’s a win:win for the club as he either helps us this season and we get an option to keep him or just slides off into obscurity and we can all forget he ever played here.

Completely agree with this, no matter the subject it’s seems opinions are less and less nuanced these days.

What you say is true, he will basically need to score in every remaining game, and get us promoted to come close to justifying his £20m price tag.

That being said, who’s to say there’s not a £5m, a £10m or even just a £2m player in there?

Even if he has another disappointing season and ends up leaving on a free, I hope people get behind him when he wears the shirt, as his torrid time wasn’t self inflicted. I can understand why a unitedite may have hammered Marlon King, Jose Baxter, Lys Mousset or Ravel Morrison - as their problems appeared self inflicted; that’s not the case with Brewster.

 

[Houston_Blade]

Completely agree with this, no matter the subject it’s seems opinions are less and less nuanced these days.

What you say is true, he will basically need to score in every remaining game, and get us promoted to come close to justifying his £20m price tag.

That being said, who’s to say there’s not a £5m, a £10m or even just a £2m player in there?

Even if he has another disappointing season and ends up leaving on a free, I hope people get behind him when he wears the shirt, as his torrid time wasn’t self inflicted. I can understand why a unitedite may have hammered Marlon King, Jose Baxter, Lys Mousset or Ravel Morrison - as their problems appeared self inflicted; that’s not the case with Brewster.

While he’s on the pitch I’m behind him, the problem is that when he comes on a little bit of me dies.

I don’t want any Blades players to be shit, no Blade does really, I’d just prefer if someone else plays instead of him based on how good he is.

 

[100% part time blade]

I'd say Brewster is worse than Gribic... Gribic's mistakes are highlighted more because they result in a goal. He occasionally makes a good save whereas Brewster rarely even registers a shot, his movement is terrible, he can't tackle, can't pass and is always injured.

He doesn’t.

 

[CaptainMorgans]

Great cameo today. Worked really hard for the team and showed some really nice touches. I think hope that he was more effective than O'Hare who he replaced.
Keep it up, Rhian.

 

[Blade56]

Stood by the lad to long now. Time to get him off the wage bill. He could do with a spell abroad then come back as someone’s rescue project