I find it strange to the point that it's almost amusing to see so many people with such certain views as to whether it'd be a good move or not. It'd be a punt, by definition who the fuck knows?
Could be inspired, a former England CB with shitloads of PL experience coming in and giving us assurance at the back.
Could also be an old, way past his best cart horse with nothing to offer.
Fact is, no one knows and those saying 'he's not been good enough to get in Everton's team' need to get their heads out of the clouds. That there pond ain't the one we're fishing in lads.