Bullshit
30,000 of our fans makes everything worse, considering we are the worst fans in football
We could have afforded quality players
My list when we got promoted included Conor Gallagher, Ivan Toney, Jarod Bowen, Ollie Watkins, Ryan Sessignon, all at lower league clubs than us at the time.
Most of these could have been brought in for less than Berge, Brewster, Freeman Robinson and McBurnie at the time
I think the reported fee for Sessegnon was £30 million pound after performance-related add-ons, alongside 5 years of Tottenham-level wages (rather than Sheffield United level) to factor into the budget as well.
In order to tempt him away from London (where he was already playing), and away from potentially champions league football and challenging for the title, to instead come to a club everyone had as nailed-on relegation fodder, we’d have had to offer a LOT more than that.
I’m sure we would have loved to have signed Watkins -his fee reportedly had a top-line of £33 million pounds after add-ons, and I suspect he was offered higher wages too.
I’ve no idea what wages Chelsea were paying Connor Gallagher back then, or what fee they might have asked for him, but I don’t think they had any interest in selling did they?
Jarrod Bowen went for £22 million reportedly, and wages of £3 million a year. He had a choice of 2 very well established premier league London clubs, and apparently went for the one that offered him the best personal terms. At the time, West Ham were desperate as they were on the verge of the relegation zone that January. Maybe we should have gone in for him, but I think they would have outmuscled us financially, just as they did Palace.
In 2020, Ivan Toney would have been a great buy, but at the time he was lower down the food-chain: he was the best of league one, looking for a championship move: we were looking at the best of the championship at players looking for a premier league move (e.g. Watkins whom Toney ended up replacing at Brentford).
We were also reportedly in for Eze and Maupay, but again they didn’t want to come and went elsewhere for more money.
As well as affording the transfer fee, and affording the wages, we also have to persuade players that joining Sheffield United is better than any other option for their careers. That normally means offering more money than other clubs might be offering.
I’d be surprised if we could have brought in the players you listed for ‘less’ than the players we bought, with the exception of Towney who proved to be a very good buy for Brentford in the championship, and whom none of the other premier league clubs were considering at the time.
I’d say we got good players for our outlay, who have done well in getting us to a good position this year. Any purchase is a gamble, because any player can get injured in any game and be out for months, or even years. I think Brewster was the biggest gamble, and successive injuries have made his acquisition by far the least successful. Mousset was a fairly big outlay, and we got nothing back on him, but his mid-season goals helped us get a top 10 finish, so maybe it was worth it. Ramsdale cost even more in the 2nd season, but we made quite a lot of profit on his sale.
I think the disastrous 2nd season had more to do with the defensive line-up than anything else: Ampadu, Bryan, Jagielka, and for some games Robinson, Basham - alongside Egan. I really think that’s where it all started to wrong, more than with the purchases above that we made, which actually weren’t that bad given that we were being regularly outbid by other big-spending premier league clubs around us at the time.