Who’s the worst of the worst?

[Bayingblade]

Paul Williams. Guthrie-esq in ability but at a lower level.

 

[Badger Blade]

Robinson has hardly covered himself in glory, every time the ball comes his way he looks like he's going to either let it go under his foot or his touch will take it 5 yards away from him. A good game for him isn't one where he's made a goal-saving tackle, block or clearance, a good game for him is one where he's managed not to embarrass himself. Like when the weather in this country is considered to be nice just because it hasn't rained.

He's still not as bad as McEveley, the fact that he was captain shows how bad the rest of them were. He'd shout and wave his arms at everyone else then promptly have an airswing, pass the ball straight to the opposition, fall over or be looking in the opposite direction to the ball. There are plenty from that period who were diabolical, like Stewart, Taylor, Nosworthy, Collins, Williams, Westlake.

 

[Champagneblade]

Robinson has hardly covered himself in glory, every time the ball comes his way he looks like he's going to either let it go under his foot or his touch will take it 5 yards away from him. A good game for him isn't one where he's made a goal-saving tackle, block or clearance, a good game for him is one where he's managed not to embarrass himself. Like when the weather in this country is considered to be nice just because it hasn't rained.

He's still not as bad as McEveley, the fact that he was captain shows how bad the rest of them were. He'd shout and wave his arms at everyone else then promptly have an airswing, pass the ball straight to the opposition, fall over or be looking in the opposite direction to the ball. There are plenty from that period who were diabolical, like Stewart, Taylor, Nosworthy, Collins, Williams, Westlake.

It's no coincidence that with Davies and playing a back three we'd started to pick up. Enter stage left Jack Robinson. After an unexpected win at Fulham, he screws up and we lose by 3 at Wolves, he takes his own man out as we lose to Derby and we let a 2 goal lead slip to Preston with the winner coming down the left hand side. Cheers mate. Now clear off!

 

[cahill]

Tebily was good and quickly got poached by Birmingham.

Simonsen was the worst for catastrophic errors in the last 20 years. No one else comes close for me.

True enough. That Wendy home game !

 

[guancheblade]

Didn't we make a tidy profit on Tebily into the bargain?

Very tidy indeed for someone who only played 8 games for us

 

[dtblade]

agree Robinson a bit of an accident waiting to happen
BUT at least he's got some physical presence, which were seriously lacking
Davies is an absolute lightweight and gets blown over by the wind, he needs sending back to the scousers

 

[SwitchBLADE Smiles]

I’m quite surprised to see that we’ve reached page 4 & there hasn’t been a single mention of Paddy McCarthy yet. Those 10 or so games left a permanent scar on my psyche…

At least Nosworthy & McEveley had some comedy value to them. McEveley would usually absolutely crunch someone for no reason (occasionally miles away from the ball) & due to Nosworthys Kryten shaped head, it was always interesting to see which direction the ball would fly. Spoiler for those who never saw him - it was always a significant distance away from its intended target.

 

[VwBlade]

A back five of Nosworthy Tebily McEveley Robinson and Stewart.

This website needs a vomit react for posts like that

 

[derfblade.3]

This website needs a vomit react for posts like that

Ok....