Hall of Fame new entry - Worst individual performances X1

[ReeceofBDTBL]

Congratulations to Ben Godfrey on the worst performance from a full back in living memory. I’ve seen this club churn out some tripe over the decades but what he did yesterday was absolutely astonishing.

The heart of a pea, no defensive instincts, quality, desire or even pride to stand up and at least try to defend properly against a team that rejected him last season

One of the singularly most disgusting performances I’ve even seen from a Sheffield United player. Even Mason Holgate tried, he was just as dumb as a stump.

But this kid is an absolute coward and a fraud. Disgraceful


Sheffield United individual performance all time worst X1 (updated):

Baxter (Burnley 2004)

Godfrey (Ipswich away 2025)
RND (Bristol Home 2025)
Robinson (Plymouth away 2025)
Sean McGinty (Colchester home 2013)

Woolford (Scunthorpe 2016)
Mark Rankine (2003, Millenium stadium)
Hammond (Scunthorpe 2016)
Cannon (Millwall at home 2025)

Sammon (Blackpool at home 2015)
Craig Beattie (Burnley 2009 Wembley)

 

[Nicolaus_Copernicus]

Smeets (Portsmouth away 1999)

 

[Nedski]

McBurnie v Burnley
Burrows - pick any game this season

 

[wardonia_blade]

RND V Cardiff in the cup last year.

 

[FMBlade1]

Nosworthy Vs Burnley

 

[Rochdaleblade]

Dries Boussatta surely gets a mention. A sub getting subbed. Back in the days when only a couple of subs were allowed.

 

[bladesince64]

Congratulations to Ben Godfrey on the worst performance from a full back in living memory. I’ve seen this club churn out some tripe over the decades but what he did yesterday was absolutely astonishing.

The heart of a pea, no defensive instincts, quality, desire or even pride to stand up and at least try to defend properly against a team that rejected him last season

One of the singularly most disgusting performances I’ve even seen from a Sheffield United player. Even Mason Holgate tried, he was just as dumb as a stump.

But this kid is an absolute coward and a fraud. Disgraceful


Sheffield United individual performance all time worst X1 (updated):

Baxter (Burnley 2004)

Godfrey (Ipswich away 2025)
RND (Bristol Home 2025)
Robinson (Plymouth away 2025)
Sean McGinty (Colchester home 2013)

Woolford (Scunthorpe 2016)
Mark Rankine (2003, Millenium stadium)
Hammond (Scunthorpe 2016)
Cannon (Millwall at home 2025)

Sammon (Blackpool at home 2015)
Craig Beattie (Burnley 2009 Wembley)

Reading some of those made me laugh and physically shudder at the same time

 

[SB_90]

Nosworthy Vs Burnley

Nosworthy V Hull on boxing day, when he vanished

 

[Carlton Blade]

Steve Bruce v Portsmouth or Sunderland in 98

 

[Carlton Blade]

Oli Norwood v Birmingham. 2018

 

[Carlton Blade]

Beesley v Gabbiadini