Stadium Development leads to Team Regression - nothing new at The Lane

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Cheshire Cat

Active Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2009
Messages
1,209
Reaction score
2,221
Location
Poynton
Whilst I was idly passing the time whilst nothing much was happening in the transfer window I got to thinking about how every time we develop Bramall Lane, we go backwards on the pitch.

I'll admit that I used no historical sources beyond that of my own memory, but I was quickly able to draw a parallel between new stands / improved stands and either relegation or a period of struggle on the pitch.

Can anyone add anything to:
  • Bramall Lane Corner and Hotel - relegation from Premier League
  • New John Street Stand - 6 years of struggle ending with 2002/3's unexpected cup-run
  • (Pushing it a bit) New Kop roof - relegation from the Premier League inside two seasons
  • South Stand - Divisions 1 to 4 in 5 seasons
  • Bramall Lane Stand (before my time so could be wrong) - dipped out of the first division

Clearly its got something to do with spending more than we can afford and cutting back on the pitch - and certainly not a new phenomenon. We also have an uncanny knack of investing at exactly the wrong time - leading to planned costs or benefits going completely tits up.

It's also come to be a real omen for me - along with 6 year play-off final cycles and the like. Any traders looking for Black Swans should probably look at our building plans - if something is slated for completion, there's a chance that an economic meltdown is just around the corner.
 



It's not uncommon for clubs to struggle after redeveloping on-site. Those who've moved to identikit stadia in soulless retail parks have generally done a lot better as they have the proceeds of city centre land sales to play with.

Chelsea built a monster of an East Stand in the '80s and suffered for it. Notts Country were in the top division in 1990, completely redeveloped Meadow Lane, and have been stuffed ever since.

One exception springs to mind... Wendy have been veeery lucky to have their ground improved with assistance from others (world cup and euro money).
 
It's not uncommon for clubs to struggle after redeveloping on-site. Those who've moved to identikit stadia in soulless retail parks have generally done a lot better as they have the proceeds of city centre land sales to play with.

Chelsea built a monster of an East Stand in the '80s and suffered for it. Notts Country were in the top division in 1990, completely redeveloped Meadow Lane, and have been stuffed ever since.

One exception springs to mind... Wendy have been veeery lucky to have their ground improved with assistance from others (world cup and euro money).

Very lucky indeed, PLEASE just remind me (and make me laugh), what division are they in?
 
Very lucky indeed, PLEASE just remind me (and make me laugh), what division are they in?

I'd be glad to. :)

But I think we need to thank some horrendous Wendy mismanagement for their current plight (hello Dave!), not their expenditure on the ground. The fact they didn't bulldoze Leppings Lane after the tragedy shows how little willingness they've shown in that regard.
 
Yep its true of Wednesday as well

5 Painters turn up and the following season they get relegated
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom