Hard disagree.
His ego is way too big, he's always looking to make a "look at me" big tackle for a cheer, but then multiple times gets dragged out of position by opposition. Every single game he ends up wrong side of the ball because he gets sucked in looking for a duel., and has to save himself by taking a booking. He's incapable of staying in shape and showing discipline.
He needs to sit in position, do the boring unspectacular work and be a cog in the machine. Unfortunately his personality and ego mean he needs to feel important and the star of the show, so he goes wandering around looking to be involved where he shouldn't.
He's still miles off redemption in my view