Odds at the start of the season...

[TomMounsey]

On Gary Madine crowdsurfing off the team bus singing Mind the gap Sheffield Wednesday?

 

[knowsnowt]

40/9 is my guess. Though I don't really understand this betting lark.

 

[Guesty]

I don't know, but you'd have to find a niche bookies!

 

[DifferentClass]

When pigs flew.

Or surfed in this case.

 

[Paisley Blade]

On Gary Madine crowdsurfing off the team bus singing Mind the gap Sheffield Wednesday?

Hmmm ... attempting to curry favour all too obviously methinks.

Never mind , he's done OK , especially his performance in that big 3 points against Boro where his introduction was pivotal.

 

[Bladesman]

 

[Kozzy_is_my_Dad]

I was never for signing him and I don't think he's been good enough, but I'll give it to him, that's class!

 

[SteveBlade]

Gary Madine = A Championship James Hanson.

Solid signings that helped us over the line, but beyond that, not quite up to the level above.

From what I'm hearing, Wilder fancies Madine for next season, so what the fuck do I know?

 

[Grizzly blade]

He might be useful, my only issue being that if the king of direct didn’t want him at Cardiff I have to wonder what we might want him for.
But I’m happy to wait and see.

I preferred it when we didn’t go direct to him, I feel he’s more than just a big lad

 

[Punk Blade]

I still can't make out the last line of that one...

 

[fatpat]

sorry but he is at best an average championship player. we can do much much better than him, singing that song shows him not to have any real character I'm afraid. while we lap it up cuz its aimed at piggies, to me it says he has no loyalty to anyone but himself, back to cardiff please

 

[blade67]

On Gary Madine crowdsurfing off the team bus singing Mind the gap Sheffield Wednesday?

It's been an emotional time. I'd have him back next year personally. Whilst he's been a Championship, James Hanson, I can see him being a Premier League James Hanson as well

 

[Bruce Wayne]

Madine should be nowhere near our squad next season. My opinion.

 

[Niceguyeddie]

He might be useful, my only issue being that if the king of direct didn’t want him at Cardiff I have to wonder what we might want him for.
But I’m happy to wait and see.

I preferred it when we didn’t go direct to him, I feel he’s more than just a big lad

Cardiff are direct very direct ,they either launch it into the inside channels for someone quick to chase or into the outside channels for someone quick to chase and cross it first time for someone quick to get on the end of ,no midfield runners ,not really any midfield at all

 

[AWetFlannel]

I'm as harsh on Madine as anyone, but just for this thread, lets appreciate what we have just witnessed.

Mind
The



Gap

 

[Pinchy]

When pigs flew.

Or surfed in this case.

Which pigs?

 

[Pinchy]

I'm as harsh on Madine as anyone

Why?

 

[AWetFlannel]

Why?

His past behaviour, specifically in relation to our club.

He was, without contest, the most hated individual player by our fan base.

But as I said above, would forget that just to enjoy this thread.

 

[Pinchy]

His past behaviour, specifically in relation to our club.

He was, without contest, the most hated individual player by our fan base.

But as I said above, would forget that just to enjoy this thread.

Our fan base is the least sophisticated in the world so I’m not impressed by what they think.

The Machine has contributed significantly and substantially to our promotion. If Dirty Corrupt Leeds had been bright enough to bring in Madine and Hogan to increase the depth of their threadbare strike force it might have been different. They didn’t; we did. Tufty sees beyond the infantile agenda.

 

[AWetFlannel]

Our fan base is the least sophisticated in the world so I’m not impressed by what they think.

The Machine has contributed significantly and substantially to our promotion. If Dirty Corrupt Leeds had been bright enough to bring in Madine and Hogan to increase the depth of their threadbare strike force it might have been different. They didn’t; we did. Tufty sees beyond the infantile agenda.

Given some of the questionable opinions you have stated about our manager and players over the years, I'll take my 'infantile' opinion on Madine over yours ta.

Not liking a human for being a bellend isn't an agenda, it is just having an opinion. I haven't tried to dislike Madine over the years due to some strange agenda, it has just happened to me and 99% of our fan base due to his actions.

 

[hidesbehindapseudonym]

On balance Madine has done a good job for us.
.Lots of comments on here about "could do better" but IMO that depends on us spending a wad. Not our forte.

 

[Pinchy]

Given some of the questionable opinions you have stated about our manager and players over the years, I'll take my 'infantile' opinion on Madine over yours ta.

Not liking a human for being a bellend isn't an agenda, it is just having an opinion. I haven't tried to dislike Madine over the years due to some strange agenda, it has just happened to me and 99% of our fan base due to his actions.

But not our manager. I’ll go with him; not thick fans.