Decided to read the whole thread before writing anything (not a lot else to do on a non-football, non-pub, non-owt Friday). I also took the advantage of watching Barnsley v Chelsea.
Firstly, we won, and are in the quarter finals. This is good news which was not inevitable. I thought Bogle was great, and we appear to have stumbled on a player with real potential. Ramsdale did ok, and because Bristol City seem to present far less of a challenge than their neighbours (who I thought were great, and "managed" us far better than Plymouth, who had more skill but less "oomph"), the defence was ok.
Now for the less good bit. If we agree that Chelsea's second string would make a decent PL side, rather better than we are now, it's likely that we'll make less of a game against them than Barnsley did. Barnsley had (and have) something we've shown little of this season - a plan, and reasonably effective tactics and skills. They were solid, passed well, and had a go at keeping possession. But what really struck me was that they had some urgency and purpose, they defended in numbers, and got the ball forward relatively quickly. They didn't spend forever tapping it around and seemed to recognise that the aim of the game was to put the ball in Chelsea's net. They didn't succeed, but their "having a go " wasn't short of skill and some effectiveness. They weren't bad to watch either- I didn't nod off!
I spoke to Esteemed Forgeblade during the game and said "Is it me or do we play in a really ponderous and sluggish way?". Sadly, I have to say it wasn't my tactical ineptitude, but he confirmed that compared to Barnsley, we look slow and ponderous.
So, this is actually the embarrassing part. Despite the 4 great years, the double promotions, the £100 million plus spent, we're likely in a few short months to end up where we've spent many years - in the same division as little old Barnsley.
It does make you think, "what was all that about then?"
The other embarrassing part is that if Barnsley had won, the way we have been "performing", we would perhaps have no better chance of winning than we have at Chelsea.
It's obvious I'm no Clapper, but I'm not a doom merchant either. However, I do think that after watching two fairly average Championship sides on consecutive nights, that those who think we'll storm that league next year are a bit deluded.
Ta for reading!