KEVIN MCDONALD

[PeterNdlovu081]

Valid points, and don't disagree with most of them. We have certainly detracted from my opening point though. Do you think we would be in the top 6 now if McDonald was here all season? My answer would be yes, if yours isn't, well fair enough. That's football!

For us to be in the top 6 now means Weir would still be manager.

So if we had kept McDonald you think Weir would have got us into the play offs?

That's absolutely insane.

 

[super_pig]

In terms of Monty,ability limited certainly,never hid when the going got tough .Completely different player to KMac whereas Monty's job was to mark and tackle...KMAC is incapable of doing either.

cool. i always wondered what his job was.. he wasn't very good at it was he?? like you said completely different player to KMac.. so you have contradicted yourself

 

[Rossb123]

We haven't ever replaced Mcdonald correct, but who could we replace him with? Iv seen a lot of League One games this season and haven't seen anyone playing at this level that is as good as him.

He quite clearly is only playing at this level because wolves knew about his release clause and are still paying championship/premiership wages. Mcdonald left us because of money and he felt he had a better chance of getting to the championship with wolves than us.

I can't really blame him for leaving to be honest, he's earning more money and gone to a team that will be playing championship football next season.

 

[Harry's Game]

We haven't ever replaced Mcdonald correct, but who could we replace him with? Iv seen a lot of League One games this season and haven't seen anyone playing at this level that is as good as him.

He quite clearly is only playing at this level because wolves knew about his release clause and are still paying championship/premiership wages. Mcdonald left us because of money and he felt he had a better chance of getting to the championship with wolves than us.

I can't really blame him for leaving to be honest, he's earning more money and gone to a team that will be playing championship football next season.

Almost exactly what I said so be careful people will be calling you a pig.

 

[Rossb123]

Almost exactly what said so be careful people will be calling you a pig.

With 8 Page's of comments I chose not to read though and just say what I thought, thanks for the heads up though! ha-ha

 

[GRUMPY BLADE]

OK OK I'll shut up now. I rest my case!

It's not what you smoke, it's how much you have

 

[bartman]

cool. i always wondered what his job was.. he wasn't very good at it was he?? like you said completely different player to KMac.. so you have contradicted yourself

Are you trying to say Monty couldn't mark or tackle. ? It was all he could do as his passing was awful.

Therefore no contradiction

 

[Bladesway]

"But you should avoid bringing McCall into the debate because he was a fantastic player in his prime. Remember watching him against Brazil in the 1990 world cup and he was excellent."

Sorry but that's case closed in my eyes. Playing in the SPL apparently means squat but a World Cup game against Brazil just about polishes that argument off.

That said, MacDonald was great against Notts County for us so that's about the same isn't it?

 

[super_pig]

Are you trying to say Monty couldn't mark or tackle. ? It was all he could do as his passing was awful.

Therefore no contradiction

kmacs job was NOT to mark and tackle.. does that make it clearer
monty still divisive although he left yonks ago

 

[bartman]

kmacs job was NOT to mark and tackle.. does that make it clearer
monty still divisive although he left yonks ago

he played in midfield...of course it is his job to mark and tackle. At least you seem to be acknowledging that Doyle was doing his work for him then

 

[green blade]

K mac left for money. No other reason. Good player yes. Blade No. , Move on. He has !

 

[Bladesway]

K mac left for money. No other reason. Good player yes. Blade No. , Move on. He has !

Nice to see Yoda is still in the building.