Intersting Outsiders View On SO'D

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Jim Chimmerney

Can hear the 'Cod Army' roar from his back garden
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Messages
7,474
Reaction score
5,101
Location
Parts Unknown
From FANHOUSEUK;

If he harbours serious ambitions to further himself and to perhaps one day manage in the Premier League, Sean O'Driscoll must leave Doncaster Rovers and grab Sheffield United's offer with both hands.

Canny Rovers chairman John Ryan has taken the moral high ground by granting his manager for the last four years permission to talk with their South Yorkshire rivals, rather than be seen to be attempting to stand in the way of the 53-year-old.

It's a smart tactic, but O'Driscoll needs to call his bluff by agreeing to succeed Gary Speed. There's an awful lot of work needed to be done to transform things at Bramall Lane, and the sooner he starts, the better.

In short, O'Driscoll has taken Doncaster as far as he can. After winning promotion through the League One play-offs in 2008, to leave them in the top half of the Championship just four points shy of the play-offs is the stuff of minor miracles, for a club who at best should be in the top eight of League One given their crowds, status and history.

The first step would be the hardest, it being a backward one, with United languishing in 20th, four points clear of danger. He has to look beyond that, and has shown enough foresight already in his career to suggest he will. There may be a certain amount of turmoil in the red half of Sheffield, but that just adds to the challenge, and the rewards if he gets things right. O'Driscoll would be tapping into far greater potential than he could ever hope to have at the Keepmoat Stadium. Even given their appalling start to the season allied to Arctic weather conditions, there were still over 17,000 at Bramall Lane to see the much-needed victory over Swansea under caretaker manager John Carver - almost double Doncaster's average for what has been one of the best runs in their history, a third consecutive campaign in the second tier.

Rovers' demand for in the region of £500,000 compensation shouldn't prove a stumbling block, as the Blades received a tidy sum from the Welsh FA for Speed, who jumped ship after a distinctly under-whelming four months at the helm. The Bramall Lane board must have thought Christmas had come early to receive money for a manager who had he not improved things pretty quickly, they would have had to consider sacking.

Not since Newcastle inexplicably paid a hefty sum to Blackburn to take the hapless Graeme Souness, who was on the brink of the sack at Ewood Park, has outside interest in a manager been so welcomed.

"It will be substantial (compensation)," Ryan insisted, if his ploy to prevent O'Driscoll becoming United's third permanent manager this season backfires. "If Sheffield United don't pay, they can forget about taking our manager because Sean leaving us in mid-season would put us in a very difficult predicament.

"I've given Sean permission to speak with them but I don't think anything will happen this side of Christmas. I've spoken to Sean and I'm confident that he'll stay. Further attempting to cast doubts into the mind of his manager, he added: "We have a better chance of getting promotion and we're willing to back our manager to the hilt. I don't know whether Sheffield United's fans would give him enough time."

Either way, O'Driscoll will be in the dugout at Bramall Lane on January 3, when the clubs meet in the Championship, Rovers looking to achieve the double over their local rivals.

Having proved impervious to Burnley's advances before they unwisely appointed the hopelessly out of his depth Brian Laws to fill the void left by Owen Coyle 12 months ago, a similar course of action from O'Driscoll would hint at a lack of ambition - or bottle - or both in his unwillingness to leave his Keepmoat comfort zone for a fresh, bigger challenge. If he only does it to spare long-suffering Blades fans the hope-draining appearance of perma-tanned Phil Brown as their next manager, that should be reason enough.

Fair enough he has a history of putting down roots at a club, as 17 years and 750 games as a player and manager at Bournemouth might suggest. But he will be acutely aware that there's only a brief window in any managerial career where your stock is so high that clubs actually come calling. Otherwise, it's back to hopefully submitting your CV with the 30 other canditates who're attempting to get back on the merry-go-round. When on this occasion that club is three times the size of the one you're at, you owe it to yourself to give it a crack to see how far you can take it.

He could accept it and end up being sacked at the end of the season, but at least he'd have given it a try and not been undermined by that nagging doubt of what might have been had he not opted for the 'nothing ventured, nothing gained' course of inaction on which Ryan clearly pins his hopes.

As the likes of Colchester, Southend and Grimsby - all clubs of similar stature to Rovers - have all recently shown, a minnow's time at a rarified level always has a certain shelf-life before finances catch up with them and they head back down from whence they came. Time to get out Sean, or you will live to regret it.
 



Difficult to disagree with much of that. The only thing is, are we a big enough club for his ambition? He may decide to sit it out and wait for a premier league job.

As it happens though, i think we could well be the perfect club for him. He's not going to get much attention whilst he's at Doncaster from the big boys, we could be a useful stepping stone for him.
 
Difficult to disagree with much of that. The only thing is, are we a big enough club for his ambition? He may decide to sit it out and wait for a premier league job.

As it happens though, i think we could well be the perfect club for him. He's not going to get much attention whilst he's at Doncaster from the big boys, we could be a useful stepping stone for him.

We're by no means a sleeping giant but there may never be a better time to take over a club like us, who could sustain Premier League status, as now when expectations and morale are currently so low. Whilst he would need to get results to stay in this League, the pressure is less now than it would have been, say, if he'd taken over in the Summer when everyone would have been screaming play-offs at least. He would have half a season to start getting his methods across, assess the squad and then start re-building in the Summer. It wouldn't be difficult for him to stamp his authority on us and make pretty noticeable changes for the good and that can only further enhance his CV so I agree it could be a decent stepping stone if he wanted it.

As the article says, it's all down to him and his ambition but this kind of job, at this time, with a club like us doesn't come around very often.
 
Without wanting to sound arrogant, it sums it up pretty well.

We are a bigger club than Donny, we have so much more potential, we just need someone to coax it out of us.
What Donny have achieved over the last few years, is nothing short of remarkable, and while he may be moving down the footballing infastructure, I see it only as a temporary basis and we will soon be back above Donny,
 
We're by no means a sleeping giant but there may never be a better time to take over a club like us, who could sustain Premier League status, as now when expectations and morale are currently so low. Whilst he would need to get results to stay in this League, the pressure is less now than it would have been, say, if he'd taken over in the Summer when everyone would have been screaming play-offs at least. He would have half a season to start getting his methods across, assess the squad and then start re-building in the Summer. It wouldn't be difficult for him to stamp his authority on us and make pretty noticeable changes for the good and that can only further enhance his CV so I agree it could be a decent stepping stone if he wanted it.

As the article says, it's all down to him and his ambition but this kind of job, at this time, with a club like us doesn't come around very often.

But so much rides on us staying up.
 
The only issue with that Highbury is, he doesn't want to step up too far. The bigger step you make the harder it will be! I think a move to us would be a perfect move for him.
 
Difficult to disagree with much of that. The only thing is, are we a big enough club for his ambition? He may decide to sit it out and wait for a premier league job.

As it happens though, i think we could well be the perfect club for him. He's not going to get much attention whilst he's at Doncaster from the big boys, we could be a useful stepping stone for him.

You seriously think a bigger club than us will come in for SOD?

Shame to read so much implied negativity on here about us. Of course the manager of Doncaster Rovers should jump at the chance to manage us. He'd be barking mad or a bottler not too.

And if Donny fans were trying tempt the manager of Sheffield FC they'd be saying the same things, it's the natural order of things in football not arrogance.

Let's not forget we have averaged the biggest gates of any club in the country for the appalling silverware record we haveand not so long ago average over 30,000 for the second time since one of the biggest clubs in the world managed it.

Yet somehow we approach the management situation like we do everything else at United - being negative, doing ourselves down instead of demanding and expecting the very best we can get.

I'm not saying we are going to win the Prem like Wednesday will! but let's not kid ourselves that a move from Donny to United is not a massive step up and if SOD is even considering turning it down then he's not the man for us.
 
You seriously think a bigger club than us will come in for SOD?

Shame to read so much implied negativity on here about us. Of course the manager of Doncaster Rovers should jump at the chance to manage us. He'd be barking mad or a bottler not too.

And if Donny fans were trying tempt the manager of Sheffield FC they'd be saying the same things, it's the natural order of things in football not arrogance.

Let's not forget we have averaged the biggest gates of any club in the country for the appalling silverware record we haveand not so long ago average over 30,000 for the second time since one of the biggest clubs in the world managed it.

Yet somehow we approach the management situation like we do everything else at United - being negative, doing ourselves down instead of demanding and expecting the very best we can get.

I'm not saying we are going to win the Prem like Wednesday will! but let's not kid ourselves that a move from Donny to United is not a massive step up and if SOD is even considering turning it down then he's not the man for us.

I like the tone of your post and agree that most people connected with the club don't realise our immense potential. Irrespective of who the next manager is maybe it's time for those at the top to show some real positivity, the absence of which has been our hallmark since the day's of Dick Wragg.
 
You seriously think a bigger club than us will come in for SOD?

Shame to read so much implied negativity on here about us. Of course the manager of Doncaster Rovers should jump at the chance to manage us. He'd be barking mad or a bottler not too.

And if Donny fans were trying tempt the manager of Sheffield FC they'd be saying the same things, it's the natural order of things in football not arrogance.

Let's not forget we have averaged the biggest gates of any club in the country for the appalling silverware record we haveand not so long ago average over 30,000 for the second time since one of the biggest clubs in the world managed it.

Yet somehow we approach the management situation like we do everything else at United - being negative, doing ourselves down instead of demanding and expecting the very best we can get.

I'm not saying we are going to win the Prem like Wednesday will! but let's not kid ourselves that a move from Donny to United is not a massive step up and if SOD is even considering turning it down then he's not the man for us.

No I don't which is why O'Driscoll if he ever wants the opportunity to manage in the premiership then he should take the offer (If it has been made). If he does well at the lane, then either he'll go up with us, or he's more likely to get noticed by an established premiership club.
 
people keep saying we have to be patient with S'OD so he can get this methods across. Which premierleague club is going to be in a position to do that with him? I don't think any so a club the size of ourselves really is the next step for him. Wolves are not going to take a risk on him as they are close to the bottom and can't risk it. I don't personally thnk we are in any danger of going down ourselves so we are that club. Burnley proved when push came to shove they would not pay compo for him last season so I don't see them coming back for him now. It might sound arrogant or whatever but I don't care, we really are the only option if he is brave enough to make it
 
I like the tone of your post and agree that most people connected with the club don't realise our immense potential. Irrespective of who the next manager is maybe it's time for those at the top to show some real positivity, the absence of which has been our hallmark since the day's of Dick Wragg.

Most people outside the club don't realise our immense potential either. Unlike ALL other clubs of our size, we've won absolutely nothing for 85 years so the next manager won't even need to achieve much in order to attain legend status. Judging by some of the posts on here, stringing a few passes together will be enough to get O'Driscoll chaired off the pitch with his shoes missing, regardless of results! I'd just like us to attack, excite and score a few more goals than we have done lately. What other job could a manager hope for where the expectations are so low?
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom