If you could change one football decision in your United supporting lifetime, what would it be?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

The 2nd and 3rd games of the Prem relegation season vs Villa and Leeds. We had Egan sent off and Lundstram missed the penalty in the former... and missed a really good chance before Bamford scored in the latter.

I think wins in either of these would have seen us have a fighting chance of staying up
I've often thought that. The Villa goal should really have been saved by Ramsdale and there was a good shout for a foul in the build up to the Leeds goal. Win both those 1-0 and we have 6 points from the first 3 games. I think that would have led to a very different season.
 

Sacking Warnock / allowing him to leave or whatever happened. He would have got us promoted again within two seasons easily.
 
The 2006 penalty decision by Rob Styles when he said the Sheffield defender (Morgs) intended to foul Stevie (Gerrard) so Liverpool equalised . Those extra 2pts would have saved us from relegation

Or even scoring one of the two pens we missed v Blackburn.

Usworth did eventually score a pen that season at the Lane though
 
Letting Ched Evans be tried in court when the season ended ( as John Terry was allowed to do over the Anton Ferdinand saga ) instead of being tried and jailed before the season ended depriving us of the few goals needed for us to go up……..or…. Ched not being naughty at all.
 
I wonder if it's the Mandela Principle at work here, and after Adkins was moved swiftly on at Southampton, replaced by Mauricio Pottechino, fans from previously promoted/relegated teams, started to re-write history. Like you, I don't remember anyone suggesting Warnock get the chop after promotion. I think it would have ridiculous tbh.
I clearly remember people calling for us to replace him. It may be a different Bertie but I am pretty sure Bertiblade was in that camp. Apologies if I am wrong.
 
First point…….in your United supporting life time. This leaves potential for supporting others in your life time. 😧

100% not telling mi mates repeatedly that John Cofie would score 20 goals for us.
 
It would have to be the Deane & Fjortoft double whammy...

That cost us an appearance in the FA Cup final... In my opinion.

Biggest stab in the back to the fans ever..
 
For me it was the Blades decision not to head hunt me at school and invite me for a trial when I was a gangly lad back in the seventies.
 
Funny how things work though, by changing these past events, you might be changing the path we are currently on, and who knows that could be a golden era of PL and European glory,

i know it’s unlikely. But look at so many teams who’ve had success and look where they are now, Leicester are looking odds on for relegation, pigs are languishing in L1 after europe and cups in the 80s, Portsmouth and Bolton are L2 after europe in the 00s

That’s Football!
 
I apologise if my response deviates away from was asked but I feel I need to cleanse myself openly in front of you all.
It is 1966, I have been a Blade for some years and my joy was receiving my new season ticket wallet for the forthcoming season, checking there was always enough vouchers in the book to cover every game and enough extra vouchers to cover FA Cup games at home or replays or replays of replays or replays of replays of replays.
It is May 1966, the season had finished, we had ended up 9th in the League 1, our neighbours 17th, I think it should be applauded that this weekend they will still be playing in League 1 albeit 33 places lower.
The FA Cup was the biggest sporting event in the world of football at that time, teams took it seriously and hundreds of millions around the world watched it.
That year Sheffield Wednesday reached the final, they played every game away from hoe so yes it was a feat in itself. They were playing Everton.
100,000 filled the ground of which 103,000 were Wednesday fans
Wednesday took the lead 2-0 but Everton fought back with 2 goals from Treble Cock (not the real spelling but still makes me giggle) and then Gerry Young, the Wednesday defender thinking he was the next Bobby Moore, slipped and let in Derek Temple for the winner.
My heart was full, my smile from ear to ear - until...
My Mum and Dad, now both sadly long passed were both Blades, they followed them home and away throughout their courting days.
Wednesday despite losing, were awarded an open bus top parade throughout the town centre, culminating in a balcony appearance at the Town Hall. My Mum and Dad insisted we went as they had done Sheffield proud, and we should and join in their achievement.
What do I do, I am 9 years old, fake a cold, throw myself downstairs, no I had to go.
We go there and being only about 3 foot tall, I was either on my Dad's shoulders or had my face buried in the crotch of some blue and white clad, defeat celebrating neanderthal.
There were thousands outside the Town Hall, tens or hundreds of thousands if you count like Wednesday fans count. I just had to feign enjoyment for a couple of hours and make a promise to myself that come the day we appear in and win the FA Cup that, that day in 1966 will be laid to rest forever. Little was I to know that day would never come and more than likely will not happen in my lifetime - and that is my disappointment and where I feel let down
So, I went home and scrubbed and scrubbed my face and hands with Brillo pad after Brillo pad, truth is the smell and the sounds, and the visions of that day have never left me.

Can it be classed as abuse by my Mum and Dad or were they just showing me what celebrating failure looks like then just imaging what celebrating real success would be feel like. I never talked about it with them I did not want them to see how much they had disappointed me

Having written all that, I don't feel any cleaner, no weight has been lifted off my shoulders, I suppose it won't until the ills of later life hit me
 

Letting Ched Evans be tried in court when the season ended ( as John Terry was allowed to do over the Anton Ferdinand saga ) instead of being tried and jailed before the season ended depriving us of the few goals needed for us to go up……..or…. Ched not being naughty at all.
Yes, I wonder what we’d have done under Wilson in the championship as that was a decent team playing good football. If we’d found a decent striker in the summer it would have been interesting. Also Wednesday might have lost to Huddersfield in the final. Or if they didn’t we might have signed Rhodes!! Who knows.
 
I apologise if my response deviates away from was asked but I feel I need to cleanse myself openly in front of you all.
It is 1966, I have been a Blade for some years and my joy was receiving my new season ticket wallet for the forthcoming season, checking there was always enough vouchers in the book to cover every game and enough extra vouchers to cover FA Cup games at home or replays or replays of replays or replays of replays of replays.
It is May 1966, the season had finished, we had ended up 9th in the League 1, our neighbours 17th, I think it should be applauded that this weekend they will still be playing in League 1 albeit 33 places lower.
The FA Cup was the biggest sporting event in the world of football at that time, teams took it seriously and hundreds of millions around the world watched it.
That year Sheffield Wednesday reached the final, they played every game away from hoe so yes it was a feat in itself. They were playing Everton.
100,000 filled the ground of which 103,000 were Wednesday fans
Wednesday took the lead 2-0 but Everton fought back with 2 goals from Treble Cock (not the real spelling but still makes me giggle) and then Gerry Young, the Wednesday defender thinking he was the next Bobby Moore, slipped and let in Derek Temple for the winner.
My heart was full, my smile from ear to ear - until...
My Mum and Dad, now both sadly long passed were both Blades, they followed them home and away throughout their courting days.
Wednesday despite losing, were awarded an open bus top parade throughout the town centre, culminating in a balcony appearance at the Town Hall. My Mum and Dad insisted we went as they had done Sheffield proud, and we should and join in their achievement.
What do I do, I am 9 years old, fake a cold, throw myself downstairs, no I had to go.
We go there and being only about 3 foot tall, I was either on my Dad's shoulders or had my face buried in the crotch of some blue and white clad, defeat celebrating neanderthal.
There were thousands outside the Town Hall, tens or hundreds of thousands if you count like Wednesday fans count. I just had to feign enjoyment for a couple of hours and make a promise to myself that come the day we appear in and win the FA Cup that, that day in 1966 will be laid to rest forever. Little was I to know that day would never come and more than likely will not happen in my lifetime - and that is my disappointment and where I feel let down
So, I went home and scrubbed and scrubbed my face and hands with Brillo pad after Brillo pad, truth is the smell and the sounds, and the visions of that day have never left me.

Can it be classed as abuse by my Mum and Dad or were they just showing me what celebrating failure looks like then just imaging what celebrating real success would be feel like. I never talked about it with them I did not want them to see how much they had disappointed me

Having written all that, I don't feel any cleaner, no weight has been lifted off my shoulders, I suppose it won't until the ills of later life hit me
It’s good to talk. Sharing is the first step to absolution my friend.
 
Letting Ched Evans be tried in court when the season ended ( as John Terry was allowed to do over the Anton Ferdinand saga ) instead of being tried and jailed before the season ended depriving us of the few goals needed for us to go up……..or…. Ched not being naughty at all.
Does the accused have a choice as to when they are tried?
 
Not signing younger better players in an aging 74/75 squad. We were on the threshold to bigger things,but injuries and poor depth cost us.
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom