Hendo - Man of the Match

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Klanger

Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2009
Messages
157
Reaction score
507
Who thought last nights champagne moment was our fabulous goalies overhead kick/slice that he had to scramble to save?
 



The last two MOTM have been a bit of a farce really, shows you that the majority of voters are doing so on Twitter at home.

Henderson was very good last night, but how the MOTM could have come from anyone but one of the centre-backs is baffling.
It would be better just to go along with whoever Deadbat selects as MoM :)
 
Basham played the ball back to Henderson when he sliced it. He then parried it out with his hands, should that be an indirect free kick? You can't touch a back pass with your hands.

You could say that he swiped at the ball and therefore that's a different passage of play but if that's the case, GKs could just flick it up into their hands from their feet?
 
It was a great recovery but it was terrible judgement in the first place. It clearly wasn't a pass back, he should've collected it.

That was my reaction at the time too. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen us concede a free kick for a backpass – seen us win a couple, but not concede.
 
I didn't think it was a backpass live, but it was:



I thought it was a backpass, it never crossed my mind that it wasn't but I was on the Kop so i didn't have the best view.

Thanks for the video, I've been looking for a replay of the incident.
 
Something else I've just remembered from that video. What the fuck were they moaning about when the ball popped and McGoldrick picked it up? They seemed to think they should have the ball back, though they didn't have it in the first place.
 
Something else I've just remembered from that video. What the fuck were they moaning about when the ball popped and McGoldrick picked it up? They seemed to think they should have the ball back, though they didn't have it in the first place.
I was watching the Brentford iFollow stream, and the commentators were saying the same - that the ball shouldn’t have gone back to Henderson as Brentford had the ball. Still no idea what they were talking about.
 
I was watching the Brentford iFollow stream, and the commentators were saying the same - that the ball shouldn’t have gone back to Henderson as Brentford had the ball. Still no idea what they were talking about.

Romaine Sawyers for them even tried to take a throw in with the new ball, no idea where he'd got the idea from that it was their throw in.
 
Something else I've just remembered from that video. What the fuck were they moaning about when the ball popped and McGoldrick picked it up? They seemed to think they should have the ball back, though they didn't have it in the first place.

I thought they were asking for a booking for deliberate handball?
 



You could say that he swiped at the ball and therefore that's a different passage of play but if that's the case, GKs could just flick it up into their hands from their feet?

When the rule was made in 1992, they called that scenario a 'manufactured' backpass. I don't think that Henderson's miskick would fall into that category.
 
I thought they were asking for a booking for deliberate handball?

Yeah, I think they were arguing that flat ball or not McGoldrick stopped the play by picking it up and not the ref. Thought it was daft he didn't just punt it out and then tell the ref.

My understanding is that the ball becomes dead at the moment it goes flat. If it happens from a goal kick/corner/free kick then you retake, if it happens elsewhere it's a drop ball. But presumably it's up to players to signal to the ref rather than stop the game themselves, but then given you have physical evidence that the ball was already dead maybe that doesn't matter.
 
Basham played the ball back to Henderson when he sliced it. He then parried it out with his hands, should that be an indirect free kick? You can't touch a back pass with your hands.

You could say that he swiped at the ball and therefore that's a different passage of play but if that's the case, GKs could just flick it up into their hands from their feet?
Didn't Hendo head it away after the slice?
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom