Well, show me the absolute proof that the repeated selling of our best players and replacement with substandard disproves my theory.
Start with this:
"For the past three seasons, we have sold our best players at key moments in the campaign and not signed ones that have significantly altered our form or got us promoted"
Now show me I am wrong.
pommpey
I start with - show me the absolute proof that the board are happy for us to remain in this league and don't want us out of it? And don't give me rubbish about selling players, it's a business, all teams sell their best players regardless of if you're Sheffield United or Manchester United. (Speaking of Man Utd...one of biggest clubs in the world......I remember a certain Cristiano Ronaldo, not just the best player at Man Utd but arguably one of the best players in the World, being sold)
McDonald - was unexpected I admit that.
Maguire - open secret that he forced the clubs hand in getting a transfer otherwise he wouldn't have gone as this board rejected (yes that's REJECTED) the approaches from Hull and it was us, thanks to player power of wanting to actually move to a club in the premier league offering him more money that we then went crawling to Hull and asked if they still wanted to buy him (after they moved onto their other target whom they actually signed before Maguire went there).
Murphy - we did reject several bids last season. Murphy wanted to talk to the club who are in a higher division and who no doubt are in a position to offer better terms, which he took. If we then started playing the Maguire game, and he spat his dummy out, then where would we be? Another player forcing the club to sell him because he knows he can?
Let me each of those into normal working man/non-football terms.....
You do you job, you do it well, another company wants you to work for them. This company is bigger than the one you are currently at and conduct their business and work at higher levels, working for them would enable you to also work at a higher level, where you can showcase your talents and show how good you really are. In order to persuade you to join them (as if the lure of working at a larger company at a higher level isn't enough) they also offer to double/treble your wages.
What normal person turns that down? Other than those content with being big fish in very small puddles.
There is hardly any loyalty left in football these days.
You can't state that the circumstances of today are comparable to the last two seasons where we never replaced players in key players when they moved on (McDonald et al.). We have a players who can play in Murphy's position and the transfer window isn't closed so we may yet sign some more players. As I've said on another thread, if we went up this season no one will bat an eyelid that Murphy went.
Start your crying game on 1st September, and even more so afterwards if no one is brought in on loan, not yet, not at this early stage of the season.