Free Transfers?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?




Jadon sancho
Gerrimin
500k per goal commission only
If he bangs in 30 its worth it surely 🤣
 
Champagneblade said:
His wages can’t be that big. There isn’t going to be a clamour to sign someone with his record.

Call me cynical but I’d rather someone with slightly less overall capability but who will be available. If he’s coming in as back up there’s no point in him being there and injured. This is where a loan form Robbo starts to make a bit of sense. A shiver runs down my spine typing that last part. But things change. As 4th pick you know exactly what he can bring. Him in and Zatterstrom on loan and playing games makes sense.

I’m open to Webster but he needs to not be greedy and have the mother of all medicals.
Click to expand...
Robinson would make sense, whether people like it or not

I'd sign him regardless now

If you're in a possible battle to stay up do you want him in your squad or not - ask yourself that
 
3Cheers4Ramirez said:
Robinson would make sense, whether people like it or not

I'd sign him regardless now

If you're in a possible battle to stay up do you want him in your squad or not - ask yourself that
Click to expand...
Agreed … the more players that Wilder has this season who know exactly what he wants from them the better. Robbo is a fighter and we’re going to need that.
 
Can't see Robbo signing unless McGuiness leaves or Baptiste on loan. With Webster in that's 4 cb's in.
 
If Webster comes in (and there are no departures in the defensive positions) I think we'll have to go with what we have in that department. Until January and then see where we are.
All the other loans need to be used on creative players.
 
Down the Channels said:
If Webster comes in (and there are no departures in the defensive positions) I think we'll have to go with what we have in that department. Until January and then see where we are.
All the other loans need to be used on creative players.
Click to expand...
Think McGuinness deserves his chance to be fair.

He came in last season on deadline day and was thrown in by Selles against Ipswich. He's had a full preseason with us and i think he deserves his shot, he's played excellently in the first two games
 
I'd sign Robinson even if we sign Webster

Then decide on whether to loan out Baptiste or McGuinness - almost definitely Baptiste, hopefully to a top L1 side

But there's nothing wrong with carrying 5 CBs. Especially when one is an injury worry and one is unproven. It's just a question of budget I guess
 
Stipe Biuk a free agent, 23 years old and a left winger, potential high reward scenario if he performs, 6 foot tall too. Seems around what were looking at
 
ckpe147 said:
Think McGuinness deserves his chance to be fair.

He came in last season on deadline day and was thrown in by Selles against Ipswich. He's had a full preseason with us and i think he deserves his shot, he's played excellently in the first two games
Click to expand...
I'm definitely in the give McGuiness more time camp. Especially considering he's our player and has a further three years of his contract to run. He's a decent defender if we use him to his strengths and allow Tanganga to be the more athletic/covering runners in behind him. We'd have the same issue with Souttar too but our fans don't mention that.
 



Booker4 said:
I'm definitely in the give McGuiness more time camp. Especially considering he's our player and has a further three years of his contract to run. He's a decent defender if we use him to his strengths and allow Tanganga to be the more athletic/covering runners in behind him. We'd have the same issue with Souttar too but our fans don't mention that.
Click to expand...

I have never bought into the mcguiness is a donkey and terrible idea

I think he is a solid CB at this level probabaly better than that after a run of games him and tanganga is a goood pair at this level
 
Signings we should make loans and frees

Solly march or Ryan Kent left wing free
Fábio Carvalho on loan from Brentford to replace hamer
Axel tuanzebe free
Tyler Bindon Loan
Adebayo Free
 
McGuinness has impressed me in the first 2 games.
When you factor in that he knew a few weeks ago that he wasn't in the managers long term plans at that time, he has put the shirt on and played very, very well - fair play to him.
The clubs short term plans have clearly been impacted transfer wise, so I'd go with him.
He's got limitations, clearly, but so have we as a club at this moment in time.
Back him, he's our player and there are plenty worse out there.

I'd still bring another in on loan, absolutely. Whether that's Robinson or a young premier league kid from one of the top 10.

Our more pressing issue's are on both wings - we haven't got a single left winger in the squad, and on the right Donovan needs time to grow into the division and its demands (reminds me massively of McAtee when he first joined), and Chong is next to useless and can't stay fit.
 
Bladey_blade said:
Stipe Biuk a free agent, 23 years old and a left winger, potential high reward scenario if he performs, 6 foot tall too. Seems around what were looking at
Click to expand...

We can do the diagonal balls to him too like we used to do to Cresswell when he was on the wing.
 
Vass Borbokis said:
One of the greatest days in recent history was the day that Robinson left the cluib.

Birmingham fans DESPISE him.

And yet some of our fans want him back.
Jesus christ.
Click to expand...
Agreed, was a strong rumour around the play offs that Wilder would have played Holding over Robinson but knew that Robinson would disrupt training and boot balls everywhere if he wasn't playing
 
NathTheBlade said:
Signings we should make loans and frees

Solly march or Ryan Kent left wing free
Fábio Carvalho on loan from Brentford to replace hamer
Axel tuanzebe free
Tyler Bindon Loan
Adebayo Free
Click to expand...
When the frees are 32, 29, 28 and 28 the wages will be massive, and those names all add nothing but depth. That's bad general strategy and will leave us in a worse place than what a club that knows what they are doing will be when their contracts are done. Also, while Bindon did fine, not a fan of using loan spots on defenders, should be used on creative positions to get players we would not normally be able to obtain for a small percentage of what they would cost on a perm. Frankly we are not in a promotion window and were not even before this week's shenanigans, so if we are not bringing in much younger players who can rise in both value and quality, we should not be bringing in players at all.
 
WorksopBlade86 said:
McGuinness has impressed me in the first 2 games.
When you factor in that he knew a few weeks ago that he wasn't in the managers long term plans at that time, he has put the shirt on and played very, very well - fair play to him.
The clubs short term plans have clearly been impacted transfer wise, so I'd go with him.
He's got limitations, clearly, but so have we as a club at this moment in time.
Back him, he's our player and there are plenty worse out there.

I'd still bring another in on loan, absolutely. Whether that's Robinson or a young premier league kid from one of the top 10.

Our more pressing issue's are on both wings - we haven't got a single left winger in the squad, and on the right Donovan needs time to grow into the division and its demands (reminds me massively of McAtee when he first joined), and Chong is next to useless and can't stay fit.
Click to expand...
I think part of the issue for McGuiness is that Wilder like to press teams in and play a high line, which leaves an entire half of the pitch behind the defence and McGuiness isn't the fastest. We're often so vulnerable to teams on the counter because of the press in my view. However with Cooper in goal back to his best and McCullam back in and no Hamer I think we look more solid overall.

I think we may need to be slightly more defensive this season which would suit McGuiness but I don't expect major tactical changes by Wilder. When it works we play some great stuff but it's risk and reward as Wilder says but can be risk and conc!
 
calcalcal said:
Adebayo
Carvalho
And good old rabbie matondo
What's up with that. Nailed on mid table 👀
Click to expand...
I'll take that now fella. Mid table that is. And that's coming from someone who every season predicted play offs minimum in this league.

Id definitely be interested in Adebayo but probably only if Cannon leaves.
 



Vass Borbokis said:
One of the greatest days in recent history was the day that Robinson left the cluib.

Birmingham fans DESPISE him.

And yet some of our fans want him back.
Jesus christ.
Click to expand...
I think there is a a difference between wanting him back when you have multiple options and can pay fees compared to acknowledging we are shopping in a specific pool and he’s part of that pool and compared to others there may be a scenario when he isn’t the worst option.

For the record I was also heavily in favour of him leaving. But if we’re scratching around last minute and coming up blank and need an experienced back up then you’d take him over being short.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Ron_Justice
Free Agents - Wilders Wild Card.
2
Replies
38
Views
4K
Rufus Smalls
Rufus Smalls
Iffy Onuora's Shiny Head
Statistics 6 Years of SUFC Transfers
Replies
22
Views
2K
steve26272
steve26272
mattbianco1
Player Suggestion EFL Targets for 2025/26
2
Replies
53
Views
8K
Yogi
Yogi
MayorOJC
Life After Gus
2 3
Replies
72
Views
7K
finlaytheblade
F
MayorOJC
Out of Contract 2026
2 3
Replies
89
Views
11K
Slug
Slug

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom